高肩峰坡度与低肩肱间距增加肩袖修复后冈上肌腱再撕裂风险
本研究回顾性分析55例接受双排修复的冈上肌腱全层撕裂患者,随访至少2年。结果显示肩肱间距(调整OR 0.9)和肩峰坡度(调整OR 1.4)与再撕裂风险相关,临界值分别为7.4 mm和24.5°;肩胛盂倾斜角和版本与再撕裂无关联。推荐临床术前测量肩肱间距和肩峰坡度。
要点
- 肩肱间距小于7.4 mm者再撕裂OR为11(95%CI 2-46),肩峰坡度大于24.5°者OR为9(95%CI 2-46)。
- 肩胛盂倾斜角和版本在有再撕裂与无再撕裂组间无显著差异。
- 作者推荐在冈上肌腱修复术前测量肩肱间距和肩峰坡度。
核心结论
- 术前肩肱间距和肩峰坡度与冈上肌腱修复后再撕裂相关。
- 临界肩角、肩峰倾斜角、肩峰指数和肩峰外侧角与术后转归无关联。
- 肩胛盂倾斜角和版本与再撕裂率无关。
- 作者推荐临床中对接受冈上肌腱修复的患者详细分析肩肱间距和肩峰坡度。
- 作者认为外科医生在术前应测量肩肱间距和肩峰坡度,尤其在计划行肩峰成形术时。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析2012年8月至2015年12月治疗的92例冈上肌腱撕裂患者,最终纳入55例(60%)接受双排修复且随访至少2年的患者。
- 术后MRI随访平均2.3±0.4年,所有患者完成西安大略肩袖指数和牛津肩关节评分。
- 术前X线片和MRI测量肩峰形态及肩胛盂方向参数,术后MRI评估肌腱完整性和质量。
- 采用二项对数回归分析,并用受试者工作特征曲线确定临界值。
主要发现
- 控制肩峰成形术、术前脂肪浸润和肌肉萎缩等混杂因素后,与再撕裂风险相关的形态学参数为肩肱间距(调整OR 0.9 [95%CI 0.9-0.99];p<0.01)和肩峰坡度(调整OR 1.4 [95%CI 1.1-1.8];p<0.01)。
- 肩肱间距小于7.4 mm者再撕裂OR为11(95%CI 2-46;p=0.01),肩峰坡度大于24.5°者OR为9(95%CI 2-46;p=0.04)。
- 肩胛盂倾斜角在无再撕裂组为6°±4° vs 再撕裂组6°±3°,平均差0.8°(-1°至3°;p<0.48),无显著差异。
- 肩胛盂版本在无再撕裂组为-2°±3° vs 再撕裂组-3°±3°,平均差1°(-1°至3°;p<0.30),无显著差异。
- 西安大略肩袖指数在无再撕裂组为98±2 vs 再撕裂组97±3,平均差0.73(95%CI -0.30至0.31;p=0.96),无显著差异;牛津肩关节评分无再撕裂组26±13 vs 再撕裂组23±10,平均差2.80(95%CI -4.12至9.72;p=0.41),无显著差异。
关键数值与推荐
- 肩峰坡度临界值为24.5°,肩肱间距临界值为7.4 mm。
- 肩肱间距小于7.4 mm或肩峰坡度大于24.5°的患者再撕裂风险更高(肩肱间距:OR 11 [95%CI 2-46];肩峰坡度:OR 9 [95%CI 2-46])。
- 作者推荐在临床中对接受冈上肌腱修复的患者详细分析肩肱间距和肩峰坡度。
- 作者认为外科医生在术前应测量肩肱间距和肩峰坡度,尤其在计划行肩峰成形术时。
临床怎么用
- 作者推荐临床中对接受冈上肌腱修复的患者详细分析肩肱间距和肩峰坡度。
- 作者认为外科医生在术前应测量肩肱间距和肩峰坡度,尤其在计划行肩峰成形术时。
- 作者建议未来研究应探讨肩峰成形术在肩峰坡度或肩肱间距异常患者中的作用,并明确更彻底的肩峰成形术能否降低再撕裂风险。
局限性
- 本研究为回顾性研究。
- 92例患者中仅55例(60%)纳入最终分析。
- 作者建议未来研究应探讨肩峰成形术在肩峰坡度或肩肱间距异常患者中的作用,并明确更彻底的肩峰成形术能否降低再撕裂风险。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Retearing of the supraspinatus (SSP) tendon after repair is relatively common, but its cause is rarely clear. Although the role of acromion morphology and glenoid orientation in the pathogenesis of primary SSP tendon tears have frequently been analyzed, their association with the risk of rerupture of a repaired SSP tendon is poorly understood. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) Is acromial morphology associated with the risk of retear after SSP tendon repair? (2) Is there an association between inclination and version of the glenoid and the odds for retear of the SSP tendon after repair? (3) Are there differences in outcome scores between patients who had intact cuff repairs and those who had retears? METHODS: Between August 2012 and December 2015, we treated 92 patients for SSP tendon tears; all of these patients were considered for inclusion in the present study. We considered patients with complete tear of the SSP that was reconstructed with a double-row repair and a minimum follow-up of 2 years as potentially eligible. Based on these criteria, 28% (26 of 92) were excluded because they had a partial rupture and did not receive a double-row reconstruction. A further 9% (eight of 92) were excluded because of missing planes or slices (such as sagittal, axial, or frontal) on MRI, and another 3% (three of 92) were lost before the minimum study follow-up interval or had incomplete datasets, leaving 60% (55 of 92) for inclusion in the present analysis. All included patients had a minimum follow-up of 2 years; follow-up with MRI occurred at a mean duration of 2.3 ± 0.4 years postoperatively. All patients were asked to complete the Western Ontario Rotator Cuff Index and Oxford Shoulder Scores, and they underwent MRI of the operated-on shoulder. Preoperative true AP radiographs and MR images of the affected shoulders were retrospectively assessed by measuring the acromiohumeral interval, critical shoulder angle, acromial slope, acromial tilt, acromial index, lateral acromial angle, and glenoid version and inclination. The patients also underwent acromioplasty, in which the underface of the acromion was flattened. To rule out any change in the above parameters because of acromioplasty, these parameters were compared using preoperative and postoperative MR images and showed no difference. In addition, the tendon integrity and quality on postoperative MRI were analyzed independently of one another by the same two observers using the Sugaya and Castricini classifications, accounting for atrophy and fatty