髋与膝是最常涉诉的骨科病例:全国性5年医疗过失索赔分析
该研究查询全国数据库获取2015至2020年17个州的164例骨科医疗过失索赔,分析各亚专科涉诉频率、赔偿与过失主张、案件结局及防御性判决相关因素。结果显示髋与膝病例占比最高(n=49,29.9%),其中防御性判决38例(77.6%),原告判决9例(18.4%,平均赔偿4,866,929美元),和解2例(4.1%,平均和解金1,550,000美元);不可逆损害(如瘫痪、截肢、死亡;P<.001)与防御性结局可能性降低相关。
要点
- 髋与膝病例在骨科医疗过失诉讼中占比最高(n=49,29.9%)。
- 髋与膝案件中防御性判决占77.6%,原告判决占18.4%,和解占4.1%。
- 不可逆损害(如瘫痪、截肢、死亡;P<.001)与防御性判决可能性降低相关。
核心结论
- 髋与膝病例在骨科医疗过失诉讼中占比最高。
- 当发生不可逆损害时,外科医生更常被认定存在过失。
- 骨科外科医生应了解诉讼模式,同时确保以患者为中心的高质量照护。
研究设计与样本
- 查询全国数据库获取2015至2020年所有骨科医疗过失索赔,共获得来自17个州的164例索赔。
- 收集变量包括案件结局、赔偿支付、损害、过失主张、治疗及患者特征。
- 采用二元逻辑回归判断所收集变量是否增加防御性判决的可能性。
主要发现
- 髋与膝病例占比最高(n=49,29.9%;膝:n=26,15.9%;髋:n=23,14.0%),其次为脊柱(n=36,22.0%)、创伤(n=29,17.7%)、手与腕(n=16,9.8%)、运动医学(n=16,9.1%)、足与踝(n=7,4.3%)、儿科(n=6,3.7%)及肩(n=6,3.7%)。
- 在髋与膝手术中,防御性判决38例(77.6%),原告判决9例(18.4%,平均赔偿4,866,929美元),和解2例(4.1%,平均和解金1,550,000美元)。
- 不可逆损害(如瘫痪、截肢、死亡;P<.001)与防御性结局可能性降低相关。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Approximately 80% of hip and knee surgeons will face malpractice litigation. Understanding contemporary reasons for litigation and legal outcomes in our field may help surgeons deliver more effective and satisfying care, while limiting their legal exposure. This study aimed to determine: 1) which orthopaedic subspecialties were most frequently litigated; 2) malpractice damages and negligence claimed; 3) the proportion of different case outcomes; and 4) factors associated with defense verdicts. METHODS: A nationwide database was queried for all orthopaedic medical malpractice claims (2015 to 2020), obtaining 164 claims from 17 states. Variables included were as follows: case outcome, indemnity payment, damages, negligence claimed, treatment, and patient characteristics. A binary logistic regression determined if any collected variable increased the likelihood of a defense verdict. RESULTS: Hip and knee cases were the highest-represented (n = 49, 29.9%; knee: n = 26, 15.9%; hip: n = 23, 14.0%), followed by the spine (n = 36; 22.0%), trauma (n = 29;17.7%), hand and wrist (n = 16; 9.8%), sports (n = 16; 9.1%), foot and ankle (n = 7; 4.3%), pediatric (n = 6; 3.7%), and shoulder (n = 6; 3.7%). Within hip and knee surgery, defense verdicts occurred in 38 cases (77.6%), while 9 (18.4%) resulted in plaintiff verdicts (mean payment: $4,866,929) and 2 (4.1%) resulted in settlements (mean settlement: $1,550,000). Nonreversible damages (eg, paralysis, amputation, and death; P < .001) were associated with a decreased likelihood of a defense outcome. CONCLUSION: Hip and knee cases were the highest-represented in orthopaedic malpractice litigation. Surgeons were more frequently found negligent when nonreversible damages occurred. Orthopaedic surgeons should be cognizant of litigation patterns while ensuring patient-centered high-quality care.
引用
- Sauder N, Emara AK, Rullán PJ, et al. Hip and Knee Are the Most Litigated Orthopaedic Cases: A Nationwide 5-Year Analysis of Medical Malpractice Claims. J Arthroplasty. 2022. PMID: 36526101. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2022.11.021
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。