文献速递运动医学关节外科

首次翻修前交叉韧带重建失败的处理:非手术管理与二次翻修重建的临床结局比较——来自SANTI组的研究

Management of the Failed First Revision ACL Reconstruction: Clinical Outcomes of Nonsurgical Management Versus Second Revision ACL Reconstruction From the SANTI Group.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Sports Med · 2022-09-08

该队列研究(证据等级3)评估首次翻修前交叉韧带重建(RACLR)失败后二次RACLR与非手术管理的结局。41例患者平均随访104±52.7个月,二次RACLR组在Tegner、Lysholm、KOOS生活质量及KOOS运动与娱乐评分上均显著优于非手术组,但两组重返运动率均较高。非手术管理是未能达到良好/优秀Lysholm评分的唯一显著预测因素。

要点

  • 二次RACLR组Tegner评分6.35 vs 非手术组4.8(P=.012),Lysholm评分88.5 vs 78.3(P=.0353)。
  • 二次RACLR组KOOS生活质量72.6 vs 非手术组56.3(P=.0490),KOOS运动与娱乐81.4 vs 62.5(P=.0033)。
  • 二次RACLR组达到KOOS运动与娱乐可接受症状状态比例74.2% vs 非手术组30%(P=.015)。

核心结论

  • 二次RACLR与非手术管理首次RACLR失败均与较高的重返运动率相关。
  • 二次RACLR在Tegner、Lysholm、KOOS生活质量及KOOS运动与娱乐评分上显著优于非手术管理。
  • 非手术治疗是末次随访时未能达到良好/优秀Lysholm评分的唯一显著预测因素,可能与该组膝关节稳定性较差有关。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究为队列研究,证据等级3。
  • 共评估41例首次RACLR失败患者,平均随访104±52.7个月(范围40-140个月)。
  • 31例接受二次RACLR,10例选择非手术管理;所有参与者无论接受非手术治疗还是二次RACLR均遵循相同的康复方案。
  • 随访包括定期临床复查和研究结束时标准化电话访谈,患者报告结局指标在末次随访时记录。

主要发现

  • 二次RACLR组Tegner评分6.35 vs 非手术组4.8(P=.012)。
  • 二次RACLR组Lysholm评分88.5 vs 非手术组78.3(P=.0353)。
  • 二次RACLR组KOOS生活质量评分72.6 vs 非手术组56.3(P=.0490)。
  • 二次RACLR组KOOS运动与娱乐评分81.4 vs 非手术组62.5(P=.0033)。
  • 二次RACLR组达到KOOS运动与娱乐可接受症状状态比例74.2% vs 非手术组30%(P=.015)。

关键数值与推荐

  • 多因素分析中,未能达到良好/优秀Lysholm评分的最重要预测因素为非手术管理(P=.0095)。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: The optimum management strategy after failure of revision anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (RACLR) is not clearly defined. The literature evaluating differences in outcomes between surgical and nonsurgical management is sparse. PURPOSE/HYPOTHESIS: The purpose was to evaluate the outcomes of surgical versus nonsurgical management of failed first RACLR. It was hypothesized that the long-term clinical outcomes of second RACLR would be superior with respect to knee stability, return to sport, and patient-reported outcome measures when compared with nonsurgical treatment. STUDY DESIGN: Cohort study; Level of evidence, 3. METHODS: Patients who experienced failure of first RACLR were evaluated. All participants followed the same rehabilitation protocol regardless of whether they underwent nonsurgical treatment or a second RACLR. Follow-up comprised regular clinical review and a standardized telephone interview at the end of the study period. Patient-reported outcome measures were recorded at the final follow-up. RESULTS: A total of 41 patients with a mean follow-up of 104 ± 52.7 months (range, 40-140 months) were evaluated. Of these, 31 underwent a second RACLR, and 10 patients chose nonsurgical treatment. There was a high rate of return to sport in both groups, but patients undergoing second RACLR had significantly better Tegner (6.35 vs 4.8; P = .012), Lysholm (88.5 vs 78.3; P = .0353), Knee injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score (KOOS) Quality of Life (72.6 vs 56.3; P = .0490), and KOOS Sport and Recreation scores (81.4 vs 62.5; P = .0033). Significantly more patients undergoing second RACLR achieved the Patient Acceptable Symptom State for KOOS Sport and Recreation than those who underwent nonsurgical management (74.2% vs 30%; P = .015). The most important predictor of failure to achieve a good/excellent Lysholm score in multivariate analysis was nonsurgical management (P = .0095). CONCLUSION: Both second RACLR and nonsurgical management of failed first RACLR were associated with high rates of return to sport. However, second RACLR was associated with significantly better functional outcome scores with respect to Tegner, Lysholm, KOOS Quality of Life, and KOOS Sport and Recreation scores compared to nonsurgical management. In addition, nonsurgical treatment was the only significant predictor of failure to achieve a good/excellent Lysholm score at the final follow-up, and this was likely a function of inferior knee stability in that group.

来源:Am J Sports Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Fradin T, Saithna A, Haidar IM, et al. Management of the Failed First Revision ACL Reconstruction: Clinical Outcomes of Nonsurgical Management Versus Second Revision ACL Reconstruction From the SANTI Group. Am J Sports Med. 2022. PMID: 36074032. doi:10.1177/03635465221119202

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。