髋膝关节置换术中人工智能应用的顾虑:文献综述与有意义采用的建议
该综述回顾了2018至2021年间髋膝关节置换术相关人工智能文献,涵盖图像分析、价值医疗、远程患者监测和增强现实。在233篇人工智能相关骨科文章中,178篇(76%)为原创研究,其中52%(n=92)涉及髋膝关节置换术,仅3项研究进行了外部验证。作者总结了当前研究的方法学缺陷,并提出有意义采用人工智能的简单检查点。
要点
- 在233篇人工智能相关骨科文章中,178篇(76%)为原创研究,52%的原创研究(n=92)涉及髋膝关节置换术。
- 仅3项研究进行了外部验证。
- 当前研究缺陷包括混淆术语、重复包装有限注册数据、过早发布内部验证预测模型、评价模型架构而非输入数据、保留代码以及使用过时的基于回归的指南评价研究。
核心结论
- 尽管人工智能已应用于多种髋膝关节置换术场景,但临床影响有限;若问题有意义、方法严谨透明、数据丰富且模型经过外部验证,未来仍有希望。
研究设计与样本
- 对2018年至2021年间髋膝关节置换术中人工智能相关文献(图像分析、价值医疗、远程患者监测、增强现实)进行叙述性综述。
主要发现
- 在233篇人工智能相关骨科文章中,178篇(76%)为原创研究,其余为社论或综述。
- 52%的原创人工智能相关研究涉及髋膝关节置换术(n=92)。
- 仅3项研究进行了外部验证。
- 当前研究的缺陷包括:混淆术语(「人工智能/机器学习」)、重复包装有限的注册数据、过早发布内部验证的预测模型、评价模型架构而非输入数据、保留代码、使用过时的基于回归的指南评价研究。
关键数值与推荐
- 有意义采用人工智能的简单检查点包括确保应用关注:行政支持而非临床评估与管理;先进模型的必要性;所回答问题的新颖性。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Literature surrounding artificial intelligence (AI)-related applications for hip and knee arthroplasty has proliferated. However, meaningful advances that fundamentally transform the practice and delivery of joint arthroplasty are yet to be realized, despite the broad range of applications as we continue to search for meaningful and appropriate use of AI. AI literature in hip and knee arthroplasty between 2018 and 2021 regarding image-based analyses, value-based care, remote patient monitoring, and augmented reality was reviewed. Concerns surrounding meaningful use and appropriate methodological approaches of AI in joint arthroplasty research are summarized. Of the 233 AI-related orthopaedics articles published, 178 (76%) constituted original research, while the rest consisted of editorials or reviews. A total of 52% of original AI-related research concerns hip and knee arthroplasty (n = 92), and a narrative review is described. Three studies were externally validated. Pitfalls surrounding present-day research include conflating vernacular ("AI/machine learning"), repackaging limited registry data, prematurely releasing internally validated prediction models, appraising model architecture instead of inputted data, withholding code, and evaluating studies using antiquated regression-based guidelines. While AI has been applied to a variety of hip and knee arthroplasty applications with limited clinical impact, the future remains promising if the question is meaningful, the methodology is rigorous and transparent, the data are rich, and the model is externally validated. Simple checkpoints for meaningful AI adoption include ensuring applications focus on: administrative support over clinical evaluation and management; necessity of the advanced model; and the novelty of the question being answered.Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2022;104-B(12):1292-1303.
引用
- Polisetty TS, Jain S, Pang M, et al. Concerns surrounding application of artificial intelligence in hip and knee arthroplasty : a review of literature and recommendations for meaningful adoption. Bone Joint J. 2022. PMID: 36453039. doi:10.1302/0301-620X.104B12.BJJ-2022-0922.R1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。