使用3D打印模型识别肘部复杂骨折模式
本研究纳入15名骨科创伤外科医生(7名初级、8名高级),对20例复杂肘部骨折进行模式识别评估。结果显示,额外使用3D打印模型后,整体模式识别准确率从0.62显著提高至0.69(Δ=0.07,95%CI 0.00-0.14,p=0.025),可靠性κ值从0.41提高至0.59(Δ=0.18,95%CI 0.14-0.22,p≤0.001)。初级医生在可靠性改善方面优于高级医生(κ=0.65 vs 0.54,Δ=0.11,95%CI 0.04-0.18,p=0.002)。作者认为3D打印模型可显著提高识别复杂肘部骨折模式的准确性和可靠性,但当前打印时间长和材料不可重复使用可能限制其临床应用,可作为可重复使用的工具用于住院医师教学。
要点
- 3D打印模型使整体模式识别准确率从0.62提高至0.69(Δ=0.07,95%CI 0.00-0.14,p=0.025)。
- 3D打印模型使模式识别可靠性κ值从0.41提高至0.59(Δ=0.18,95%CI 0.14-0.22,p≤0.001)。
- 初级医生使用3D打印模型后可靠性改善大于高级医生(κ=0.65 vs 0.54,Δ=0.11,95%CI 0.04-0.18,p=0.002)。
核心结论
- 使用3D打印模型显著提高了识别肘部复杂骨折模式的准确性和可靠性。
- 当前打印时间长和材料不可重复使用可能限制3D打印模型在临床实践中的实用性。
- 3D打印模型可作为可重复使用的工具用于住院医师教学。
研究设计与样本
- 本研究为评估3D打印模型对复杂肘部骨折模式识别影响的研究,共纳入15名骨科创伤外科医生(7名初级、8名高级),评估20例复杂肘部骨折。
- 医生首先基于X线片及二维和三维CT扫描评估骨折,一个月后额外使用3D打印模型进行第二轮评估。
- 计算每次评估的诊断准确率(acc)和医生间可靠性(κ)。
主要发现
- 整体模式识别准确率:二维/三维CT组0.62 vs 3D打印模型组0.69(Δ=0.07,95%CI 0.00-0.14,p=0.025)。
- 整体模式识别可靠性:二维/三维CT组κ=0.41(中等)vs 3D打印模型组κ=0.59(中等)(Δ=0.18,95%CI 0.14-0.22,p≤0.001)。
- 使用3D打印模型时,初级与高级医生准确率相当:初级0.70 vs 高级0.68(Δ=-0.02,95%CI -0.17-0.13,p=0.904)。
- 不使用3D打印模型时,初级与高级医生可靠性相当:初级κ=0.39(一般)vs 高级κ=0.43(中等)(Δ=0.03,95%CI -0.03-0.10,p=0.318)。
- 使用3D打印模型时,初级医生可靠性改善大于高级医生:初级κ=0.65(显著)vs 高级κ=0.54(中等)(Δ=0.11,95%CI 0.04-0.18,p=0.002)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为3D打印模型可显著提高识别复杂肘部骨折模式的准确性和可靠性。
- 作者指出当前打印时间长和材料不可重复使用可能限制3D打印模型在临床实践中的实用性。
- 作者认为3D打印模型可作为可重复使用的工具用于住院医师教学。
局限性
- 当前打印时间长和材料不可重复使用可能限制3D打印模型在临床实践中的实用性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: This study aimed to answer the following questions: do 3D-printed models lead to a more accurate recognition of the pattern of complex fractures of the elbow?; do 3D-printed models lead to a more reliable recognition of the pattern of these injuries?; and do junior surgeons benefit more from 3D-printed models than senior surgeons? METHODS: A total of 15 orthopaedic trauma surgeons (seven juniors, eight seniors) evaluated 20 complex elbow fractures for their overall pattern (i.e. varus posterior medial rotational injury, terrible triad injury, radial head fracture with posterolateral dislocation, anterior (trans-)olecranon fracture-dislocation, posterior (trans-)olecranon fracture-dislocation) and their specific characteristics. First, fractures were assessed based on radiographs and 2D and 3D CT scans; and in a subsequent round, one month later, with additional 3D-printed models. Diagnostic accuracy (acc) and inter-surgeon reliability (κ) were determined for each assessment. RESULTS: Accuracy significantly improved with 3D-printed models for the whole group on pattern recognition (acc2D/3D = 0.62 vs acc3Dprint= 0.69; Δacc = 0.07 (95% confidence interval (CI) 0.00 to 0.14); p = 0.025). A significant improvement was also seen in reliability for pattern recognition with the additional 3D-printed models (κ2D/3D = 0.41 (moderate) vs κ3Dprint = 0.59 (moderate); Δκ = 0.18 (95% CI 0.14 to 0.22); p ≤ 0.001). Accuracy was comparable between junior and senior surgeons with the 3D-printed model (accjunior = 0.70 vs accsenior = 0.68; Δacc = -0.02 (95% CI -0.17 to 0.13); p = 0.904). Reliability was also comparable between junior and senior surgeons without the 3D-printed model (κjunior = 0.39 (fair) vs κsenior = 0.43 (moderate); Δκ = 0.03 (95% CI -0.03 to 0.10); p = 0.318). However, junior surgeons showed greater improvement regarding reliability than seniors with 3D-printed models (κjunior = 0.65 (substantial) vs κsenior = 0.54 (moderate); Δκ = 0.11 (95% CI 0.04 to 0.18); p = 0.002). CONCLUSION: The use of 3D-printed models significantly improved the accuracy and reliability of recognizing the pattern of complex fractures of the elbow. However, the current long printing time and non-reusable materials could limit the usefulness of 3D-printed models in clinical practice. They could be suitable as a reusable tool for teaching residents.Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2023;105-B(1):56-63.
引用
- de Klerk HH, Oosterhoff JHF, Schoolmeesters B, et al. Recognition of the pattern of complex fractures of the elbow using 3D-printed models. Bone Joint J. 2023. PMID: 36587260. doi:10.1302/0301-620X.105B1.BJJ-2022-0415.R2
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。