具有直接数据抽象的大型手术数据库:VASQIP与ACS-NSQIP
本文综述了退伍军人事务部手术质量改进计划(VASQIP)和美国外科医师学会国家手术质量改进计划(ACS-NSQIP)两个手术数据库。两者均由经过培训的医学数据抽象员对参与医院的部分手术病例进行病历直接数据抽象,提供高质量的手术及术后早期数据。VASQIP近期更新包括建立退伍军人事务部系统全髋关节登记库;ACS-NSQIP的数据要素及其支持的骨科质量改进与结局研究在文中得到详细回顾,并讨论了未收集数据及其局限性。
要点
- VASQIP和ACS-NSQIP均通过培训过的数据抽象员对部分手术病例进行病历直接抽象来获取高质量数据。
- VASQIP近期更新包括建立退伍军人事务部系统的全髋关节登记库。
- ACS-NSQIP的数据要素及未收集数据带来的局限性在文中得到详细回顾。
核心结论
- VASQIP和ACS-NSQIP的数据要素与数据完整性为其他大数据项目建立了重要基准,后者常尝试使用成本更低的替代数据收集方法以实现更广泛或全国性数据收集。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为综述,回顾两个历史相关的手术质量改进项目:VASQIP和ACS-NSQIP。
- 两项目均对参与医院全部手术中的部分样本,由经过专门培训并具备资质的数据抽象员进行类似的数据抽象。
主要发现
- VASQIP由Nicholas J. Giori医学博士在本文第一部分详细介绍,使用经过培训的抽象员,近期更新包括建立退伍军人事务部系统的全髋关节登记库。
- ACS-NSQIP由Elizabeth B. Habermann博士、公共卫生硕士在第二部分详细回顾,包括收集的数据要素、其支持的骨科质量改进与结局研究示例,以及未收集数据及其局限性。
- ACS-NSQIP效仿美国退伍军人事务部先前启动的非常相似的VASQIP。
局限性
- ACS-NSQIP存在未收集的数据,由此带来局限性,文中提供了相关信息。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Direct data abstraction from a patient's chart by experienced medical professional data abstractors has been the historical gold standard for quality and accuracy in clinical medical research. The limiting challenge to population-wide studies for quality and public health purposes is the high personnel costs associated with very large-scale efforts of this type. Two historically related programs that are at least partially able to successfully circumvent this problem and provide high-quality data relating to surgical procedures and the early postoperative period are reviewed in this article. Both utilize similar data abstraction efforts by specially trained and qualified medical abstractors of a sample subset of the total procedures performed at participating hospitals.The Veterans Affairs Surgical Quality Improvement Program (VASQIP), detailed by Nicholas J. Giori, MD, PhD, in the first section of this article, makes use of trained abstractors and has undergone recent additions and updates, including the development of an associated total hip registry for the VA system. The data elements and data integrity provided by both of these programs establish important benchmarks for other "big data" efforts, which often attempt to use alternative less-expensive methods of data collection in order to achieve more widespread or even nationwide data collection.In the second section, Elizabeth B. Habermann, PhD, MPH, provides a detailed review of the American College of Surgeons National Surgical Quality Improvement Program (ACS NSQIP), the data elements collected, and examples of the range of quality improvement and outcomes studies in orthopaedic surgery that it has made possible, along with information on data that have not been collected and the resulting limitations. The ACS NSQIP was actually modeled after the very similar earlier effort started by the United States Department of Veterans Affairs (VA).
引用
- Habermann EB, Harris AHS, Giori NJ, et al. Large Surgical Databases with Direct Data Abstraction: VASQIP and ACS-NSQIP. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2022. PMID: 36260037. doi:10.2106/JBJS.22.00596
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。