骨科医务人员如何认识急性损伤后的良好患者结局及其障碍与促进因素?一项定性研究
该横断面定性研究从美国三个地理分布不同的I级创伤中心招募79名骨科医务人员,通过焦点小组和个体访谈探讨其对急性骨科损伤后良好结局、障碍与促进因素的认识。结果显示,医务人员对良好结局的定义自然包含生物医学因素,同时也带有细微的心理社会因素,且未经提示即从生物心理社会框架描述障碍与促进因素。
要点
- 骨科医务人员定义良好结局时既包含骨愈合、功能独立和疼痛缓解等生物医学因素,也包含心理康复和感到被倾听等心理社会因素。
- 医务人员将心理功能障碍(如适应不良的回避或再损伤恐惧)与生物医学因素交织,视为康复行为的障碍。
- 社会支持与「特权」(如职业或教育)等社会 socioeconomic 因素被视为良好结局的促进因素。
核心结论
- 尽管生物医学模型在临床实践中占主导,但各站点、各角色的医务人员在未经直接提示的情况下,仍以相互关联的生物心理社会因素来定义良好结局及其障碍与促进因素。
- 因此,类似的I级创伤中心可能比最初预期更愿意采纳生物心理社会照护方法。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面定性研究,从美国三个地理分布不同的I级创伤中心(乡村东南部、城市西南部和城市东北部)通过电子筛查调查招募94名骨科医务人员。
- 最终样本包括79名参与者:48名外科医生(20名主治医师、28名住院医师)和31名其他骨科专业人员。
- 由心理学研究者团队开展按提供者类型组织的焦点小组(每组约60分钟),随后进行5至10分钟的个体退出访谈。
- 确定所有主题均达到主题饱和,无需额外焦点小组;三名独立编码者识别良好结局、结局障碍和结局促进因素的编码,并应用于所有转录文本。
主要发现
- 骨科医务人员对良好结局的定义自然包括生物医学因素(骨愈合、功能独立和疼痛缓解),同时也以细微的心理社会因素为标志,包括患者需要从损伤相关的心理创伤中恢复并感到被倾听和理解。
- 关于感知的障碍,医务人员将心理与生物医学因素交织(例如「如果他们是吸烟者,如果他们有抑郁、焦虑……」),并讨论心理功能障碍(例如适应不良的回避或再损伤恐惧)如何限制康复期间的关键行为(如坚持物理治疗方案)。
- 未经提示,医务人员还引用了心理学研究中与韧性相关的术语,包括(低)「自我效能」、「灾难化思维」和(缺乏)心理「坚韧性」作为障碍。
- 关于感知的促进因素,出现了各种社会和社会经济因素,包括康复、社会支持与「特权」(如职业或教育)之间的生物社会联系。
- 这些观点在各站点和提供者类型中均有出现。
临床怎么用
- 作者指出,其他I级创伤中心可以鼓励采纳生物心理社会方法的领导者分享其观点,并培训其他提供者进行生物心理社会概念化和治疗。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Good clinical outcomes in orthopaedics are largely dictated by the biomedical model, despite mounting evidence of the role of psychosocial factors. Understanding orthopaedic providers' conceptualizations of good clinical outcomes and what facilitates and hinders them may highlight critical barriers and opportunities for training providers on biopsychosocial models of care and integrating them into practice. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) How do orthopaedic trauma healthcare providers define good clinical outcomes for their patients after an acute orthopaedic injury? (2) What do providers perceive as barriers to good outcomes? (3) What do providers perceive as facilitators of good outcomes? For each question, we explored providers' responses in a biopsychosocial framework. METHODS: In this cross-sectional, qualitative study, we recruited 94 orthopaedic providers via an electronic screening survey from three Level I trauma centers in geographically diverse regions of the United States (rural southeastern, urban southwestern, and urban northeastern). This study was part of the first phase of a multisite trial testing the implementation of a behavioral intervention to prevent chronic pain after acute orthopaedic injury. Of the 94 participants who were recruited, 88 completed the screening questionnaire. Of the 88 who completed it, nine could not participate because of scheduling conflicts. Thus, the final sample included 79 participants: 48 surgeons (20 attendings, 28 residents; 6% [three of 48] were women, 94% [45 of 48] were between 25 and 55 years old, 73% [35 of 48] were White, and 2% [one of 48] were Hispanic) and 31 other orthopaedic professionals (10 nurse practitioners, registered nurses, and physician assistants; 13 medical assistants; five physical therapists and social workers; and three research fellows; 68% [21 of 31] were women, 97% [30 of 31] were between 25 and 55 years old, 71% [22 of 31] were White, and 39% [12 of 31] were Hispanic). Using a semistructured interview, our team of psychology researchers conducted focus groups, organized by provider type at each site, followed by individual exit interviews (5- to 10-minute debriefing conversations and opportunities to voice additional opinions one-on-one with a focus group facilitator). In each focus group, providers were asked to share their perceptions of what constitutes a "good outcome for your patients," what factors facilitate these outcomes, and what factors are barriers to achieving those outcomes. Focus groups were approximately 60 minutes long. A research assistant recorded field notes during the focus groups to summarize insights gained and disseminate findings to the broader research team. Using this procedure, we determined that thematic saturation was reached for all topics and no additional focus groups were necessary. Three independent coders identified the codes of good outcomes, outcome barriers, and outcome facilitators and applied this coding framework to all transcripts. Three separate data interpreters collaboratively extracted themes related to biomedical, psychological, and social factors and corresponding inductive subthemes. RESULTS: Although orthopaedic providers' definitions of good outcomes naturally included biomedical factors (bone healing, functional independence, and pain alleviation), they were also marked by nuanced psychosocial factors, including the need for patients to recover from psychological trauma associated with injury and feel heard and understood-not just as outcome facilitators, but also as key outcomes themselves. Regarding perceived barriers to good outcomes, providers interwove psychological and biomedical factors (for example, "if they're a smoker, if they have depression, anxiety…") and discussed how psychological dysfunction (for example, maladaptive avoidance or fear of reinjury) can limit key behaviors during recovery (such as adherence to physical therapy regimens). Unprimed, providers also cited resiliency-related terms from psychological research, including (low) "self-efficacy," "catastrophic thinking," and (lack of) psychological "hardiness" as barriers. Regarding perceived facilitators of good outcomes, various social and socioeconomic factors emerged, including a biosocial connection between recovery, social support, and "privilege" (such as occupation or education). These perspectives emerged across sites and provider types. CONCLUSION: Although the biomedical model prevails in clinical practice, providers across all sites, in various roles, defined good outcomes and their barriers and facilitators in terms of interconnected biopsychosocial factors without direct priming to do so. Thus, similar Level I trauma centers may be more ready to adopt biopsychosocial care approaches than initially expected. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Providers' perspectives in this study aligned with a growing body of research on the role of biomedical and psychosocial factors in surgical outcomes and risk of transition to chronic pain. To translate these affirming attitudes into practice, other Level I trauma centers could encourage leaders who adopt biopsychosocial approaches to share their perspectives and train other providers in biopsychosocial conceptualization and treatment.
引用
- Doorley JD, Fishbein NS, Greenberg J, et al. How Do Orthopaedic Providers Conceptualize Good Patient Outcomes and Their Barriers and Facilitators After Acute Injury? A Qualitative Study. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2022. PMID: 36346734. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000002473
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。