文献速递运动医学关节外科

精英运动员中全内技术与由内向外技术半月板修复的比较

A Comparison of All-inside and Inside-out Meniscal Repair in Elite Athletes.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Sports Med · 2023-02-06

本研究回顾性纳入2013年1月至2019年9月期间接受半月板修复的精英运动员192例(135例外侧、57例内侧),随访至少2年,比较全内(AI)与由内向外(IO)技术的失败率及失败时间。结果显示,内侧半月板AI修复失败率(18/31,58%)显著高于IO修复(6/26,23%)及外侧半月板AI(9/76,12%)或IO(8/59,14%)修复(P < .001);内侧半月板AI修复的失败风险约为外侧半月板AI修复的8倍(P < .001)。

要点

  • 内侧半月板AI修复失败率58%(18/31),显著高于IO修复23%(6/26)及外侧半月板修复。
  • 术后1年,外侧半月板修复失败率8%(无论技术),内侧IO修复16%,内侧AI修复42%。
  • 内侧半月板AI修复术后2年失败率53%,5年失败率63%。

核心结论

  • 在精英运动员中,内侧半月板AI修复的失败率高于内侧或外侧半月板的IO修复,内侧半月板修复失败率高于外侧半月板修复。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性队列研究,证据等级3级;纳入2013年1月至2019年9月期间接受半月板修复的全体职业及国家/国际级业余运动员,随访至少2年;根据手术技术分为AI或IO组;采用Cox比例风险模型分析失败率是否因半月板修复部位和技术而异,并控制年龄、性别、运动项目和合并交叉韧带重建等已知危险因素。

主要发现

  • 共完成192例精英运动员半月板修复(135例外侧、57例内侧),总体41例(21%)符合失败标准。
  • 内侧半月板AI修复失败18/31(58%),内侧半月板IO修复失败6/26(23%),外侧半月板AI修复失败9/76(12%),外侧半月板IO修复失败8/59(14%)(P < .001)。
  • Cox比例风险模型显示,内侧半月板AI修复的失败风险约为外侧半月板AI修复的8倍(P < .001)。
  • 术后1年,外侧半月板修复失败率8%(无论技术),内侧半月板IO修复失败率16%,内侧半月板AI修复失败率42%。
  • 术后2年,内侧半月板AI修复失败率53%;术后5年,失败率63%。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: The popularization of all-inside (AI) meniscal repair devices has led to a shift away from the historical gold standard of inside-out (IO) meniscal repair without comparative studies to support the change. PURPOSE: To compare the failure rate and time to failure of AI and IO meniscal repair performed in elite athletes. STUDY DESIGN: Cohort study; Level of evidence, 3. METHODS: A retrospective review was performed of all professional and national- and international-level amateur athletes who underwent meniscal repair, with a minimum of 2-year follow-up between January 2013 and September 2019. Meniscal repair was classified as AI or IO depending on the surgical technique performed. Treatment failure was defined as patients having to undergo subsequent surgery to address a persistent meniscal tear after repair. Cox proportional hazards modeling was used to determine if meniscal repair failure rates differed by the location and technique of meniscal repair. Models were controlled for known risk factors such as age, sex, sport, and concurrent cruciate ligament reconstruction. RESULTS: A total of 192 (135 lateral and 57 medial) meniscal repairs were performed in elite athletes during the study period. Overall, 41 (21%) meniscal repairs met the criteria for failure. Medial meniscal tears repaired with the AI technique failed at a significantly higher rate (18/31 [58%]) than medial meniscal tears repaired with the IO technique (6/26 [23%]) or lateral meniscal tears repaired with the AI (9/76 [12%]) or IO (8/59 [14%]) technique (P < .001). Cox proportional hazards modeling revealed that a medial meniscal tear repaired with the AI technique had an almost 8 times greater hazard of failure than a lateral meniscal tear repaired with the AI technique (P < .001). At 1 year postoperatively, 8% of lateral meniscal repairs had failed (regardless of technique), while medial meniscal tears failed at a rate of 16% with the IO technique and 42% with the AI technique. By 2 years, 53% of medial meniscal tears repaired with the AI technique had failed, and by 5 years, 63% had failed. CONCLUSION: AI repair of medial meniscal tears led to a higher rate of failure than IO repair of medial or lateral meniscal tears in elite athletes. Medial meniscal repair failed at a higher rate than lateral meniscal repair.

来源:Am J Sports Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Borque KA, Laughlin MS, Webster E, et al. A Comparison of All-inside and Inside-out Meniscal Repair in Elite Athletes. Am J Sports Med. 2023. PMID: 36745037. doi:10.1177/03635465221147058

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。