动态韧带内稳定前交叉韧带修复与前交叉韧带重建后器械化膝关节松弛度及患者报告结局相当:一项随机对照试验的5年结果
这项随机对照试验将85例急性前交叉韧带撕裂患者分配至动态韧带内稳定(DIS)前交叉韧带修复组或自体腘绳肌腱前交叉韧带重建组,5年随访时两组Rolimeter测得的胫骨前移侧侧差值(ΔATT)分别为1.7±1.6 mm与1.4±1.3 mm(P=.334),IKDC主观评分分别为94.1±9.9与89.9±7.8(P=.047),Lysholm评分分别为97.0±5.4与94.5±5.5(P=.322);复发性不稳分别为35%与20%(P=.09),翻修手术分别为38%与27%(P=.118)。
要点
- 5年时ΔATT修复组1.7±1.6 mm vs 重建组1.4±1.3 mm,P=.334,无显著差异。
- 5年IKDC主观评分修复组94.1±9.9 vs 重建组89.9±7.8,P=.047。
- 复发性不稳修复组35% vs 重建组20%,P=.09;翻修手术38% vs 27%,P=.118。
核心结论
- 前交叉韧带修复联合DIS术后5年,器械化膝关节松弛度及患者报告结局与前交叉韧带重建相当。
- 尽管修复与重建之间未发现显著差异,仍需对复发性不稳(分别为35%与20%)和翻修手术(分别为38%与27%)的发生率进行审慎评估。
- 年轻年龄和高术前活动水平是两组复发性不稳的主要危险因素。
- 前交叉韧带重建仍是前交叉韧带撕裂治疗的金标准,但本研究支持将DIS前交叉韧带修复作为年龄≥25岁、低至中等活动水平(Tegner评分<7)急性前交叉韧带撕裂患者的一种可行选择。
研究设计与样本
- 随机对照试验,证据等级1级。
- 共85例急性前交叉韧带撕裂患者随机接受DIS前交叉韧带修复或自体半腱肌腱前交叉韧带重建。
- 主要结局为术后5年Rolimeter测得的胫骨前移侧侧差值(ΔATT)。
- 随访在术后1年、2年和5年进行;患者报告结局采用Tegner活动量表、国际膝关节文献委员会(IKDC)主观评分和Lysholm评分评估。
- 记录复发性不稳、其他并发症和翻修手术率;事先进行效力分析,采用Friedman检验、Mann-Whitney U检验和Bonferroni校正,显著性设为P<.05。
主要发现
- 纳入时平均年龄修复组28.3±11.5岁,重建组27.1±11.5岁。
- 术后5年共64例患者可随访(修复组43例中34例[79%];重建组42例中30例[71%])。
- 5年时ΔATT修复组1.7±1.6 mm vs 重建组1.4±1.3 mm(P=.334)。
- 两组术前患者报告结局在术后1年即恢复,并至术后2年和5年保持平台期;5年时Lysholm评分修复组97.0±5.4 vs 重建组94.5±5.5(P=.322),IKDC主观评分修复组94.1±9.9 vs 重建组89.9±7.8(P=.047)。
- 术后5年修复组12例(35%;年龄<25岁:n=10/12;Tegner评分≥7:n=10/12)出现复发性不稳,其中10例接受单期翻修前交叉韧带重建;重建组6例(20%;年龄<25岁:n=6/6;Tegner评分≥7:n=5/6)出现复发性不稳,其中5例需要分期翻修;两组复发性不稳(P=.09)或前交叉韧带翻修手术(P=.118)差异无统计学意义;两组复发性不稳均与年龄<25岁和Tegner评分>7相关。
关键数值与推荐
- 主要结局:5年ΔATT修复组1.7±1.6 mm vs 重建组1.4±1.3 mm(P=.334)。
- 5年Lysholm评分修复组97.0±5.4 vs 重建组94.5±5.5(P=.322)。
- 5年IKDC主观评分修复组94.1±9.9 vs 重建组89.9±7.8(P=.047)。
- 5年复发性不稳修复组35% vs 重建组20%(P=.09);翻修手术修复组38% vs 重建组27%(P=.118)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,尽管前交叉韧带重建仍是前交叉韧带撕裂治疗的金标准,本研究支持将DIS前交叉韧带修复作为年龄≥25岁、低至中等活动水平(Tegner评分<7)急性前交叉韧带撕裂患者的一种可行选择。
- 作者指出,尽管修复与重建之间未发现显著差异,仍需对复发性不稳(分别为35%与20%)和翻修手术(分别为38%与27%)的发生率进行审慎评估。
- 作者报告,修复组每例复发性不稳均可行单期翻修前交叉韧带重建。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Technical innovation has led to the renaissance of anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) repair in the past decade. PURPOSE/HYPOTHESIS: The present study aimed to compare instrumented knee joint laxity and patient-reported outcomes (PROs) after ACL repair with those after primary ACL reconstruction for acute isolated ACL tears. It was hypothesized that ACL repair would lead to comparable knee joint stability and PROs at 5 years postoperatively in comparison with ACL reconstruction. STUDY DESIGN: Randomized controlled trial; Level of evidence, 1. METHODS: A total of 85 patients with acute ACL tears were randomized to undergo either ACL repair using dynamic intraligamentary stabilization (DIS) or primary ACL reconstruction with a semitendinosus tendon autograft. The primary outcome was the side-to-side difference in anterior tibial translation (ΔATT) assessed by Rolimeter testing at 5 years postoperatively. Follow-up examinations were performed at 1, 2, and 5 years. PROs were assessed using the Tegner activity scale, the International Knee Documentation Committee (IKDC) subjective score, and the Lysholm score. Furthermore, the rates of recurrent instability, other complications, and revision surgery were recorded. A power analysis was performed a priori, and the Friedman test, Mann-Whitney U test, and Bonferroni correction were applied for statistical comparisons with significance set at P < .05. RESULTS: The mean age at inclusion was 28.3 ± 11.5 years in the ACL repair group and 27.1 ± 11.5 years in the ACL reconstruction group. At 5 years postoperatively, a total of 64 patients (ACL repair: n = 34 of 43 [79%]; ACL reconstruction: n = 30 of 42 [71%]) were available for follow-up. At 5 years, ΔATT was 1.7 ± 1.6 mm in the ACL repair group and 1.4 ± 1.3 mm in the ACL reconstruction group (P = .334). Preinjury PROs were restored as soon as 1 year after surgery and plateaued until 2 and 5 years postoperatively in both groups. At the 5-year follow-up, the mean Lysholm score was 97.0 ± 5.4 versus 94.5 ± 5.5 (P = .322), respectively, and the mean IKDC subjective score was 94.1 ± 9.9 versus 89.9 ± 7.8 (P = .047), respectively, in the ACL repair group versus ACL reconstruction group. At 5 years postoperatively, 12 patients in the ACL repair group (35%; age <25 years: n = 10/12; Tegner score ≥7: n = 10/12) had recurrent instability, of whom 10 underwent single-stage revision ACL reconstruction. In the ACL reconstruction group, there were 6 patients with recurrent instability (20%; age <25 years: n = 6/6; Tegner score ≥7: n = 5/6); however, in 5 patients, staged revision was required. Differences between both groups regarding recurrent instability (P = .09) or ACL revision surgery (P = .118) were not statistically significant. Recurrent instability was associated with age <25 years and Tegner score >7 in both groups. CONCLUSION: At 5 years after ACL repair with DIS, instrumented knee joint laxity and PROs were comparable with those after ACL reconstruction. Although no significant difference was found between repair and reconstruction, a critical appraisal of the rates of recurrent instability (35% vs 20%, respectively) and revision surgery (38% vs 27%, respectively) is needed. Young age and a high preinjury activity level were the main risk factors for recurrent instability in both groups. However, single-stage revision ACL reconstruction was possible in each case in the ACL repair group. Although ACL reconstruction remains the gold standard in the treatment of ACL tears, the present study supports the use of ACL repair with DIS as a feasible option to treat acute ACL tears in patients aged ≥25 years with low to moderate activity levels (Tegner score <7). REGISTRATION: DRKS00015466 (German Clinical Trials Register).
引用
- Glasbrenner J, Raschke MJ, Kittl C, et al. Comparable Instrumented Knee Joint Laxity and Patient-Reported Outcomes After ACL Repair With Dynamic Intraligamentary Stabilization or ACL Reconstruction: 5-Year Results of a Randomized Controlled Trial. Am J Sports Med. 2022. PMID: 36005281. doi:10.1177/03635465221117777
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。