文献速递关节外科

患者在接受全关节置换术时会考虑哪些因素?一项离散选择实验

Which Factors Are Considered by Patients When Considering Total Joint Arthroplasty? A Discrete-choice Experiment.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2022-09-15

该离散选择实验纳入150例拟行全髋或全膝关节置换术的患者,评估疼痛、身体功能、重返工作及感染风险等8个属性对手术决策的影响。结果显示身体功能从50%改善至100%是最重要因素(β=-0.80),患者愿接受37%的假想感染风险换取该功能改善。

要点

  • 身体功能从50%改善至100%是患者决策中最看重的因素(β=-0.80)。
  • 疼痛从重度改善至轻微(β=-0.59)和重返工作能力(β=-0.38)也是重要影响因素。
  • 仅基线重度疼痛患者认为感染风险影响决策(β=-0.27),并愿接受24%感染风险换取功能改善。

核心结论

  • 患者认为疼痛缓解、身体功能改善和感染风险是全关节置换术决策中最重要的属性。
  • 基线重度疼痛患者表现出愿意承担假想的高感染风险以换取身体功能改善或疼痛缓解。
  • 作者认为外科医生在讨论关节置换时应个体化说明患者达到显著功能改善的可能性。
  • 作者建议未来研究应定量评估患者在手术咨询后对手术风险的理解,尤其是最易耐受风险的患者。

研究设计与样本

  • 离散选择实验(DCE),于2021年10月至2022年3月从两位关节置换外科医生的门诊连续招募新患者。
  • 纳入年龄大于18岁、因膝或髋相关问题预约咨询且无初次全膝或全髋置换史的新患者。
  • 517例新患者中56%(292/517)符合标准并受邀完成DCE,最终51%(150/292)完成DCE。
  • DCE包含10个假想场景,每个场景要求患者在手术与非手术结局之间选择,涉及8个属性(疼痛、身体功能、重返工作、感染风险、再手术、植入物失败导致提前翻修、深静脉血栓和死亡)。
  • 采用条件logit回归控制DCE内潜在混杂属性,通过比较各因素β系数绝对值评估相对重要性。

主要发现

  • 身体功能从50%改善至100%的β系数为-0.80(95%CI -0.9至-0.7;p<0.01),绝对值最大,为患者最看重的因素。
  • 疼痛从重度改善至轻微的β系数为-0.59(95%CI -0.72至-0.46;p<0.01)。
  • 能重返工作相比不能重返工作的β系数为-0.38(95%CI -0.48至-0.28;p<0.01)。
  • 感染风险的β系数为-0.22(95%CI -0.30至-0.14;p<0.01)。
  • 为通过全关节置换术将身体功能从50%改善至100%和将疼痛从重度改善至轻微,患者分别愿意接受假想的绝对37%和27%感染风险。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为外科医生在讨论关节置换的每次门诊中应个体化说明患者达到显著功能改善的可能性。
  • 作者指出外科医生应意识到身体功能最受限和基线疼痛最高的患者更愿意接受全关节置换术伴随的潜在危及生命和破坏性风险,尤其是感染。
  • 作者认为患者似乎低估了感染的危害,外科医生需特别用心解释假体周围感染对患者的伤害或致死程度。

