文献速递手外科与足踝外科

微创手术在拇外翻畸形治疗中是否比开放手术提供更好的临床或影像学结果?一项系统综述与Meta分析

Does Minimally Invasive Surgery Provide Better Clinical or Radiographic Outcomes Than Open Surgery in the Treatment of Hallux Valgus Deformity? A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2022-11-04

该系统综述与Meta分析纳入7项研究(395足),比较微创与开放手术治疗拇外翻,发现两组在AOFAS评分、VAS评分、影像学角度、并发症及手术时间上均无临床重要差异;作者认为源研究方法学缺陷可能夸大微创优势,无法推荐微创优于传统开放手术。

要点

  • 微创与开放手术的AOFAS评分差异无临床重要性(88±7 vs 85±8,均差4分,95%CI 1-6,p<0.01)。
  • 两组VAS评分、拇外翻角、跖间角、远端跖骨关节角及手术时间均无差异。
  • 并发症频率或严重程度无差异;作者认为方法学缺陷可能夸大微创优势,无法推荐微创优于传统。

核心结论

  • 该Meta分析发现,与开放手术相比,微创手术治疗拇外翻未带来更好的临床或影像学结果。
  • 源研究方法学缺陷可能夸大了微创手术的表观优势,实际上微创可能劣于传统入路。
  • 鉴于缺乏临床重要获益及学习曲线相关风险,作者无法推荐微创入路优于传统入路。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统综述与Meta分析,遵循Cochrane干预系统评价手册和PRISMA指南,检索PubMed、Embase、Scopus、CINAHL和CENTRAL数据库,检索日期为2022年5月3日。
  • 纳入7项研究(395足),包括6项随机对照研究和1项前瞻性对照研究,比较微创手术与开放手术治疗拇外翻。
  • 微创手术定义为通过准确操作所需最小切口进行的手术,切口长度最大约2 cm;开放手术涉及较大切口和深部结构直接可视化。
  • 使用Cochrane随机试验偏倚风险评估工具第二版或Newcastle-Ottawa量表评估偏倚风险;多数纳入研究偏倚风险质量为中等;排除1项高偏倚风险研究。
  • 进行敏感性分析,仅纳入低偏倚风险研究以确认Meta分析稳健性;当存在显著异质性(I²>50%)时使用随机效应模型,否则使用固定效应模型。

主要发现

  • 微创组与开放组AOFAS评分分别为88±7与85±8,均差4分(95%CI 1至6),p<0.01,未达临床重要差异(最小临床重要差异为29分)。
  • 微创组与开放组VAS评分分别为0±0与0±1,标准化均差0分(95%CI -1至0),p=0.08。
  • 微创组与开放组拇外翻角分别为12°±4°与12°±4°,均差0°(95%CI -2至2),p=0.76;跖间角分别为7°±2°与7°±2°,均差0°(95%CI -1至1),p=0.69;远端跖骨关节角分别为7°±4°与8°±4°,均差-1°(95%CI -4至2),p=0.28。
  • 定性分析显示微创组与开放组并发症频率或严重程度无差异。
  • 微创组与开放组手术时间分别为28±8分钟与40±10分钟,均差-12分钟(95%CI -25至1),p=0.06。

关键数值与推荐

  • AOFAS评分范围0至100,评分越高代表疼痛越轻和功能越好,最小临床重要差异为29分。
  • VAS评分基于疼痛评分量表(范围0至10),评分越高代表疼痛越重。
  • 微创手术定义为通过准确操作所需最小切口进行的手术,切口长度最大约2 cm;开放手术涉及较大切口和深部结构直接可视化。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为,鉴于本Meta分析未发现任何临床重要获益,无法推荐微创入路优于传统入路。
  • 作者指出,微创手术存在学习曲线,期间患者可能因外科医生熟悉新技术而受到伤害。
  • 作者建议未来研究应确保方法学稳健,使用经过验证的临床和影像学参数以及患者报告结局指标评估微创手术的长期结果。

