德国手术使用模型预测75岁及以上患者脊柱融合术数量上升将挑战全球医疗系统
基于德国联邦统计局2005至2019年全国手术数据,采用自回归积分滑动平均模型预测至2060年后路脊柱融合术的使用趋势。模型显示,2060年每10万居民发生率为102例(95%CI 71至133),较当前增加约83%(95%CI 28%至139%);75岁及以上患者手术量从2019年的14657例增至2060年的38974例(95%CI 27294至50653)。作者认为若当前趋势持续,该增长将挑战全球医疗系统。
要点
- 预测至2060年,德国后路脊柱融合术每10万居民发生率将增至102例(95%CI 71至133),增加约83%(95%CI 28%至139%)。
- 75岁及以上患者手术量从2019年14657例增至2060年38974例(95%CI 27294至50653),其中女性增加246%(95%CI 138%至355%),男性增加296%(95%CI 222%至370%)。
- 55岁以下所有年龄组的手术量预计至2060年保持稳定甚至下降趋势。
核心结论
- 作者认为,若当前趋势持续,后路脊柱融合术使用增加尤其是75岁及以上患者,将挑战全球医疗系统。
- 作者认为,本研究可作为许多面临相似人口与手术发展趋势的其他工业化国家的模型。
- 作者强调需要关注衰弱研究以及适当的财政和人力资源管理。
- 作者认为,有效的围手术期医疗管理、多学科治疗和跨机构协议是必要的,尤其是在老年患者中。
研究设计与样本
- 基于德国联邦统计局提供的全国数据,量化后路脊柱融合术发生率与日历年、年龄和性别的关系。
- 采用自回归积分滑动平均模型,基于2005至2019年历史手术率与2020至2060年官方人口预测,预测未来绝对数量和发生率。
- 证据等级为III级,经济与决策分析。
主要发现
- 预测2060年后路脊柱融合术发生率为每10万居民102例(95%CI 71至133),较当前增加约83%(95%CI 28%至139%)。
- 绝对数量上女性接受手术的比率高1.3倍。
- 75岁及以上患者2060年预测后路脊柱融合术38974例(95%CI 27294至50653),而2019年为14657例。
- 75岁及以上女性后路脊柱融合术总数增加246%(95%CI 138%至355%),男性增加296%(95%CI 222%至370%)。
- 55岁以下所有年龄组后路脊柱融合术预计至2060年呈稳定甚至负增长趋势。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 长期预测比短期预测更容易受到意外干扰。
- 缺乏关于后路脊柱融合术未来趋势的证据。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Spinal fusion is a well-established procedure in the treatment of degenerative spinal diseases. Previous research shows that the use of this operative treatment has been growing in recent decades in industrialized countries and has become one of the most cost-intensive surgical procedures. It seems that in some countries such as Germany-with its large, industrialized, European population-this increase is mainly driven by demographic changes with low fertility rates, increasing life expectancy, and an aging population. Based on current projections, however, Germany faces a population trend that many other countries are likely to follow within a few decades. An increasingly shrinking and aging working population may eventually put the healthcare system under enormous pressure, with greater demands for spinal fusions and associated higher costs. Thus, we aimed to provide reliable projections regarding the future demand for posterior spinal fusion procedures including age- and gender-related trends up to 2060, which will be necessary for future resource planning and possible improvements in actual treatment strategies. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) How is the use of posterior spinal fusions in Germany expected to change from 2019 through 2060, if currents trends continue? (2) How is the use of posterior spinal fusions in Germany expected to change depending on patients' age and gender during this time period? METHODS: Comprehensive nationwide data provided by the Federal Statistical Office, the official institution for documenting all data on operations and procedures performed in Germany, were used to quantify posterior spinal fusion rates as a function of calendar year, age, and gender. Because there is a lack of evidence regarding future trends in the use of posterior spinal fusions, an autoregressive integrated moving average model on historical procedure rates from 2005 to 2019 in relation to official population projections from 2020 to 2060 was chosen to forecast future absolute numbers and incidence rates of this procedure in Germany. Long-term forecasting is more prone to unexpected disruptions than forecasting over short-term periods; however, longer spans facilitate estimates of how trends may challenge future healthcare systems if those trends continue, and thus are useful for research and planning. RESULTS: The incidence rate of posterior spinal fusion was projected to increase by approximately 83% (95% CI 28% to 139%) to 102% per 100,000 inhabitants (95% CI 71% to 133%) in 2060, with a 1.3-fold higher rate of women undergoing surgery in terms of absolute numbers. The highest increase identified by the model occurred in patients 75 years and older with 38,974 (95% CI 27,294 to 50,653) posterior spinal fusions in 2060, compared with 14,657 in 2019. This trend applied for both women and men, with a 246% (95% CI 138% to 355%) increase in the total number of posterior spinal fusions for women 75 years and older and a 296% (95% CI 222% to 370%) increase for men 75 years and older. At the same time, posterior spinal fusions in all age groups younger than 55 years were projected to follow a constant or even negative trend up to 2060. CONCLUSION: Our findings suggest that increasing use of posterior spinal fusion, particularly in patients 75 years and older, will challenge healthcare systems worldwide if current trends persist. This study may serve as a model for many other industrialized countries facing similar demographic and procedure-specific developments in the future. This emphasizes the need to focus on frailty research as well as appropriate financial and human resource management. Effective perioperative medical management, multidisciplinary treatment, and interinstitutional protocols are warranted, especially in older patients as we attempt to manage these trends in the future. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, economic and decision analysis.
引用
- Heck VJ, Klug K, Prasse T, et al. Projections From Surgical Use Models in Germany Suggest a Rising Number of Spinal Fusions in Patients 75 Years and Older Will Challenge Healthcare Systems Worldwide. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2023. PMID: 36779601. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000002576
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。