择期脊柱手术中抗凝/抗血小板药物管理及静脉血栓栓塞预防:基于改良德尔菲法的简明临床推荐
该改良德尔菲法研究邀请21名脊柱外科医生,20名完成全部三轮问卷,就择期脊柱手术抗凝/抗血小板药物停用与重启时机及静脉血栓栓塞化学预防达成26/27项共识。共识推荐直接口服抗凝药术前停用2天、华法林停用5天、其余抗凝/抗血小板药及阿司匹林停用7天,并给出基于风险分层的重启与预防时点。
要点
- 直接口服抗凝药术前停用2天,华法林停用5天,其余抗凝/抗血小板药及阿司匹林停用7天。
- 术后重启抗凝/抗血小板药物按低/中/高危分别为术后第7/5/2天。
- 静脉血栓栓塞化学预防低阈值/中阈值/高阈值范围分别为术后第5天或无/术后第3-4天/术后第1-2天。
核心结论
- 20名脊柱外科医生就择期脊柱手术抗凝/抗血小板药物管理及静脉血栓栓塞化学预防的26/27项条目达成共识(共识定义为>70%同意)。
- 这些共识推荐可能有助于标准化成人择期脊柱手术术前抗凝/抗血小板药物管理及术后静脉血栓栓塞化学预防。
研究设计与样本
- 采用改良德尔菲法进行共识制定,共三轮(2021年1月26日至2021年6月21日)。
- 邀请21名脊柱外科医生,20名完成全部轮次问卷。
- 共识定义为>70%同意,26/27项条目达成共识。
主要发现
- 术前停药共识:直接口服抗凝药术前停用2天,华法林停用5天,其余抗凝/抗血小板药物及阿司匹林停用7天。
- 术后重启抗凝/抗血小板药物共识:低/中/高危患者的阈值分别为术后第7天/术后第5天/术后第2天,5/5项风险因素(静脉血栓栓塞史/心脏/行走状态/前路手术/手术)达成共识。
- 静脉血栓栓塞化学预防共识:低阈值/中阈值/高阈值范围分别为术后第5天或无/术后第3-4天/术后第1-2天,12/13项风险因素(年龄/体重指数/静脉血栓栓塞史/心脏/癌症/激素治疗/手术/前路手术/分期不同日/分期同日/手术时间/输血)达成共识。
- 唯一未达成共识的领域为同日分期手术。
- 其他达成共识的静脉血栓栓塞化学预防考虑:术后第1天定义为手术次日早晨无论手术结束时间,依诺肝素为首选药物,采用标准化而非基于体重的剂量每日一次。
关键数值与推荐
- 术前直接口服抗凝药停用2天,华法林停用5天,其余抗凝/抗血小板药物及阿司匹林停用7天。
- 术后重启抗凝/抗血小板药物:低危患者术后第7天,中危患者术后第5天,高危患者术后第2天。
- 静脉血栓栓塞化学预防:低阈值术后第5天或无,中阈值术后第3-4天,高阈值术后第1-2天。
- 静脉血栓栓塞化学预防药物选择依诺肝素,采用标准化剂量每日一次,术后第1天定义为手术次日早晨。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
STUDY DESIGN: Delphi method. OBJECTIVE: To gain consensus on the following questions: (1) When should anticoagulation/antiplatelet (AC/AP) medication be stopped before elective spine surgery?; (2) When should AC/AP medication be restarted after elective spine surgery?; (3) When, how, and in whom should venous thromboembolism (VTE) chemoprophylaxis be started after elective spinal surgery? SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: VTE can lead to significant morbidity after adult spine surgery, yet postoperative VTE prophylaxis practices vary considerably. The management of preoperative AC/AP medication is similarly heterogeneous. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Delphi method of consensus development consisting of three rounds (January 26, 2021, to June 21, 2021). RESULTS: Twenty-one spine surgeons were invited, and 20 surgeons completed all rounds of questioning. Consensus (>70% agreement) was achieved in 26/27 items. Group consensus stated that preoperative Direct Oral Anticoagulants should be stopped two days before surgery, warfarin stopped five days before surgery, and all remaining AC/AP medication and aspirin should be stopped seven days before surgery. For restarting AC/AP medication postoperatively, consensus was achieved for low-risk/medium-risk/high-risk patients in 5/5 risk factors (VTE history/cardiac/ambulation status/anterior approach/operation). The low/medium/high thresholds were POD7/POD5/POD2, respectively. For VTE chemoprophylaxis, consensus was achieved for low-risk/medium-risk/high-risk patients in 12/13 risk factors (age/BMI/VTE history/cardiac/cancer/hormone therapy/operation/anterior approach/staged separate days/staged same days/operative time/transfusion). The one area that did not gain consensus was same-day staged surgery. The low-threshold/medium-threshold/high-threshold ranges were postoperative day 5 (POD5) or none/POD3-4/POD1-2, respectively. Additional VTE chemoprophylaxis considerations that gained consensus were POD1 defined as the morning after surgery regardless of operating finishing time, enoxaparin as the medication of choice, and standardized, rather than weight-based, dose given once per day. CONCLUSIONS: In the first known Delphi study to address anticoagulation/antiplatelet recommendations for elective spine surgery (preoperatively and postoperatively); our Delphi consensus recommendations from 20 spine surgeons achieved consensus on 26/27 items. These results will potentially help standardize the management of preoperative AC/AP medication and VTE chemoprophylaxis after adult elective spine surgery.
引用
- Zuckerman SL, Berven S, Streiff MB, et al. Management of Anticoagulation/Antiplatelet Medication and Venous Thromboembolism Prophylaxis in Elective Spine Surgery: Concise Clinical Recommendations Based on a Modified Delphi Process. Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 2022. PMID: 36730667. doi:10.1097/BRS.0000000000004540
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。