degeneration of the SSP muscle. To assess interobserver reliability, the two observers took measurements independently from each other. They were orthopaedic residents who completed a training session before taking the measurements. All measurements had excellent intrarater (Cronbach alpha 0.996 [95% confidence interval (CI) 0.99 to 1.00; p > 0.01) and interrater (interrater correlation coefficient 0.975 [95% CI 0.97 to 0.98]; p > 0.01) reliabilities. To answer the study's first question, SSP integrity on postoperative MRI was compared with acromial morphologic parameters measured on preoperative AP radiographs and MR images. To answer the second question, the postoperative integrity and quality of the SSP tendon were correlated with glenoid inclination and glenoid version. To answer our third question, we compared outcome scores between patients with intact SSP tendons and those with reruptured SSP tendons. To investigate any correlation among the acromial morphology, glenoid orientation, and postoperative outcomes, a binomial logarithmic regression analysis was performed. Receiver operating characteristic curves were used to determine cutoff points for the radiologic parameters that showed a correlation in the binomial regression analysis. RESULTS: After controlling for potentially confounding variables such as acromioplasty or preoperative fatty infiltration as well as muscle atrophy, the only morphological parameters associated with a higher risk (adjusted odds ratio) of SSP tendon rerupture were the acromiohumeral interval (adjusted OR 0.9 [95% CI 0.9 to 0.99]; p < 0.01) and acromial slope (adjusted OR 1.4 [95% CI 1.1 to 1.8]; p < 0.01). The critical shoulder angle, acromial tilt, acromial index, and lateral acromial angle were not associated with the risk of rerupture. The cutoff values for acromial slope and acromiohumeral interval were 24.5° and 7.4 mm, respectively. Patients with an acromiohumeral interval smaller than 7.4 mm or an acromial slope greater than 24.5° had higher odds (acromiohumeral interval: OR 11 [95% CI 2 to 46]; p = 0.01 and acromial slope: OR 9 [95% CI 2 to 46]; p = 0.04) for rerupture of the SSP. No difference was found between patients with intact SSP tendons and those with reruptured SSP tendons in terms of glenoid inclination (6° ± 4° versus 6° ± 3°, mean difference 0.8° [-1° to 3°]; p < 0.48) and glenoid version (-2° ± 3° versus -3° ± 3°, mean difference 1° [-1° to 3°]; p < 0.30). No difference was found between the intact and reruptured SSP groups regarding clinical outcomes (Western Ontario Rotator Cuff Index: 98 ± 2 versus 97 ± 3, mean difference 0.73 [95% CI -0.30 to 0.31]; p = 0.96; Oxford Shoulder Score: 26 ± 13 versus 23 ± 10, mean difference 2.80 [95% CI -4.12 to 9.72]; p = 0.41). CONCLUSION: The preoperative acromiohumeral interval and acromial slope are associated with SSP tendon rerupture after repair. Conversely, the critical shoulder angle, acromial tilt, lateral acromial angle, and acromial index had no association with the postoperative outcome. Additionally, glenoid inclination and version were not associated with the rerupture rate after SSP tendon repair. A detailed analysis of the acromiohumeral interval and acromial slope is recommended in clinical practice in patients undergoing SSP tendon repair. Surgeons should consider measuring the acromiohumeral interval and acromial slope preoperatively when performing SSP repair, especially in the context of planned acromioplasties. Future studies should investigate the role of acromioplasty during SSP repair in patients with a pathologic acromial slope and acromiohumeral interval. In this context, it should be determined whether a more-radical acromioplasty could reduce the risk of rerupture of the SSP in these patients. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, therapeutic study.
引用
- Caffard T, Kralewski D, Ludwig M, et al. High Acromial Slope and Low Acromiohumeral Distance Increase the Risk of Retear of the Supraspinatus Tendon After Repair. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2022. PMID: 36623210. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000002520
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。