支持患者从骨质疏松治疗中获得最佳效果:关于何种干预有效、对谁有效及在何种情境下有效的快速现实主义综述
本研究为快速现实主义综述,旨在理解哪些情境条件和机制能促成骨质疏松药物优化干预。识别出患者与从业者/医疗系统的5个情境时间点,发现支持患者知情决策的干预似可影响长期治疗承诺,而仅支持实际服药能力仅在结合其他方法时才有帮助,且需进一步研究可持续、以患者为中心的长期照护模式。
要点
- 支持患者知情决策的干预似可影响长期治疗承诺。
- 仅降低治疗负担或提醒等实际服药支持,需结合其他方法才有帮助。
- 支持初级保健临床医生决策及整合初级与二级保健似可改善治疗起始和依从率。
核心结论
- 需要进一步研究以识别可持续、整合、以患者为中心且具有成本与临床效果的骨质疏松长期照护模式。
研究设计与样本
- 快速现实主义综述,初步检索观察性或干预性研究,补充检索任何设计研究,采用情境-机制-结果配置模式分析,以实用性与感知方法为概念框架。
主要发现
- 识别出患者(识别问题、开始用药、继续用药)及从业者与医疗系统(做出诊断并给出治疗推荐、审查药物)的5个情境时间点。
- 支持患者知情决策的干预似可影响长期治疗承诺。
- 支持患者实际服药能力(如降低治疗负担和发送提醒)仅在结合其他方法解决患者信念和担忧时才有帮助。
- 支持初级保健临床医生决策及整合初级与二级保健服务似可改善治疗起始率和依从率。
- 极少研究明确涉及患者对疾病和治疗的感知。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 极少研究明确涉及患者对疾病和治疗的感知。
- 需要进一步研究以识别可持续、整合、以患者为中心且具有成本与临床效果的骨质疏松长期照护模式。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
UNLABELLED: Systematic reviews that examine effectiveness of interventions to improve medicines optimisation do not explain how or why they work. This realist review identified that interventions which effectively optimise medicines use in osteoporosis include opportunities to address patients' perceptions of illness and treatment and/or support primary care clinician decision making. INTRODUCTION: In people with osteoporosis, adherence to medicines is poorer than other diseases and patients report follow-up is lacking, and multiple unmet information needs. We conducted a rapid realist review to understand what contextual conditions and mechanisms enable interventions to support osteoporosis medication optimisation. METHODS: A primary search identified observational or interventional studies which aimed to improve medicines adherence or optimisation; a supplementary second search identified research of any design to gain additional insights on emerging findings. Extracted data was interrogated for patterns of context-mechanism-outcome configurations, further discussed in team meetings, informed by background literature and the Practicalities and Perception Approach as an underpinning conceptual framework. RESULTS: We identified 5 contextual timepoints for the person with osteoporosis (identifying a problem; starting medicine; continuing medicine) and the practitioner and healthcare system (making a diagnosis and giving a treatment recommendation; reviewing medicine). Interventions which support patient-informed decision making appear to influence long-term commitment to treatment. Supporting patients' practical ability to adhere (e.g. by lowering treatment burden and issuing reminders) only appears to be helpful, when combined with other approaches to address patient beliefs and concerns. However, few studies explicitly addressed patients' perceptions of illness and treatment. Supporting primary care clinician decision making and integration of primary and secondary care services also appears to be important, in improving rates of treatment initiation and adherence. CONCLUSIONS: We identified a need for further research to identify a sustainable, integrated, patient-centred, and cost- and clinically effective model of long-term care for people with osteoporosis.
引用
- Paskins Z, Babatunde O, Sturrock A, et al. Supporting patients to get the best from their osteoporosis treatment: a rapid realist review of what works, for whom, and in what circumstance. Osteoporos Int. 2022. PMID: 35688897. doi:10.1007/s00198-022-06453-4
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。