附着点病、肌腱病及盂唇与关节盘疾病的病理特征是否与黏液样变性相关?一项系统综述
该系统综述检索1980年至2021年PubMed、EMBASE和CINAHL数据库,纳入52项手术标本组织病理学研究,评估附着点病、肌腱病、盂唇和关节盘疾病的黏液样变性、炎症和血管性。结果显示100%研究至少报告一项黏液样变性要素,仅20%报告炎症,各解剖部位和结构间无差异,作者认为这些疾病可能与衰老相关而非损伤或活动。
要点
- 100%(52/52)的研究报告至少一项黏液样变性要素,69%报告细胞外基质增加。
- 仅20%(10/51)的研究报告炎症,其中9项为炎症细胞、1项为炎症标志物。
- 各解剖部位和结构间炎症与黏液样变性无差异,膝半月板较少被描述为血管性增加。
核心结论
- 系统综述发现软组织结构疾病(附着点病、肌腱病、盂唇和关节盘疾病)组织病理学一致表现为黏液样变性、轻微炎症和血管性评估不精确,这些发现跨解剖部位和结构一致,支持将这些疾病重新概念化为与衰老(衰老或变性)相关而非损伤或活动。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述检索PubMed、EMBASE和CINAHL数据库中1980年至2021年研究扳机指、de Quervain肌腱病、足底筋膜炎、肘内外侧附着点病、肩袖肌腱病、胫后肌腱病、髌腱病、跟腱病或髋盂唇、尺腕关节盘、膝半月板疾病手术标本组织病理学的研究。
- 初始检索得到3196项研究,应用纳入标准后559篇文章评估合格性,最终纳入52项研究。
- 记录研究是否报告炎症细胞或分子标志物、超出预期的血管性(定量计数伴或不伴对照、分子标志物或定性判断)以及黏液样变性特征(胶原排列紊乱、细胞外基质增加或软骨样化生)。
主要发现
- 按解剖部位比较,炎症或黏液样变性无差异,膝半月板较少被描述为血管性高于正常。
- 按解剖结构比较无差异。
- 调查炎症的51项研究中20%(10/51)报告炎症,包括9项炎症细胞和1项炎症标志物。
- 52项研究中83%(43/52)判定血管性增加:其中40%(17/43)使用定量方法(14项有对照、3项无对照),60%(26/43)使用不精确标准。
- 52项研究全部(100%)识别至少一项黏液样变性要素:69%(36/52)报告细胞外基质增加,71%(37/52)报告胶原排列紊乱,33%(17/52)报告软骨样化生。
关键数值与推荐
- 炎症报告率:20%(10/51),其中炎症细胞9项、炎症标志物1项。
- 血管性增加判定率:83%(43/52);定量方法占40%(17/43,14项有对照、3项无对照),不精确标准占60%(26/43)。
- 黏液样变性要素:细胞外基质增加69%(36/52),胶原排列紊乱71%(37/52),软骨样化生33%(17/52)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,这种重新概念化支持已知与更大舒适感和能力相关的调适性心态。
- 作者认为,了解人们衰老过程中结构性软组织变化的显著基础率,可能减少对偶然、良性或无关紧要的信号改变和病理生理的过度诊断和过度治疗。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Tendinopathy, enthesopathy, labral degeneration, and pathologic conditions of the articular disc (knee meniscus and ulnocarpal) are sometimes described in terms of inflammation or damage, while the histopathologic findings are often consistent with mucoid degeneration. A systematic review of the histopathology of these structures at diverse locations might reconceptualize these diseases as expected aspects of human aging. The potential benefits of this evolution might include healthier patient and clinician mindsets as well as a reduced likelihood of overdiagnosis and overtreatment resulting from greater awareness of base rates of pathology. QUESTION/PURPOSE: In this systematic review of studies of surgical specimens, we asked: Are there are any differences in the histopathologic findings of structural soft tissue conditions (mucoid degeneration, inflammation, and vascularity) by anatomic site (foot, elbow, or knee) or structure (tendon body, muscle or tendon origin or insertion [enthesis], labrum, or articular disc)? METHODS: Studies between 1980 and 2021 investigating the histopathologic findings of specimens from surgery for trigger digit, de Quervain tendinopathy, plantar fasciitis, lateral and medial elbow enthesopathy, rotator cuff tendinopathy, posterior tibial tendinopathy, patellar tendinopathy, Achilles tendinopathy, or disease of the hip labrum, ulnocarpal articular disc, or knee meniscus were searched for in the PubMed, EMBASE, and CINAHL databases. Inclusion criteria were the prespecified anatomic location or structure being analyzed histologically and any findings described with respect to inflammation, vascularity, or mucoid degeneration. Studies were excluded if they were nonhuman studies or review articles. Search terms included "anatomy," "pathology," and "histopathology." These terms were coupled with anatomic structures or disorders and included "trigger finger," "de Quervain," "fasciitis, plantar," "tennis elbow," "rotator cuff tendinopathy," "elbow tendinopathy," "patellar tendonitis," "posterior tibial tendon," and "triangular fibrocartilage." This resulted in 3196 studies. After applying the inclusion criteria, 559 articles were then assessed for eligibility according to our exclusion criteria, with 52 eventually included. We recorded whether the study identified the following histopathologic findings: inflammatory cells or molecular markers, greater than expected vascularity (categorized as quantitative count, with or without controls; molecular markers; or qualitative judgments), and features of mucoid degeneration (disorganized collagen, increased extracellular matrix, or chondroid metaplasia). In the absence of methods for systematically evaluating the pathophysiology of structural (collagenous) soft tissue structures and rating histopathologic study quality, all studies that interpreted histopathology results were included. The original authors' judgment regarding the presence or absence of inflammation, greater than expected vascularity, and elements of mucoid degeneration was recorded along with the type of data used to reach that conclusion. RESULTS: Regarding differences in the histopathology of surgical specimens of structural soft tissue conditions by anatomic site, there were no differences in inflammation or mucoid degeneration, and the knee meniscus was less often described as having greater than normal vascularity. There were no differences by anatomic structure. Overall, 20% (10 of 51) of the studies that investigated for inflammation reported it (nine inflammatory cells and one inflammatory marker). Eighty-three percent (43 of 52) interpreted increased vascularity: 40% (17 of 43) using quantitative methods (14 with controls and three without) and 60% (26 of 43) using imprecise criteria. Additionally, 100% (all 52 studies) identified at least one element of mucoid degeneration: 69% (36 of 52) reported an increased extracellular matrix, 71% (37 of 52) reported disorganized collagen, and 33% (17 of 52) reported chondroid metaplasia. CONCLUSION: Our systematic review of the histopathology of diseases of soft tissue structures (enthesopathy, tendinopathy, and labral and articular disc) identified consistent mucoid degeneration, minimal inflammation, and imprecise assessment of relative vascularity; these findings were consistent across anatomic sites and structures, supporting a reconceptualization of these diseases as related to aging (senescence or degeneration) rather than injury or activity. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: This reconceptualization supports accommodative mindsets known to be associated with greater comfort and capability. In addition, awareness of the notable base rates of structural soft tissue changes as people age might reduce overdiagnosis and overtreatment of incidental, benign, or inconsequential signal changes and pathophysiology.
引用
- Bruni DF, Pierson SR, Sarwar F, et al. Are the Pathologic Features of Enthesopathy, Tendinopathy, and Labral and Articular Disc Disease Related to Mucoid Degeneration? A Systematic Review. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2022. PMID: 36563131. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000002499
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。