临床诊断的精神疾病与全关节置换术之间有何关联?一项评估结局、医疗资源使用和患者报告结局指标的系统综述
该系统综述纳入21项回顾性比较研究、共31,023,713例患者,评估临床诊断的精神疾病与全关节置换术(TJA)后并发症、再入院、医疗资源使用及患者报告结局指标(PROMs)的关联。结果显示精神疾病患者术后并发症风险、住院时间、费用、非居家出院及PROMs较差的风险增加,但焦虑与再入院率无差异。作者鼓励在风险分层时纳入合并精神疾病,并关注围手术期干预。
要点
- 精神分裂症患者医疗和手术并发症的比值 consistently 较高,尤其是贫血和呼吸系统并发症。
- 抑郁、精神分裂症和严重精神疾病患者TJA后再入院比值较高,但焦虑与无精神疾病患者相比再入院率无差异。
- 抑郁患者TJA后至少1年随访的PROM评分较差,焦虑患者与无精神疾病患者相比改善无差异。
核心结论
- 该系统综述发现精神疾病患者TJA后并发症风险增加、住院时间延长、费用更高、非居家出院更少且PROM评分更差。
- 作者认为这些发现鼓励在风险分层时纳入合并精神疾病,并关注围手术期干预以最小化血栓栓塞事件、贫血、出血和呼吸系统并发症风险,以及充分镇痛且不加剧上述不良事件风险的药物,以减少急诊就诊和再入院。
- 作者指出未来需要比较合并精神疾病(如抑郁和焦虑)患者与单一诊断患者的研究,以及认知行为疗法等靶向干预的结果,以了解骨科医生如何改善合并精神疾病患者的照护质量。
研究设计与样本
- 检索PubMed、EBSCO host、Medline和Google Scholar电子数据库,检索日期为2022年4月9日,纳入2000年1月1日至2022年4月1日期间发表的研究。
- 纳入标准为全文英文可用、报告临床诊断精神疾病患者初次TJA结局、包含无精神疾病TJA患者作为对照、再入院率评估至少随访30天、其他围手术期结局(如住院时间和并发症)至少随访90天、评估PROMs至少随访1年。
- 排除使用心理健康筛查检查而非临床诊断的研究、系统综述、病例报告、数据库间重复研究和灰色文献。
- 最终分析纳入21项研究,共31,023,713例患者,平均年龄范围57至69岁。
- 两位评审员独立使用非随机研究方法学指数(MINORS)工具评估纳入研究质量,平均MINORS评分为19.5 ± 0.91(满分24分),所有纳入文章均为回顾性比较研究;因异质性未进行Meta分析,结果以描述性方式呈现。
主要发现
- 精神分裂症患者医疗和手术并发症的比值 consistently 高于无精神疾病患者,尤其是贫血和呼吸系统并发症。
- 在样本量最大的研究中,单纯抑郁或抑郁合并焦虑患者并发症的比值略高。
- 大多数研究识别出抑郁、精神分裂症和严重精神疾病患者TJA后再入院的比值较高;然而焦虑与无精神疾病患者相比再入院率无差异。
- 抑郁、焦虑、抑郁合并焦虑及严重精神疾病患者在各项研究中报告急诊就诊的比值略高。
- 在报告抑郁与住院时间或出院去向的研究中,样本量最大的文章发现抑郁患者住院时间适度延长且非居家出院比值更高;尽管多项研究报告焦虑与住院总费用略增相关,但最稳健的研究报告无差异或平均住院时间略短;精神分裂症患者住院时间略长且居家出院和费用的比值适度降低;根据两项报告超过1000例患者的文章,抑郁合并焦虑患者平均住院时间略长;抑郁患者TJA后至少1年随访的PROM评分较差,焦虑患者与无精神疾病患者相比改善无差异。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为这些发现鼓励在风险分层时纳入合并精神疾病。
- 作者建议关注围手术期干预以最小化血栓栓塞事件、贫血、出血和呼吸系统并发症风险,以及充分镇痛且不加剧上述不良事件风险的药物,以减少急诊就诊和再入院。
局限性
- 所有纳入文章均为回顾性比较研究。
- 因纳入研究的异质性,未进行Meta分析,结果以描述性方式呈现。
- 纳入研究仅报告部分经济分析的费用,导致证据相对表浅。
- 未来需要比较合并精神疾病(如抑郁和焦虑)患者与单一诊断患者的研究,而不是仅将合并诊断患者与无任何精神疾病患者进行比较。
- 需要认知行为疗法等靶向干预的结果,以了解骨科医生如何改善合并精神疾病患者的照护质量。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Studies evaluating the effects of a psychiatric illness on orthopaedic surgical outcomes have yielded mixed results. Because awareness of patient comorbid mental health disorders has become increasingly important to tailor treatment plans, the aim of our systematic review was to present the findings of all studies reporting on the association between clinically diagnosed psychiatric illnesses and total joint arthroplasty (TJA) outcomes and evaluate the quality of evidence to provide a comprehensive summary. QUESTION/PURPOSE: Is there a consistently reported association between comorbid psychiatric illness and (1) complication risk, (2) readmission rates, (3) healthcare use and discharge disposition, and (4) patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) after TJA? METHODS: The PubMed, EBSCO host, Medline, and Google Scholar electronic databases were searched on April 9, 2022, to identify all studies that evaluated outcomes after TJA in patients with a comorbid clinically diagnosed mental health disorder between January 1, 2000, and April 1, 2022. Studies were included if the full-text article was available in English, reported on primary TJA outcomes in patients with clinically diagnosed mental health disorders, included patients undergoing TJA without a psychiatric illness for comparison, and had a minimum follow-up time of 30 days for evaluating readmission rates, 90 days for other perioperative outcomes such as length of stay and complications, and 1-year minimum follow-up if assessing PROMs. Studies that used a mental health screening examination instead of clinical diagnoses were excluded to isolate for verified psychiatric illnesses. Additionally, systematic reviews, case reports, duplicate studies between the databases, and gray literature were excluded. Twenty-one studies were included in our final analysis comprising 31,023,713 patients with a mean age range of 57 to 69 years. Mental health diagnoses included depression, anxiety, bipolar disorder, schizophrenia, major personality disorder, and psychosis as well as