局限性

  • 大多数纳入研究关于偏倚风险的质量为中等。
  • 源研究的方法学缺陷可能夸大了微创手术的表观优势。
  • 微创手术存在学习曲线,期间患者可能因外科医生熟悉新技术而受到伤害。
  • 未来研究应确保方法学稳健并使用经过验证的参数评估长期结果。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Hallux valgus is the most common foot deformity and affects 23% to 35% of the general population. More than 150 different techniques have been described for surgical correction. Recently, there has been increasing interest in the use of minimally invasive surgery to correct hallux valgus deformities. A variety of studies have been published with differing outcomes regarding minimally invasive surgery. However, most studies lack sufficient power and are small, making it difficult to draw adequate conclusions. A meta-analysis can therefore be helpful to evaluate and compare minimally invasive and open surgery. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: We performed a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials and prospective controlled studies to answer the following question: Compared with open surgery, does minimally invasive surgery for hallux valgus result in (1) improved American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) scores and VAS scores for pain, (2) improved radiologic outcomes, (3) fewer complications, or (4) a shorter duration of surgery? METHODS: The systematic review and meta-analysis was conducted according to the guidelines of the Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Intervention and the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analyses. A search was performed in the PubMed, Embase, Scopus, CINAHL, and CENTRAL databases on May 3, 2022. Studies were eligible if they were randomized controlled or prospective controlled studies that compared minimally invasive surgery and open surgery to treat patients with hallux valgus. We defined minimally invasive surgery as surgery performed through the smallest incision required to perform the procedure accurately, with an incision length of approximately 2 cm at maximum. Open surgery, on the other hand, involves a larger incision and direct visualization of deeper structures. Seven studies (395 feet), consisting of six randomized controlled studies and one prospective comparative study, were included in the qualitative and quantitative data synthesis. There were no differences between the minimally invasive and open surgery groups regarding age, gender, or severity of hallux valgus deformity. Each included study was assessed for the risk of bias using the second version of the Cochrane tool for assessing the risk of bias in randomized trials or by using the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale for comparative studies. Most of the included studies had intermediate quality regarding the risk of bias. We excluded one study from our analysis because of its high risk of bias to avoid serious distortions in the meta-analysis. We performed a sensitivity analysis to confirm that our meta-analysis was robust by including only studies with a low risk of bias. The analyzed endpoints included the AOFAS score (range 0 to 100), where higher scores represent less pain and better function; the minimum clinically important difference on this scale was 29 points. In addition, the VAS score was analyzed, which is based on a pain rating scale (range 0 to 10), with higher scores representing greater pain. Radiologic outcomes included the hallux valgus angle, intermetatarsal angle, and distal metatarsal articular angle. Complications were qualitatively assessed and evaluated for differences. A random-effects model was used if substantial heterogeneity (I 2 > 50%) was found; otherwise, a fixed-effects model was used. RESULTS: We found no clinically important difference between minimally invasive and open surgery in terms of the AOFAS score (88 ± 7 versus 85 ± 8, respectively; mean difference 4 points [95% CI 1 to 6]; p < 0.01). There were no differences between the minimally invasive and open surgery groups in terms of VAS scores (0 ± 0 versus 0 ± 1, respectively; standardized mean difference 0 points [95% CI -1 to 0]; p = 0.08). There were no differences between the minimally invasive and open surgery groups in terms of the hallux valgus angle (12° ± 4° versus 12° ± 4°; mean difference 0 points [95% CI -2 to 2]; p = 0.76). Radiographic measurements of the intermetatarsal angle did not differ between the minimally invasive and open surgery groups (7° ± 2° versus 7° ± 2°; mean difference 0 points [95% CI -1 to 1]; p = 0.69). In addition, there were no differences between the minimally invasive and open surgery groups in terms of the distal metatarsal articular angle (7° ± 4° versus 8° ± 4°; mean difference -1 point [95% CI -4 to 2]; p = 0.28). The qualitative analysis revealed no difference in the frequency or severity of complications between the minimally invasive and the open surgery groups. The minimally invasive and open surgery groups did not differ in terms of the duration of surgery (28 ± 8 minutes versus 40 ± 10 minutes; mean difference -12 minutes [95% CI -25 to 1]; p = 0.06). CONCLUSION: This meta-analysis found that hallux valgus treated with minimally invasive surgery did not result in improved clinical or radiologic outcomes compared with open surgery. Methodologic shortcomings of the source studies in this meta-analysis likely inflated the apparent benefits of minimally invasive surgery, such that in reality it may be inferior to the traditional approach. Given the associated learning curves-during which patients may be harmed by surgeons who are gaining familiarity with a new technique-we are unable to recommend the minimally invasive approach over traditional approaches, in light of the absence of any clinically important benefits identified in this meta-analysis. Future research should ensure studies are methodologically robust using validated clinical and radiologic parameters, as well as patient-reported outcome measures, to assess the long-term outcomes of minimally invasive surgery.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Alimy AR, Polzer H, Ocokoljic A, et al. Does Minimally Invasive Surgery Provide Better Clinical or Radiographic Outcomes Than Open Surgery in the Treatment of Hallux Valgus Deformity? A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2022. PMID: 36332131. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000002471

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。