膝关节骨关节炎患者心理社会因素的定性研究:来自亚洲人群的见解
本研究在新加坡一家城市三级转诊医院对46例亚洲膝关节骨关节炎患者进行半结构式访谈,采用主题分析识别出心理因素(因病丢面子、预期并回避疼痛与痛苦、负性情绪体验的恶性循环)和社会因素(社会与家庭支持、工作环境与就业不确定性、建成环境)六大主题。作者认为心理社会因素对患者躯体、心理和社会功能有重要影响,其中丢面子现象和家庭社会支持动态谱系为新发现。
要点
- 心理因素包括因病丢面子、预期并回避疼痛与痛苦、负性情绪体验的恶性循环。
- 社会因素包括社会与家庭支持、工作环境与就业不确定性、建成环境。
- 丢面子现象和家庭社会支持动态谱系是亚洲患者中的新发现。
核心结论
- 心理社会因素对膝关节骨关节炎患者的躯体、心理和社会功能有重要影响。
- 丢面子现象和亚洲患者中广泛的社会与家庭支持动态是本研究的 new findings。
- 患者将使用手杖与严重残疾、失去尊重和被他人歧视相关联,为保面子而回避这些污名,甚至以活动能力和独立性为代价。
- 集体主义价值观下的复杂文化过程(感知的社会角色与对家庭的贡献、避免拖累家庭的愿望、求助行为、偏好主动提供的支持)影响患者的行为和选择。
研究设计与样本
- 在新加坡中部一家城市三级转诊医院开展半结构式访谈,访谈内容为患者管理膝关节骨关节炎的广泛经历。
- 纳入标准为符合以下任一条件:Kellgren-Lawrence分级≥3级(至少一个膝关节);膝关节损伤和骨关节炎结局评分≤60;疼痛平均值(P)、对生活乐趣的干扰(E)和对一般活动的干扰(G)(PEG)≥5。
- 所有患者均有膝关节骨关节炎临床诊断,可在社区行走(伴或不伴助行器),未接受过部分关节置换或全膝关节置换术,被处方非手术治疗,且能用英语或普通话交流。
- 共纳入46例患者(30例女性,16例男性,平均年龄64岁)。
- 采用演绎法进行主题分析,结合扎根理论和框架分析的元素;对剩余转录文本进行归纳性主题分析以识别新主题;研究团队在46份转录文本中达成数据和主题充分性时达到主题饱和。
主要发现
- 心理因素主题为:因病丢面子、预期并回避疼痛与痛苦、负性情绪体验的恶性循环。
- 社会因素主题为:社会与家庭支持、工作环境与就业不确定性、建成环境(患者在人造结构和设施中通行的能力)。
- 患者将使用手杖与严重残疾、失去尊重和被他人歧视相关联,促使患者通过远离这些污名来保面子,甚至以活动能力和独立性为代价。
关键数值与推荐
- 纳入标准包括Kellgren-Lawrence分级≥3级(至少一个膝关节)、膝关节损伤和骨关节炎结局评分≤60或PEG≥5。
- 共纳入46例患者(30例女性,16例男性,平均年龄64岁)。
临床怎么用
- 了解 culturally relevant 心理社会因素对膝关节骨关节炎患者经历和结局的影响后,临床医生能够更有效地筛查并主动探索这些因素。
- 特别重要的主题包括疼痛感知(密切关注疼痛灾难化和负性情绪迹象)、与膝关节骨关节炎诊断相关的慢性疾病羞耻感(包括使用助行器相关的污名)、以及患者获得的社会支持水平和建成环境对运动恐惧症的贡献。
- 对于仍在工作的患者,还应探索工作场所压力源的存在及其管理。
- 在可能的情况下,可在繁忙的临床环境中使用测量疼痛灾难化和情绪困扰等心理社会因素的筛查工具作为额外一层筛查。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: A patient's experience with knee osteoarthritis (OA) is influenced by many psychosocial contributors that can influence the impact of pain. Such factors are known to explain some of the discordance between objective clinical parameters and patient-reported levels of disability and treatment effectiveness. However, few data are available to help clinicians understand the psychosocial factors that apply to the world's many Asian populations. Insights gained from a qualitative study in such a population may support targeted interventions. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: In this qualitative study involving a group of Asian patients with knee OA in Singapore, we asked: (1) What psychologic factors contribute to patients' experiences, rehabilitation, and recovery? (2) What social factors contribute to patients' experiences, rehabilitation, and recovery? METHODS: Semistructured interviews eliciting broad patient experiences of managing knee OA were conducted in an urban, referral-based tertiary hospital in central Singapore. Patients were recruited if they met either of the following criteria: Kellgren-Lawrence grade ≥ 3 (minimum of one knee); Knee Injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score ≤ 60; or the Pain average (P), interference with Enjoyment of life (E), and interference with General activity (G) (PEG) ≥ 5. All patients had a clinical diagnosis of knee OA, were ambulatory in the community with or without a walking aid, had not undergone partial arthroplasty or TKA, were prescribed nonsurgical treatment, and were conversant in either English or Mandarin. Forty-six patients (30 women and 16 men, mean age 64 years old) were recruited for this study. A thematic analysis with elements of grounded theory and framework analysis was performed using a deductive approach. Psychologic influences specific to patients' behavioral and emotional responses to pain, as well as social factors known to