遵循特拉华-奥斯陆前交叉韧带队列治疗算法的患者中涌现出四种不同的5年膝关节功能轨迹
该队列研究纳入276例急性首次完全单侧前交叉韧带损伤患者,均先接受5周神经肌肉与力量训练,再经共享决策选择前交叉韧带重建加康复或单纯康复。基于IKDC-SKF识别出低、中、高及先高后下降四种5年轨迹,88%患者处于中、高轨迹;伴随半月板损伤与新发膝关节损伤分别与不良轨迹相关。
要点
- 共识别出低(8.0%)、中(51.4%)、高(38.0%)和先高后下降(2.5%)四种IKDC-SKF 5年轨迹。
- 88%遵循该治疗算法的患者处于中、高轨迹,表现为良好改善与高分。
- 伴随半月板损伤与低轨迹(vs 中轨迹)显著相关,新发膝关节损伤是先高后下降轨迹的重要特征。
核心结论
- 识别出4种不同的患者报告膝关节功能5年轨迹,提示前交叉韧带损伤患者存在4个亚组。
- 遵循该治疗算法的患者中88%处于中、高轨迹,其特征为良好改善与高分。
- 伴随半月板损伤与新发膝关节损伤是不利的低轨迹和先高后下降轨迹的重要因素,这些关联为探索性但支持轨迹的有效性。
- 研究结果可有助于患者预后教育,并支持持续二级损伤预防的重要性。
研究设计与样本
- 队列研究,证据等级3。
- 纳入276例急性首次完全单侧前交叉韧带损伤患者。
- 所有患者先接受5周神经肌肉与力量训练,随后经共享决策选择前交叉韧带重建加康复或单纯康复。
- 在最近一次随访中,62%患者接受早期前交叉韧带重建(5周程序后<6个月),11%接受延迟重建(5周程序后>6个月),27%接受单纯渐进康复。
- 在纳入时、5周程序后及前交叉韧带重建或完成5周程序后6个月、1年、2年、5年完成国际膝关节文献委员会主观膝关节量表(IKDC-SKF);采用基于组的轨迹模型识别轨迹,多项逻辑回归评估轨迹归属关联。
主要发现
- 识别出四种IKDC-SKF轨迹:低(n=22,队列8.0%)、中(n=142,51.4%)、高(n=105,38.0%)和先高后下降(n=7,2.5%)。
- 高轨迹在纳入时评分高于中轨迹,但二者均在1年内大幅改善,此后保持稳定高分。
- 先高后下降轨迹起始评分也相对较高并在1年内大幅改善,但在2至5年间出现大幅恶化。
- 低轨迹起始评分低且改善极小。
- 新发膝关节损伤是先高后下降轨迹的重要特征;伴随半月板损伤与低轨迹(vs 中轨迹)显著相关;纳入时测量的早期/术前股四头肌力量与单腿跳跃对称性与高轨迹(vs 中轨迹)显著相关。
关键数值与推荐
- 低轨迹n=22(8.0%),中轨迹n=142(51.4%),高轨迹n=105(38.0%),先高后下降轨迹n=7(2.5%)。
- 62%患者接受早期前交叉韧带重建(5周程序后<6个月),11%接受延迟重建(5周程序后>6个月),27%接受单纯渐进康复。
- 伴随半月板损伤与低轨迹(vs 中轨迹)显著相关;早期/术前股四头肌力量与单腿跳跃对称性与高轨迹(vs 中轨迹)显著相关。
临床怎么用
- 作者指出研究结果可有助于患者预后教育,并支持持续二级损伤预防的重要性。
- 由于本队列的入选标准与程序,该模型只能推广至无重大伴随损伤且遵循类似治疗算法的运动员。
局限性
- 由于本队列的入选标准与程序,该模型只能推广至无重大伴随损伤且遵循类似治疗算法的运动员。
- 伴随半月板损伤与新发膝关节损伤的关联为探索性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Impairments and dysfunction vary considerably after anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury, and distinct subgroups may exist. PURPOSE: (1) To identify subgroups of patients with ACL injury who share common trajectories of patient-reported knee function from initial presentation to 5 years after a treatment algorithm where they chose either ACL reconstruction (ACLR) plus rehabilitation or rehabilitation alone. (2) To assess associations with trajectory affiliation. STUDY DESIGN: Cohort study; Level of evidence, 3. METHODS: We included 276 patients with a acute first-time complete unilateral ACL injury. All patients underwent a 5-week neuromuscular and strength training program before a shared decision-making process about treatment. Within their latest attended follow-up, 62% of patients had undergone early ACLR (<6 months after the 5-week program), 11% delayed ACLR (>6 months after the 5-week program), and 27% progressive rehabilitation alone. Patients completed the International Knee Documentation Committee Subjective Knee Form (IKDC-SKF) at inclusion, after the 5-week program, and at 6 months, 1 year, 2 years, and 5 years after ACLR or completion of the 5-week program (patients treated with rehabilitation alone). We used group-based trajectory modeling to identify trajectories of IKDC-SKF and multinomial logistic regression to assess associations with trajectory affiliation. RESULTS: Four distinct trajectories of IKDC-SKF were identified: Low (n = 22; 8.0% of the cohort), Moderate (n = 142; 51.4%), High (n = 105; 38.0%), and High Before Declining (n = 7; 2.5%). The High trajectory had higher scores at inclusion than the Moderate trajectory, but both improved considerably within 1 year and had thereafter stable high scores. The High Before Declining trajectory also started relatively high and improved considerably within 1 year but experienced a large deterioration between 2 and 5 years. The Low trajectory started low and had minimal improvement. New knee injuries were important characteristics of the High Before Declining trajectory, concomitant meniscal injuries were significantly associated with following the Low (vs Moderate) trajectory, and early/preoperative quadriceps strength and hop symmetry (measured at inclusion) were significantly associated with following the High (vs Moderate) trajectory. CONCLUSION: We identified 4 distinct 5-year trajectories of patient-reported knee function, indicating 4 subgroups of patients with ACL injury. Importantly, 88% of the patients who followed our treatment algorithm followed the Moderate and High trajectories characterized by good improvement and high scores. Due to eligibility criteria and procedures in our cohort, we can only generalize our model to athletes without major concomitant injuries who follow a similar treatment algorithm. Concomitant meniscal injuries and new knee injuries were important factors in the unfavorable Low and High Before Declining trajectories. These associations were exploratory but support the trajectories' validity. Our findings can contribute to patient education about prognosis and underpin the importance of continued secondary injury prevention.
引用
- Pedersen M, Grindem H, Berg B, et al. Four Distinct 5-Year Trajectories of Knee Function Emerge in Patients Who Followed the Delaware-Oslo ACL Cohort Treatment Algorithm. Am J Sports Med. 2022. PMID: 35975945. doi:10.1177/03635465221116313
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。