单能与双能CT扫描参数联合金属伪影抑制算法对全髋关节置换术的影响:一项离体研究
这项离体研究将9根股骨柄(6根非骨水泥型、3根骨水泥型)在12种单能(SE)和单源连续双能(DE)CT协议下成像,比较有无迭代金属伪影抑制算法(iMAR)及单能重建对图像质量的影响。结果显示iMAR在所有方案中均显著减少条纹伪影(p=0.001至0.01),SE联合锡滤过器与iMAR的主观图像质量最佳。作者强烈建议临床使用金属伪影抑制算法。
要点
- iMAR在所有方案中均显著减少条纹伪影(p=0.001至0.01)。
- SE联合锡滤过器与iMAR的主观图像质量最佳。
- 作者强烈建议临床使用iMAR以改善骨-假体界面成像。
核心结论
- 这项离体研究强烈提示,对于非骨水泥型或骨水泥型股骨柄假体的骨-假体界面成像,临床实践中应使用金属伪影抑制算法(如iMAR)。
- 在iMAR方案中,140 kV联合锡滤过器的SE协议产生最佳主观图像质量。
- 该协议以及160和190 keV的DE单能重建联合iMAR达到最低水平的条纹和晕状伪影。
研究设计与样本
- 离体研究,9根股骨柄(6根非骨水泥型、3根骨水泥型)取自生前植入受试者,死后经解剖遗体捐献取出并检查。
- 比较12种CT协议,包括单能(SE)和单源连续双能(DE)扫描,有无迭代金属伪影抑制算法(iMAR;Siemens Healthineers)和/或单能重建。
- 对每种协议评估条纹伪影、晕状伪影和主观图像质量。
主要发现
- iMAR金属伪影抑制在所有研究方案中均显著减少条纹伪影(p=0.001至0.01)。
- 最佳主观图像质量见于SE联合锡滤过器与iMAR方案。
- 最少条纹伪影见于110、160和190 keV单能重建联合iMAR(CT值标准差分别为151.1、143.7、144.4)以及SE联合锡滤过器与iMAR(163.5)。
- 最小虚拟增长见于SE联合锡滤过器无iMAR(4.40 mm)和190 keV单能重建无iMAR(4.67 mm)。
关键数值与推荐
- 证据等级:诊断性研究III级。
- iMAR在所有方案中减少条纹伪影的p值为0.001至0.01。
- 最佳主观图像质量:SE联合锡滤过器与iMAR。
- 最少条纹伪影(CT值标准差):110 keV单能重建联合iMAR为151.1,160 keV为143.7,190 keV为144.4,SE联合锡滤过器与iMAR为163.5。
- 最小虚拟增长:SE联合锡滤过器无iMAR为4.40 mm,190 keV单能重建无iMAR为4.67 mm。
临床怎么用
- 作者强烈建议临床实践中对非骨水泥型或骨水泥型股骨柄假体的骨-假体界面成像使用金属伪影抑制算法(如iMAR)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Metal artifacts caused by hip arthroplasty stems limit the diagnostic value of computed tomography (CT) in the evaluation of periprosthetic fractures or implant loosening. The aim of this ex vivo study was to evaluate the influence of different scan parameters and metal artifact algorithms on image quality in the presence of hip stems. METHODS: Nine femoral stems, 6 uncemented and 3 cemented, that had been implanted in subjects during their lifetimes were exarticulated and investigated after death and anatomical body donation. Twelve CT protocols consisting of single-energy (SE) and single-source consecutive dual-energy (DE) scans with and without an iterative metal artifact reduction algorithm (iMAR; Siemens Healthineers) and/or monoenergetic reconstructions were compared. Streak and blooming artifacts as well as subjective image quality were evaluated for each protocol. RESULTS: Metal artifact reduction with iMAR significantly reduced the streak artifacts in all investigated protocols (p = 0.001 to 0.01). The best subjective image quality was observed for the SE protocol with a tin filter and iMAR. The least streak artifacts were observed for monoenergetic reconstructions of 110, 160, and 190 keV with iMAR (standard deviation of the Hounsfield units: 151.1, 143.7, 144.4) as well as the SE protocol with a tin filter and iMAR (163.5). The smallest virtual growth was seen for the SE with a tin filter and without iMAR (4.40 mm) and the monoenergetic reconstruction of 190 keV without iMAR (4.67 mm). CONCLUSIONS: This study strongly suggests that metal artifact reduction algorithms (e.g., iMAR) should be used in clinical practice for imaging of the bone-implant interface of prostheses with either an uncemented or cemented femoral stem. Among the iMAR protocols, the SE protocol with 140 kV and a tin filter produced the best subjective image quality. Furthermore, this protocol and DE monoenergetic reconstructions of 160 and 190 keV with iMAR achieved the lowest levels of streak and blooming artifacts. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Diagnostic Level III . See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.
引用
- Schwarz GM, Huber S, Wassipaul C, et al. Influence of Scan Parameters of Single and Dual-Energy CT Protocols in Combination with Metal Artifact Suppression Algorithms for THA: An ex Vivo Study. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2023. PMID: 36848437. doi:10.2106/JBJS.22.01003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。