have an impact on the experience of managing knee OA, were identified in the interview transcripts and coded according to established factors from earlier research. An inductive thematic analysis was then applied to the remaining transcripts to identify new themes that emerged from the data. Thematic saturation was attained when study team members agreed data and thematic sufficiency were met in the 46 transcripts. The study team discussed and deemed the 46 transcripts to contain sufficient insights for a reasonably clear understanding of the codes and development of themes to answer the study's research questions. RESULTS: Six main themes related to psychosocial influences on pain emerged. Psychologic factors were "loss of face" because of knee OA, anticipation and avoidance of pain and suffering, and a vicious cycle of negative emotional experiences. The social factors we identified were social and family support, workplace environment and employment uncertainty, and built environment (patients' ability to navigate manmade structures and facilities). CONCLUSION: Psychosocial factors have an important impact on patients' physical, psychologic, and social functioning. Although several of our findings have been addressed previously, the phenomenon of loss of face and the wide spectrum of social and family support dynamics found in our Asian patients with knee OA were new findings. With loss of face, patients were concerned about how others would view the change in them, including movement changes because of knee OA. They appeared to associate the use of walking canes with major disability, loss of respect, and being discriminated against by others, motivating patients to "save face" by dissociating themselves from those stigmas, even at the cost of mobility and independence. An interplay of complex cultural processes (perceived social roles and contributions to family, desire to avoid burdening family, help-seeking behavior, and the preference for unsolicited social support) underpinned by the value of collectivism impacted the behaviors and choices patients exhibited. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: With knowledge about the impact of culturally relevant psychosocial factors on the experience and outcomes of patients with knee OA, clinicians will be able to screen and actively explore these factors more effectively. Especially important themes include pain perception (paying close attention to signs of pain catastrophizing and negative affect), presence of chronic illness shame associated with a diagnosis of knee OA (including the stigma associated with using a walking aid), and level of social support received and contributions of a patient's built environment to kinesiophobia. For patients who are still working, the presence of workplace stressors and management of these stressors should also be explored. Where possible, screening tools that measure psychosocial factors such as pain catastrophizing and emotional distress can also be used as an added layer of screening in busy clinical settings.
引用
- Yang SY, Woon EYS, Griva K, et al. A Qualitative Study of Psychosocial Factors in Patients With Knee Osteoarthritis: Insights Learned From an Asian Population. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2022. PMID: 36580492. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000002526
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。