局限性

  • 未来研究应聚焦于定量评估患者在手术咨询后对手术风险的理解,尤其是可能最耐受风险的患者。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: TKA and THA are major surgical procedures, and they are associated with the potential for serious, even life-threatening complications. Patients must weigh the risks of these complications against the benefits of surgery. However, little is known about the relative importance patients place on the potential complications of surgery compared with any potential benefit the procedures may achieve. Furthermore, patient preferences may often be discordant with surgeon preferences regarding the treatment decision-making process. A discrete-choice experiment (DCE) is a quantitative survey technique designed to elicit patient preferences by presenting patients with two or more hypothetical scenarios. Each scenario is composed of several attributes or factors, and the relative extent to which respondents prioritize these attributes can be quantified to assess preferences when making a decision, such as whether to pursue lower extremity arthroplasty. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: In this DCE, we asked: (1) Which patient-related factors (such as pain and functional level) and surgery-related factors (such as the risk of infection, revision, or death) are influential in patients' decisions about whether to undergo lower extremity arthroplasty? (2) Which of these factors do patients emphasize the most when making this decision? METHODS: A DCE was designed with the following attributes: pain; physical function; return to work; and infection risks, reoperation, implant failure leading to premature revision, deep vein thrombosis, and mortality. From October 2021 to March 2022, we recruited all new patients to two arthroplasty surgeons' clinics who were older than 18 years and scheduled for a consultation for knee- or hip-related complaints who had no previous history of a primary TKA or THA. A total of 56% (292 of 517) of new patients met the inclusion criteria and were approached with the opportunity to complete the DCE. Among the cohort, 51% (150 of 292) of patients completed the DCE. Patients were administered the DCE, which consisted of 10 hypothetical scenarios that had the patient decide between a surgical and nonsurgical outcome, each consisting of varying levels of eight attributes (such as infection, reoperation, and ability to return to work). A subsequent demographic questionnaire followed this assessment. To answer our first research question about the patient-related and surgery-related factors that most influence patients' decisions to undergo lower extremity arthroplasty, we used a conditional logit regression to control for potentially confounding attributes from within the DCE and determine which variables shifted a patient's determination to pursue surgery. To answer our second question, about which of these factors received the greatest priority by patients, we compared the relevant importance of each factor, as determined by each factor's beta coefficient, against each other influential factor. A larger absolute value of beta coefficient reflects a relatively higher degree of importance placed on a variable compared with other variables within our study. Of the respondents, 57% (85 of 150) were women, and the mean age at the time of participation was 64 ± 10 years. Most respondents (95% [143 of 150]) were White. Regarding surgery, 38% (57 of 150) were considering THA, 59% (88 of 150) were considering TKA, and 3% (5 of 150) were considering both. Among the cohort, 49% (74 of 150) of patients reported their average pain level as severe, or 7 to 10 on a scale from 0 to 10, and 47% (71 of 150) reported having 50% of full physical function. RESULTS: Variables that were influential to respondents when deciding on lower extremity total joint arthroplasty were improvement from severe pain to minimal pain (β coefficient: -0.59 [95% CI -0.72 to -0.46]; p < 0.01), improvement in physical function level from 50% to 100% (β: -0.80 [95% CI -0.9 to -0.7]; p < 0.01), ability to return to work versus inability to return (β: -0.38 [95% CI -0.48 to -0.28]; p < 0.01), and the surgery-related factor of risk of infection (β: -0.22 [95% CI -0.30 to -0.14]; p < 0.01). Improvement in physical function from 50% to 100% was the most important for patients making this decision because it had the largest absolute coefficient value of -0.80. To improve physical function from 50% to 100% and reduce pain from severe to minimal because of total joint arthroplasty, patients were willing to accept a hypothetical absolute (and not merely an incrementally increased) 37% and 27% risk of infection, respectively. When we stratified our analysis by respondents' preoperative pain levels, we identified that only patients with severe pain at the time of their appointment found the risk of infection influential in their decision-making process (β: -0.27 [95% CI -0.37 to -0.17]; p = 0.01) and were willing to accept a 24% risk of infection to improve their physical functioning from 50% to 100%. CONCLUSION: Our study revealed that patients consider pain alleviation, physical function improvement, and infection risk to be the most important attributes when considering total joint arthroplasty. Patients with severe baseline pain demonstrated a willingness to take on a hypothetically high infection risk as a tradeoff for improved physical function or pain relief. Because patients seemed to prioritize postoperative physical function so highly in our study, it is especially important that surgeons customize their presentations about the likelihood an individual patient will achieve a substantial functional improvement as part of any office visit where arthroplasty is discussed. Future studies should focus on quantitatively assessing patients' understanding of surgical risks after a surgical consultation, especially in patients who may be the most risk tolerant. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Surgeons should be aware that patients with the most limited physical function and the highest baseline pain levels are more willing to accept the more potentially life-threatening and devastating risks that accompany total joint arthroplasty, specifically infection. The degree to which patients seemed to undervalue the harms of infection (based on our knowledge and perception of those harms) suggests that surgeons need to take particular care in explaining the degree to which a prosthetic joint infection can harm or kill patients who develop one.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Salimy MS, Humphrey TJ, Katakam A, et al. Which Factors Are Considered by Patients When Considering Total Joint Arthroplasty? A Discrete-choice Experiment. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2022. PMID: 36111881. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000002358

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。