3D打印患者特异性切除导板用于骨肿瘤切除的切除精度与导板贴合误差分析
回顾性分析29例基于3D CT和3D MRI的3D打印患者特异性切除导板(3DP-PSRG)骨肿瘤切除术,评估切除量误差与切除缘误差。最大切除量误差为2 mm,复杂切除术与更高级别切除量误差相关(p < 0.001);最大导板贴合误差为3 mm,术后一个月所有患者导板变形均为1级。作者认为3DP-PSRG在按术前计划实现准确切除量方面是可行选择,但可能存在切除缘长度与计划边缘的差异。
要点
- 29例骨肿瘤切除使用3DP-PSRG,最大切除量误差2 mm,最大导板贴合误差3 mm。
- 复杂切除术与更高级别切除量误差相关(p < 0.001),与贴合误差级别无显著关联。
- 术后一个月所有患者导板变形均为1级;作者认为3DP-PSRG是可行选择但需注意切除缘差异。
核心结论
- 就按术前计划实现准确切除量而言,3DP-PSRG可成为骨肿瘤切除的可行选择。
- 但3DP-PSRG使用可能与切除缘长度相对计划边缘的差异相关,确定手术边缘时应考虑此类差异。
- 因此即使使用3DP-PSRG,仍需要对术前影像和手术计划进行充分评估。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析29例使用基于3D CT和3D MRI的3DP-PSRG的骨肿瘤切除术。
- 评估相对于术前计划的切除量误差和切除缘误差,并分别于术中评估导板贴合误差、术后一个月评估导板变形。
- 将每种误差分为三级:1级< 1 mm,2级1至3 mm,3级> 3 mm,以评估总体精度。
主要发现
- 最大切除量误差为2 mm;29例切除量误差中15例(51.7%)为1级、14例(38.3%)为2级。
- 复杂切除术与更高级别切除量误差相关(p < 0.001)。
- 实际切除缘与计划边缘显著相关,但存在一些差异。
- 最大导板贴合误差为3 mm;导板贴合误差1级22例(75.9%)、2级5例(17.2%)、3级2例(6.9%)。
- 复杂切除术与贴合误差级别无显著关联;术后一个月所有患者导板变形均评为1级。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: This study aimed to analyze the accuracy and errors associated with 3D-printed, patient-specific resection guides (3DP-PSRGs) used for bone tumour resection. METHODS: We retrospectively reviewed 29 bone tumour resections that used 3DP-PSRGs based on 3D CT and 3D MRI. We evaluated the resection amount errors and resection margin errors relative to the preoperative plans. Guide-fitting errors and guide distortion were evaluated intraoperatively and one month postoperatively, respectively. We categorized each of these error types into three grades (grade 1, < 1 mm; grade 2, 1 to 3 mm; and grade 3, > 3 mm) to evaluate the overall accuracy. RESULTS: The maximum resection amount error was 2 mm. Out of 29 resection amount errors, 15 (51.7%) were grade 1 errors and 14 (38.3%) were grade 2 errors. Complex resections were associated with higher-grade resection amount errors (p < 0.001). The actual resection margins correlated significantly with the planned margins; however, there were some discrepancies. The maximum guide-fitting error was 3 mm. There were 22 (75.9%), five (17.2%), and two (6.9%) grade 1, 2, and 3 guide-fitting errors, respectively. There was no significant association between complex resection and fitting error grades. The guide distortion after one month in all patients was rated as grade 1. CONCLUSION: In terms of the accurate resection amount according to the preoperative planning, 3DP-PSRGs can be a viable option for bone tumour resection. However, 3DP-PSRG use may be associated with resection margin length discrepancies relative to the planned margins. Such discrepancies should be considered when determining surgical margins. Therefore, a thorough evaluation of the preoperative imaging and surgical planning is still required, even if 3DP-PSRGs are to be used.Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2023;105-B(2):190-197.
引用
- Lee SH, Kim W, Lee JS, et al. What are the resection accuracy and guide-fitting errors associated with 3D-printed, patient-specific resection guides for bone tumour resections? Bone Joint J. 2023. PMID: 36722060. doi:10.1302/0301-620X.105B2.BJJ-2022-0585.R2
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。