运动学对齐全膝关节置换术后屈曲中期的前后稳定性:一项后稳定型与内侧稳定型假体的随机定量放射学松弛度研究
本研究从一项大型随机、前瞻、盲法临床试验中随机选取63例患者,接受后稳定型(PS)或内侧稳定型(MS)假体全膝关节置换。结果显示45°屈曲时MS组前后位移显著小于PS组,90°屈曲时仅女性亚组MS组显著小于PS组,且MS组术后KSS疼痛、疼痛/运动、功能评分及恢复运动比例更高。
要点
- 45°屈曲时MS组前后总位移显著小于PS组(平均3.6 vs 16.5 mm,p≤0.0001)。
- 90°屈曲时全体患者两组前后总位移无显著差异(平均3.9 vs 5.9,p=0.07),女性亚组MS组显著小于PS组(2.3 vs 5.4 mm,p=0.008)。
- MS组术后KSS疼痛、疼痛/运动、功能评分均显著高于PS组,恢复运动比例更高(33/33 vs 19/30,p=0.0001)。
核心结论
- PS假体患者屈曲中期松弛度大于MS假体患者,且女性亚组PS组在90°屈曲时松弛度更大。
- MS组观察到的较低松弛度与更高的KSS疼痛、疼痛/运动、功能评分及更高的恢复运动比例相关。
研究设计与样本
- 从一项大型随机、前瞻、盲法临床试验中随机选取63例患者,接受初次全膝关节置换,PS假体组n=30,MS假体组n=33。
- 收集活动度、膝关节协会评分(KSS)和遗忘关节评分(FJS),并通过应力X线片评估45°和90°屈曲时前后松弛度。
主要发现
- 45°屈曲时MS组前后总位移显著小于PS组(平均3.6 vs 16.5 mm,p≤0.0001)。
- 90°屈曲时全体患者两组前后总位移无显著差异(平均3.9 vs 5.9,p=0.07);女性亚组MS组显著小于PS组(2.3 vs 5.4 mm,p=0.008)。
- MS组术后KSS疼痛评分平均48.8 vs PS组44.8(p=0.02),KSS疼痛/运动评分平均98.4 vs 89.5(p<0.0001),KSS功能评分平均95.5 vs 85.7(p=0.003)。
- MS组33例患者全部恢复运动(FJS第12题所示),PS组为19例(p=0.0001);两组术后FJS或活动度无显著差异。
关键数值与推荐
- 术后KSS疼痛评分MS组平均48.8 vs PS组44.8(p=0.02)。
- 术后KSS疼痛/运动评分MS组平均98.4 vs PS组89.5(p<0.0001)。
- 术后KSS功能评分MS组平均95.5 vs PS组85.7(p=0.003)。
- 45°屈曲前后总位移MS组平均3.6 mm vs PS组16.5 mm(p≤0.0001)。
- 女性亚组90°屈曲前后松弛度MS组2.3 mm vs PS组5.4 mm(p=0.008)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
UPDATE: This article was updated on January 4, 2023, because of a previous error, which was discovered after the preliminary version of the article was posted online. On page 16, in Figure 5, the x-axis that had read "P<0.0086" now reads "KSS Pain (p=0.02)," and the value for the MS group that had read "48.9" now reads "48.8."This article was updated on January 6, 2022, because of a previous error. On page 13, in the section entitled "Results," the sentence that had read "However, when only the subset of female subjects was considered, the MS group demonstrated significantly less anteroposterior laxity in 90° of flexion than the MS group (2.3 versus 5.4 mm; p = 0.008)." now reads "However, when only the subset of female subjects was considered, the MS group demonstrated significantly less anteroposterior laxity in 90° of flexion than the PS group (2.3 versus 5.4 mm; p = 0.008)." BACKGROUND: Stability in mid-flexion is important for satisfactory clinical outcomes following total knee arthroplasty (TKA). The purpose of the present study was to compare the anteroposterior stability of knees that had been treated with a posterior-stabilized (PS) device or a medial-stabilized (MS) device. We hypothesized that mid-flexion laxity would be greater in the PS group and that clinical outcome scores would be better for the group with lower laxity. METHODS: Sixty-three patients who had been randomly selected from a larger randomized, prospective, blinded clinical trial underwent primary TKA with either a PS implant (n = 30) or an MS implant (n = 33). Range of motion, the Knee Society Score (KSS), and the Forgotten Joint Score (FJS) were collected, and anteroposterior laxity with the knee in 45° and 90° of flexion was evaluated with stress radiographs. RESULTS: In 45° of flexion, the MS group demonstrated significantly less total anteroposterior displacement than the PS group (mean, 3.6 versus 16.5 mm; p ≤ 0.0001). In 90° of flexion, the total anteroposterior displacement was not significantly different for the 2 groups when both male and female patients were included (mean, 3.9 versus 5.9; p = 0.07). However, when only the subset of female subjects was considered, the MS group demonstrated significantly less anteroposterior laxity in 90° of flexion than the PS group (2.3 versus 5.4 mm; p = 0.008). The groups did not differ significantly in terms of preoperative age, body mass index, sex distribution, FJS, KSS, or range of motion, and they also did not differ in terms of postoperative FJS or range of motion. However, all 33 patients in the MS group returned to sports as indicated in question 12 of the FJS, compared with 19 subjects in the PS group (p = 0.0001). The postoperative KSS Pain, Pain/Motion, and Function scores were all significantly higher in the MS group than the PS; specifically, the mean KSS Pain score was 48.8 in the MS group, compared with 44.8 in the PS group (p = 0.02); the mean KSS Pain/Motion score was 98.4 in the MS group, compared with 89.5 in the PS group (p < 0.0001); and the mean KSS Function score was 95.5 in the MS group, compared with 85.7 in the PS group (p = 0.003). CONCLUSIONS: Mid-flexion laxity was greater in patients with PS implants than in those with MS implants, and laxity in 90° was greater in the subset of female patients in the PS group. The decreased laxity observed in the MS group correlated with higher KSS Pain, Pain/Motion, and Function scores as well as with a higher rate of return to sports activities. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic Level I . See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.
引用
- Scott DF, Hellie AA. Mid-Flexion, Anteroposterior Stability of Total Knee Replacement Implanted with Kinematic Alignment: A Randomized, Quantitative Radiographic Laxity Study with Posterior-Stabilized and Medial-Stabilized Implants. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2022. PMID: 36574642. doi:10.2106/JBJS.22.00549
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。