concomitant mental disorders. Two reviewers independently evaluated the quality of included studies using the Methodological Index for Nonrandomized Studies (MINORS) tool. The mean MINORS score was 19.5 ± 0.91 of 24, with higher scores representing better study quality. All the articles included were retrospective, comparative studies. Given the heterogeneity of the included studies, a meta-analysis was not performed, and results are instead presented descriptively. RESULTS: Patients with schizophrenia were consistently reported to have higher odds of medical and surgical complications than patients without psychiatric illness, particularly anemia and respiratory complications. Among studies with the largest sample sizes, patients with depression alone or depression and anxiety had slightly higher odds of complications. Most studies identified higher odds of readmission among patients with depression, schizophrenia, and severe mental illness after TJA. However, for anxiety, there was no difference in readmission rates compared with patients without psychiatric illness. Slightly higher odds of emergency department visits were reported for patients with depression, anxiety, concomitant depression and anxiety, and severe mental illness across studies. When evaluating healthcare use, articles with the largest sample sizes reporting on depression and length of stay or discharge disposition found modestly longer length of stay and greater odds of nonhome discharge among patients with depression. Although several studies reported anxiety was associated with slightly increased total costs of hospitalization, the most robust studies reported no difference or slightly shorter average length of stay. However, the included studies only reported partial economic analyses of cost, leading to relatively superficial evidence. Patients with schizophrenia had a slightly longer length of stay and modestly lower odds of home discharge and cost. Likewise, patients with concomitant depression and anxiety had a slightly longer average length of stay, according to the two articles reporting on more than 1000 patients. Lastly, PROM scores were worse in patients with depression at a minimum follow-up of 1 year after TJA. For anxiety, there was no difference in improvement compared with patients without mental illness. CONCLUSION: Our systematic review found that individuals with psychiatric illness had an increased risk of postoperative complications, increased length of stay, higher costs, less frequent home discharge, and worse PROM scores after TJA. These findings encourage inclusion of comorbid psychiatric illness when risk-stratifying patients. Attention should focus on perioperative interventions to minimize the risk of thromboembolic events, anemia, bleeding, and respiratory complications as well as adequate pain management with drugs that do not exacerbate the likelihood of these adverse events to minimize emergency department visits and readmissions. Future studies are needed to compare patients with concomitant psychiatric illnesses such as depression and anxiety with patients with either diagnosis in isolation, instead of only comparing patients with concomitant diagnoses with patients without any psychiatric illnesses. Similarly, the results of targeted interventions such as cognitive behavioral therapy are needed to understand how orthopaedic surgeons might improve the quality of care for patients with a comorbid psychiatric illness.
引用
- Hecht CJ, Burkhart RJ, Karimi AH, et al. What is the Association Between Clinically Diagnosed Psychiatric Illness and Total Joint Arthroplasty? A Systematic Review Evaluating Outcomes, Healthcare Use, and Patient-reported Outcome Measures. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2022. PMID: 36730492. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000002481
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。