国际注册中心:英国国家关节注册中心、北欧注册中心与澳大利亚骨科协会国家关节置换注册中心(AOANJRR)
本文介绍英国、北欧和澳大利亚三个国家级关节置换注册中心,描述其收集的数据元素、通过链接其他国家级注册中心或数据库可获得的数据点、数据完整性以及各数据库的优势与不足。文章指出,尽管注册中心数据样本量巨大,但观察性数据仍存在选择偏倚、终点定义差异和修订手术可及性影响修订率等局限。
要点
- 英国、北欧和澳大利亚的国家关节置换注册中心是骨科领域运行时间最长、影响力最大的大型数据库之一。
- 各注册中心每年在线发布年度报告,并可针对特定方面进行更详细分析以供专项研究。
- 使用注册中心数据时需注意观察性数据存在选择偏倚、终点定义差异及修订手术可及性影响修订率等局限。
核心结论
- 尽管注册中心数据存在诸多局限,但其优势在于报告了跨各类医院、外科医生和患者实施的大量手术的实际结果,对于识别趋势、发现特定植入物或植入物类别相关问题的早期迹象以及识别变量间的关联极具价值。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为描述性综述,介绍英国国家关节注册中心、北欧注册中心和澳大利亚骨科协会国家关节置换注册中心(AOANJRR)三个国家级关节置换注册中心。
主要发现
- 北欧注册中心是最早的注册中心之一,随后英国和澳大利亚也建立了优秀的注册中心。
- 各注册中心收集的数据元素、通过链接其他国家级注册中心或数据库可获得的数据点、数据完整性以及各数据库的优势与不足在文中均有描述。
- 各注册中心均每年在线发布年度报告,并可针对特定方面进行更详细分析以供专项研究。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 尽管样本量巨大,但观察性数据仍存在诸多局限。
- 在选择患者接受何种手术方面存在强烈的选择偏倚。
- 不同技能水平的外科医生可能对某种技术或植入物的使用存在差异。
- 各注册中心收集的终点差异很大,例如有些仅报告导致翻修的髋关节脱位而非所有脱位。
- 在翻修手术等待时间长的国家,注册中心报告的翻修率可能比翻修手术更易获得的国家人为偏低。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
National-level joint arthroplasty registries were among the first large orthopaedic surgery databases and represent some of the longest-running and most influential big databases in our profession. Nordic registries were among the first registries and were followed by excellent registries in the United Kingdom and Australia. In this article, we describe each of these registries and highlight the data elements collected, the data points that can be obtained by linking the national arthroplasty registries to other national registries or databases, the completeness of data, and the strengths and weaknesses of each database. Each of these registries publishes an annual report that is available online, and each also can do more detailed analysis of certain aspects of its data for special studies.When evaluating and interpreting data from national joint registries, the user should be aware that, despite the power of huge numbers, there remain numerous limitations to the observational data. Strong selection biases exist with regard to which patients are chosen for which procedure. Surgeons of different skill levels may use one technique or implant differentially compared with another. The end points that registries collect differ widely: for example, some report only hip dislocations leading to revision rather than all dislocations. Registries in countries in which there are long wait times for revision surgery may report artificially low revision rates compared with countries in which revision surgery is more easily accessible. Despite these limitations, registries have the merit of reporting the actual results of huge numbers of surgical procedures performed across the spectrum of hospitals, surgeons, and patients, making the data extremely powerful for identifying trends, identifying early signs of problems related to certain implants or implant classes, and identifying associations between variables that can be further studied to determine if the effect is causal.
引用
- Porter M, Rolfson O, de Steiger R, et al. International Registries: U.K. National Joint Registry, Nordic Registries, and Australian Orthopaedic Association National Joint Replacement Registry (AOANJRR). J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2022. PMID: 36260040. doi:10.2106/JBJS.22.00561
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。