经典(静态)RSA与患者运动伪影如何影响全膝关节置换术胫骨部件迁移评估?一项体外研究
该体外研究以两个胫骨膝关节置换部件固定在骨-假体模型上,在单平面测量装置中分别采用无运动和模拟运动方案,评估患者运动对经典(静态)RSA精度及植入物迁移评估的影响。结果显示模拟运动的影响总体较小,但颅尾轴方向诱导的精度损失在基于模型的RSA中大于基于标记的RSA;最大总点运动在运动方案下明显增大。结论认为,在非同步RSA图像上患者运动超过1 mm或1°会影响胫骨部件迁移检测的测量误差,RSA通常需要同步图像采集。
要点
- 模拟运动方案下基于模型RSA的精度较基于标记RSA分别在内侧-外侧平移、后-前平移和颅-尾轴旋转上差0.035±0.015 mm、0.045±0.014 mm和0.049±0.036 mm。
- 最大总点运动在基于标记RSA中从无运动方案0.038±0.007 mm增至模拟运动方案1.684±0.038 mm(p<0.001)。
- 结论指出非同步RSA图像上患者运动超过1 mm或1°会影响胫骨部件迁移检测的测量误差,RSA通常需要同步图像采集。
核心结论
- 在非同步RSA图像上患者运动超过1 mm或1°会影响胫骨部件迁移检测的测量误差。
- 在临床RSA研究中,即使临床RSA系统具有可接受的精度,患者运动对植入物迁移评估的影响也应特别关注。
- 经过专门培训的放射技师对正确采集X线片至关重要,尤其当同步X线曝光未电子自动化时。
- 一般而言,RSA需要同步图像采集,这应成为最先进水平。
研究设计与样本
- 体外研究,将两个胫骨膝关节置换部件分别固定在两个骨-假体模型上作为定制体模,在单平面测量装置中拍摄X线片。
- 评估基于模型(来自逆向工程的植入物模型)和基于标记(附加植入物标记)两种RSA方法。
- 在模拟参考与随访检查之间,使用其中一个骨-假体模型模拟患者运动,另一个平行模拟无患者运动。
- 每个骨-假体模型遵循两种既定方案:无运动方案和模拟运动方案。
- RSA图像对使用基于模型的RSA软件包(MBRSA 4.1,RSA core)分析;精度通过重复检查计算,并评估两个部件的迁移以相互比较。
主要发现
- 模拟患者运动的影响总体较小,但颅-尾轴除外;基于模型RSA中运动诱导的精度损失大于基于标记RSA。
- 在模拟运动方案下,基于模型RSA的精度值分别比基于标记RSA差0.035±0.015 mm(内侧-外侧轴平移,基于标记RSA为0.018±0.004 mm,p=0.01)、0.045±0.014 mm(后-前轴平移,基于标记RSA为0.018±0.007 mm,p=0.003)和0.049±0.036 mm(颅-尾轴旋转,基于标记RSA为0.017±0.006 mm,p=0.02)。
- 最大总点运动在基于标记RSA中从无运动方案的0.038±0.007 mm增至模拟运动方案的1.684±0.038 mm(p<0.001)。
- 最大总点运动在基于模型RSA中从无运动方案的0.101±0.027 mm增至模拟运动方案的1.973±0.442 mm(p<0.001)。
- 最大总点运动是患者运动伪影的最坏情况。
关键数值与推荐
- 患者运动超过1 mm或1°(在非同步RSA图像上)影响胫骨部件迁移检测的测量误差。
- 在基于标记RSA中,最大总点运动无运动方案0.038±0.007 mm vs 模拟运动方案1.684±0.038 mm(模拟运动方案较无运动方案升高,p<0.001)。
- 在基于模型RSA中,最大总点运动无运动方案0.101±0.027 mm vs 模拟运动方案1.973±0.442 mm(模拟运动方案较无运动方案升高,p<0.001)。
临床怎么用
- 在临床RSA研究中,通过重复检查评估的精度使用当前放射科广泛使用的标准可能不可靠。
- 在评估植入物迁移的可靠性时,提倡比较受试(模拟运动)植入物与基线(无运动)植入物之间的最大总点运动,如本研究所示,因为可准确检测患者运动伪影。
- 经过专门培训的放射技师对正确采集X线片至关重要,尤其当同步X线曝光未电子自动化时。
- 一般而言,RSA需要同步图像采集,这应成为最先进水平。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Classic (static) Roentgen stereophotogrammetric analysis (RSA) is the current gold standard to assess, in vivo, the migration of total joint arthroplasty components. To prevent potential patient motion artifacts during the acquisition of paired radiostereometric images, images must be taken by simultaneously firing both X-ray tubes. However, the influence of nonsynchronized RSA paired images or patient motion artifacts on the precision of RSA and the assessment of implant migration is not well understood. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: We assessed (1) the effect of possible patient motion on the precision of RSA and (2) apparent differences in implant migration among axes (in-plane and out-of-plane translations and in-plane and out-of-plane rotations) of possible motion artifacts. METHODS: Radiographs of two tibial knee arthroplasty components, each fixed in two bone-implant models as a customized phantom, were taken in a uniplanar measurement setup. We evaluated both model-based (implant models from reversed engineering) and marker-based (additional attached implant markers) RSA approaches. Between the simulated reference and follow-up examinations, we used one of the bone-implant models to simulate patient motion and the other to simulate no patient motion in parallel. Two defined protocols were