文献速递创伤骨科关节外科运动医学

反式全肩关节置换术治疗70岁以上三部分和四部分肱骨近端骨折的疗效优于角稳定钢板

Reverse Total Shoulder Arthroplasty Demonstrates Better Outcomes Than Angular Stable Plate in the Treatment of Three-part and Four-part Proximal Humerus Fractures in Patients Older Than 70 Years.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2022-11-15

该研究纳入70岁以上三部分或四部分肱骨近端骨折患者,按肩胛下肌Goutallier/Fuchs萎缩分级非随机分配至反式全肩关节置换术(RTSA)组或切开复位内固定(ORIF)组。结果显示RTSA组在Constant、ASES、DASH评分及活动度方面均优于ORIF组,但两组并发症风险和翻修风险无显著差异。作者认为RTSA似乎是更可取的治疗方式,但需要更长期随访评估其使用寿命。

要点

  • 70岁以上三、四部分肱骨近端骨折,RTSA组Constant评分85.0±7.0优于ORIF组53.0±5.0。
  • RTSA组前屈135°±7°、外展131°±7°、外旋85°±5°均优于ORIF组。
  • 两组并发症风险无显著差异(RR 3.3,95%CI 0.3-30.7,p=0.30),翻修风险亦无显著差异。

核心结论

  • 在70岁以上三部分和四部分肱骨近端骨折患者中,一期RTSA比角稳定锁定钢板ORIF获得更好的患者报告结局评分和更好的活动度。
  • 作者认为这些发现可能有助于外科医生在老年患者中选择内固定或关节置换,但RTSA似乎更可取的同时需要更长期随访评估其使用寿命。
  • 与愈合后通常稳定的ORIF不同,关节置换术即使在愈合完成后仍存在持续松动和感染风险。

研究设计与样本

  • 2013年1月1日至2018年6月30日治疗235例肱骨近端骨折患者,162例符合条件,进一步排除73例后,81例接受RTSA、81例接受ORIF。
  • 按肩胛下肌Goutallier/Fuchs萎缩分级非随机分配:3级或4级萎缩接受RTSA,1级或2级萎缩接受ORIF。
  • RTSA组81例中9例失访或数据不完整,72例纳入分析;ORIF组81例中15例失访或数据不完整,66例纳入分析。
  • 两组中位随访均为53个月(范围24至72个月);RTSA组平均年龄76±2.9岁,ORIF组73±2.9岁。
  • RTSA组三部分骨折27例、四部分骨折45例;ORIF组三部分骨折24例、四部分骨折42例(p=0.48)。

主要发现

  • RTSA组Constant评分85.0±7.0 vs ORIF组53.0±5.0,平均差32(95%CI 30至34),p<0.01。
  • RTSA组ASES评分46.3±3.7 vs ORIF组30.0±3.5,平均差16(95%CI 15至18),p<0.01。
  • RTSA组DASH评分40.5±4.2 vs ORIF组30.5±2.6,平均差10(95%CI 9至11),p<0.01。
  • RTSA组前屈135°±7° vs ORIF组100°±6°,平均差35°(95%CI 33至37),p<0.01;外展131°±7° vs 104°±6°,平均差27°(95%CI 25°至29°),p<0.01;外旋85°±5° vs 64°±5°,平均差21°(95%CI 19°至23°),p<0.01;内旋45°±6° vs 40°±6°,平均差5°(95%CI 3°至7°),p<0.01。
  • 并发症风险ORIF组5%(3/66)vs RTSA组1%(1/72),相对风险3.3(95%CI 0.3至30.7),p=0.30;翻修风险RTSA组0%(0/72)vs ORIF组9%(6/66),相对风险0.07(95%CI 0.0至1.2),p=0.07。

关键数值与推荐

  • ORIF组影像学不良结局:内翻畸形愈合8%(5/66)、大结节吸收6%(4/66)、肱骨头缺血性坏死2%(1/66)。
  • RTSA组影像学不良结局:假体周围骨吸收24%(17/72),79%(57/72)无切迹。
  • 手术并发症定义为脱位、骨折、粘连性关节囊炎、神经损伤或手术部位感染;翻修率仅计算非计划翻修手术。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为,对于70岁以上三部分和四部分肱骨近端骨折患者,一期RTSA可能有助于外科医生在决策时优先考虑关节置换而非角稳定钢板内固定。
  • 作者指出RTSA似乎更可取,但需要更长期随访评估其使用寿命。
  • 作者提醒关节置换术后即使愈合完成仍存在持续松动和感染风险,与ORIF愈合后通常稳定不同。

