文献速递关节外科

髋膝关节置换数据库观察性研究中因果性语言与推断的高患病率:四本骨科杂志已发表论文的综述

High Prevalence of Causal Language and Inferences in Observational Hip and Knee Arthroplasty Database Studies: A Review of Papers Published Across Four Orthopaedic Journals.
PubMed 文献 · J Arthroplasty · 2022-12-13

该综述系统识别2020年发表于4本骨科杂志的髋膝关节置换行政数据库与登记研究,由两名评价者独立对标题、摘要及全文进行因果性语言分级。116篇 eligible 文章中,79.3%的标题和摘要被分类为持续因果或不一致因果,仅20.7%为持续非因果;全文40.5%持续因果、49.1%不一致、10.3%持续非因果。结论认为因果性语言和推断在关节置换观察性数据库研究中高发,可能误导读者。

要点

  • 116篇髋膝关节置换观察性数据库研究中,79.3%的标题和摘要存在持续或不确定的因果性语言。
  • 全文仅10.3%被分级为持续非因果,49.1%为不一致因果,40.5%为持续因果。
  • 标题和摘要的因果性分级与发表期刊(P = .720)及数据库或登记来源(P = .716)无统计学显著关联。

核心结论

  • 2020年发表于4本骨科杂志的下肢关节置换观察性数据库研究中,79.3%的标题和摘要存在因果性语言和推断。
  • 关节置换文献中因果性语言和推断的高患病率可能误导读者。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统识别2020年发表于4本骨科杂志的髋膝关节置换行政数据库和登记研究。
  • 由两名评价者独立对标题、摘要及全文的因果性语言进行分级。
  • 采用卡方分析检验因果性分级与文章特征(包括发表期刊)的关系。
  • 共纳入116篇符合条件文章。

主要发现

  • 116篇 eligible 文章中,79.3%的标题和摘要被分类为持续因果或不一致因果,仅20.7%为持续非因果。
  • 全文40.5%为持续因果,49.1%为不一致,10.3%为持续非因果。
  • 标题和摘要的因果性分级与发表期刊无统计学显著关联(P = .720)。
  • 标题和摘要的因果性分级与使用数据库或登记无统计学显著关联(P = .716)。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: The use of administrative databases and clinical registries in lower extremity arthroplasty research is growing. Such observational studies are unable to fully control for confounders and cannot establish causality. However, many authors use causal language when describing their aims or findings, potentially misleading readers. We examined the prevalence of causal language and inferences in the lower extremity arthroplasty literature. METHODS: We systematically identified administrative database and registry studies on hip and knee arthroplasty that were published in 4 orthopaedic journals in 2020. Articles were graded independently by two reviewers for the presence of causal language in both the title and abstract and the full text. Chi-squared analyses were conducted to determine the relationship between the causality grading and article characteristics including the journal of publication. RESULTS: Of 116 eligible articles, we classified 79.3% of titles and abstracts as either consistently causal or inconsistently causal, with only 20.7% as consistently noncausal. A total of 40.5% of full texts were consistently causal, 49.1% were inconsistent, and 10.3% were consistently noncausal. Chi-squared analyses revealed no statistically significant association between the title and abstract's grading and the journal (P = .720) nor with the use of a database or registry (P = .716). CONCLUSION: Causal language and inferences were present in 79.3% of titles and abstracts of lower extremity arthroplasty observational database studies published in 2020. The high prevalence of causal language and inferences in the arthroplasty literature may mislead readers.

来源:J Arthroplasty,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Barakat N, Novicoff WM, Werner BC, et al. High Prevalence of Causal Language and Inferences in Observational Hip and Knee Arthroplasty Database Studies: A Review of Papers Published Across Four Orthopaedic Journals. J Arthroplasty. 2022. PMID: 36521731. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2022.12.008

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。