followed for each of the bone-implant models: no-motion and simulated motion protocols. RSA image pairs were analyzed using a model-based RSA software package (MBRSA 4.1, RSA core ). Precision was calculated through repeat examinations, and migration of the two components was assessed for comparison of the components with each other. Measurements were taken along the medial-lateral and posterior-anterior axes for translations and around the cranial-caudal axis for rotations. The maximum total point motion was measured for comparison between the two components. RESULTS: The effect of simulated patient motion was generally small, except in the cranial-caudal axis, but the induced imprecision associated with motion was larger in model-based RSA than it was in marker-based RSA. The mean ± standard deviation values of precision in model-based RSA were 0.035 ± 0.015 mm, 0.045 ± 0.014 mm, and 0.049 ± 0.036 mm greater than those in marker-based RSA, in accordance with the simulated motion protocol in translations along the medial-lateral axis (0.018 ± 0.004 mm; p = 0.01), along the posterior-anterior axis (0.018 ± 0.007 mm; p = 0.003), and rotations around the cranial-caudal axis (0.017 ± 0.006 mm; p = 0.02). Apparent differences in implant migration were the greatest for the maximum total point motion. The maximum total point motion increased from 0.038 ± 0.007 mm for the no-motion protocol to 1.684 ± 0.038 mm (p < 0.001) for the simulated motion protocol in marker-based RSA, and from 0.101 ± 0.027 mm for the no-motion protocol to 1.973 ± 0.442 mm (p < 0.001) for the simulated motion protocol in model-based RSA, and was the worst-case scenario regarding patient motion artifacts. CONCLUSION: Patient motion exceeding 1 mm or 1° on nonsynchronized RSA images affects measurement errors regarding the detection of migration of a tibial component. In clinical RSA studies, the effect of patient motion on the assessment of implant migration should be of particular concern, even if clinical RSA systems have acceptable precision. Specially trained radiographers are crucial for correctly acquiring radiographs, especially when simultaneous radiography exposures are not electronically automated. In general, RSA requires synchronized image acquisition, and this should be the state-of-the-art. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: In clinical RSA studies, precision assessed by repeat examinations may not be reliable using the current standards that are widely used in radiology departments. When assessing implant migration for reliability, comparison of the maximum total point motion between the tested (simulated motion) implant and baseline (no-motion) implant, as in this study, is advocated because of the accurate detection of patient motion artifacts.
引用
- Cao H, Sesselmann S, Xu J, et al. How Do Classic (Static) RSA and Patient Motion Artifacts Affect the Assessment of Migration of a TKA Tibial Component? An In Vitro Study. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2022. PMID: 36398327. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000002453
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。