局限性

  • 患者按肩胛下肌萎缩分级非随机分配,非随机化设计。
  • RTSA组9例、ORIF组15例失访或数据不完整。
  • 作者结论指出需要更长期随访评估RTSA使用寿命。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Proximal humeral fractures are traditionally treated with open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF), but reverse total shoulder arthroplasty (RTSA) has emerged as an increasingly popular treatment option. Although ORIF with angular locking plates is a common treatment for proximal humerus fractures, prior reports suggest high failure and complication rates. Although RTSA has become an increasingly popular option for complex proximal humeral head fractures given its low complication rates, there are concerns it may lead to limited postoperative ROM. Thus, the optimal treatment for patients older than 70 years from a functional and radiographic perspective remains unclear. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) In patients older than 70 years with three-part and four-part proximal humerus fractures, does RTSA result in better functional outcome scores (Constant, American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons [ASES], and DASH scores) than ORIF with a locking plate? (2) Does RTSA result in greater ROM than ORIF? (3) Does RTSA result in a lower risk of complications than ORIF? (4) In patients with either procedure, what are the rates of negative radiographic outcomes in those treated with ORIF (such as malunion, bone resorption, malalignment, or avascular necrosis) or those with RTSA (such as resorption, notching, and loosening)? (5) At a minimum of 2 years of follow-up, does ORIF result in a greater number of revision procedures than RTSA? METHODS: Between January 1, 2013, and June 30, 2018, we treated 235 patients for a proximal humeral fracture. We considered only patients without previous ipsilateral fracture or surgery, other fractures, or radial nerve injuries; age older than 70 years; and patients without neurologic disease or cognitive dysfunction as potentially eligible. Sixty-nine percent (162 patients) of the patients were eligible; a further 31% (73 patients) were excluded because 18% (13 of 73 patients) did not meet the inclusion criteria, 62% (45 patients) underwent nonoperative treatment, and 21% (15 patients) declined to participate. Patients were nonrandomly allocated to receive RTSA if they had supraspinatus Goutallier/Fuchs Grade 3 or 4 atrophy or ORIF if they had supraspinatus Goutallier/Fuchs Grade 1 or 2 atrophy. This left 81 patients who were treated with RTSA and another 81 patients who were treated with ORIF. Among the 81 patients treated with RTSA, 11% (nine patients) were lost to the minimum study follow-up of 2 years or had incomplete datasets, leaving 89% (72 patients) for analysis. Among the 81 patients treated with ORIF, 19% (15 patients) were lost before the minimal study follow-up of 2 years or had incomplete datasets, leaving 82% (66 patients) for analysis. The median follow-up for both groups was 53 months (range 24 to 72 months). The mean age was 76 ± 2.9 years in the RTSA group and 73 ± 2.9 years in the ORIF group. In the RTSA group, 27 patients had a three-part fracture and 45 patients had a four-part fracture. In the ORIF group, 24 patients had three-part fractures and 42 patients had four-part fractures (p = 0.48). Shoulder function was assessed using functional outcome questionnaires (ASES, DASH, and Constant) and active ROM measurements. A surgical complication was defined as any instance of dislocations, fractures, adhesive capsulitis, nerve injuries, or surgical site infections. Radiographic outcomes after ORIF (malunion, tuberosity resorption, or avascular necrosis) and RTSA (notching and osteolysis) were assessed. In calculating the revision rate, we considered unplanned revision procedures only. RESULTS: Compared with patients treated with ORIF, patients treated with RTSA had superior improvements in Constant (85.0 ± 7.0 versus 53.0 ± 5.0; mean difference 32 [95% CI 30 to 34]; p < 0.01), ASES (46.3 ± 3.7 versus 30.0 ± 3.5; mean difference 16 [95% CI 15 to 18]; p < 0.01), and DASH scores (40.5 ± 4.2 versus 30.5 ± 2.6; mean difference 10 [95% CI 9 to 11]; p < 0.01). The mean elevation was 135° ± 7° for patients with RTSA and 100° ± 6° for patients with ORIF (mean difference 35 o [95% CI 33 to 37]; p < 0.01). The mean abduction was 131° ± 7° for patients with RTSA and 104° ± 6° for those with ORIF (mean difference 27 o [95% CI 25° to 29°]; p < 0.01). The mean external rotation was 85° ± 5° for patients with RTSA and 64° ± 5° for those with ORIF (mean difference 21° [95% CI 19° to 23°]; p < 0.01). The mean internal rotation was 45° ± 6° for patients with RTSA and 40° ± 6° for those with ORIF (mean difference 5° [95% CI 3° to 7°]; p < 0.01). The risk of complications was not different between patients with ORIF and those with RTSA (5% [three of 66] versus 1% [one of 72]; relative risk 3.3 [95% CI 0.3 to 30.7]; p = 0.30). Among patients with ORIF, 8% had varus malunions (five of 66), 6% had resorption of the greater tuberosity (four of 66), and 2% had avascular necrosis of the humeral head (one of 66). In the RTSA group, 24% (17 of 72 patients) demonstrated reabsorption of periprosthetic bone and 79% of patients (57 of 72) exhibited no notching. The risk of revision was not different between the RTSA and ORIF groups (0% [0 of 72] versus 9% [six of 66]; relative risk 0.07 [95% CI 0.0 to 1.2]; p = 0.07). CONCLUSION: In patients older than 70 years with three-part and four-part proximal humerus fractures, primary RTSA resulted in better patient-reported outcome scores and better ROM than ORIF with an angular stable locking plate. Our findings might help surgeons decide between internal fixation and arthroplasty to surgically treat these injuries in older patients. Although RTSA seems to be a preferable treatment modality in view of these findings, longer follow-up is required to evaluate its longevity compared with ORIF with an angular locking plate. Dissimilar to ORIF, which is generally stable once healed, arthroplasties are at a continued risk for loosening and infection even after healing is complete. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level II, therapeutic study.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Lanzetti RM, Gaj E, Berlinberg EJ, et al. Reverse Total Shoulder Arthroplasty Demonstrates Better Outcomes Than Angular Stable Plate in the Treatment of Three-part and Four-part Proximal Humerus Fractures in Patients Older Than 70 Years. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2022. PMID: 36383078. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000002480

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。