第一跖骨过度旋前对第一跖列对线的影响:一项尸体研究
该尸体研究对12例无畸形胫骨截肢标本行6种负重CT扫描,评估第一跖骨过度旋前对第一跖趾关节和跖籽关节稳定性的影响。结果显示30°旋前截骨增加跖骨旋前角和拇趾旋前,负重时第一跖列由旋前转为旋后,附加内侧软组织松解后旋后增加;负重时第一跖列旋后与跖间角和拇外翻角增加相关。
要点
- 第一跖骨30°旋前截骨使非负重下跖骨旋前角增加28°±4°、拇趾旋前增加26°±6°。
- 旋前截骨后负重时第一跖列由旋前4°±2°转为旋后4°±2°,平均差8°(95%CI 6°至9°,p<0.001)。
- 附加内侧软组织松解后第一跖列旋后由4°±2°增至11°±7°,平均差8°(95%CI 3°至12°,p=0.003)。
核心结论
- 在该尸体研究中,第一跖骨内在过度旋前合并第一跖趾关节内侧软组织失效导致拇外翻畸形。
- 第一跖骨头相对地面的静态旋前角测量未反映第一跖列真实的内在旋前,足踝专科医生解读这些测量时应谨慎。
- 拇外翻是一种动态状况,畸形与负重时运动的相关性可能高于与平片静态测量的相关性。
研究设计与样本
- 研究使用12例无畸形的非配对胫骨截肢尸体标本。
- 每例标本在6种不同条件下接受负重CT扫描:模拟非负重、模拟负重、模拟负重加内侧软组织松解,以及第一跖骨30°旋前截骨后重复上述序列。
- 在每张负重CT图像上测量拇外翻角、跖间角、籽骨旋转角、跖骨旋前角、跖籽旋转角和拇趾旋前。
- 采用t检验比较正态分布变量均值,Mann-Whitney U检验比较非正态分布变量,Pearson积矩相关系数评估相关性。
主要发现
- 非负重条件下,第一跖骨30°旋前截骨使跖骨旋前角增加28°±4°、拇趾旋前增加26°±6°,两者增加量无差异(平均差2°,95%CI -1°至5°,p=0.20)。
- 第一跖骨30°旋前截骨后,负重时第一跖列运动由旋前转为旋后(无截骨时旋前4°±2° vs 截骨后旋后4°±2°,平均差8°,95%CI 6°至9°,p<0.001)。
- 在30°截骨基础上附加第一跖趾关节内侧软组织松解后,第一跖列旋后运动增加(无内侧软组织松解时4°±2° vs 松解后11°±7°,平均差8°,95%CI 3°至12°,p=0.003)。
- 静态角度测量中,拇外翻角和跖间角与跖骨旋前角无相关性(ρ=0.20,p=0.09;ρ=0.22,p=0.07)。
- 从非负重到负重,拇外翻角和跖间角增加时旋前减少,呈强相关(ρ=-0.82,p<0.001;ρ=-0.77,p<0.001)。
临床怎么用
- 作者指出,第一跖列旋后代偿第一跖骨内在过度旋前可能是拇外翻发病机制中的重要因素。
- 作者建议,应开展涉及拇外翻患者与对照者非负重与负重比较评估的进一步在体研究以确认该病理机制。
局限性
- 原文在临床相关性部分指出,应开展涉及拇外翻患者与对照者非负重与负重比较评估的进一步在体研究以确认该病理机制。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: There is increased evidence of first metatarsal hyperpronation in patients with hallux valgus, but its impact on the stability of the first metatarsophalangeal and metatarsosesamoid joints is unknown. A previous biomechanical study showed that an increase in hallucal pronation might lead to medial soft tissue failure of the first metatarsophalangeal joint. Conversely, dynamic studies on hallux valgus have shown that the first tarsometatarsal joint moves in supination during weightbearing, and supination was associated with an increase in the intermetatarsal angle (IMA) and hallux valgus angle (HVA). QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) Does an increase in first metatarsal pronation cause an increase in hallucal pronation? (2) Can an intrinsic increase in first metatarsal pronation lead to first ray supination during weightbearing? (3) Can a combination of intrinsic first metatarsal hyperpronation and first metatarsophalangeal medial soft tissue failure increase supination of the first ray during weightbearing? (4) Is first ray supination during weightbearing associated with an increase in the IMA and HVA? METHODS: Twelve transtibial, nonpaired cadaver specimens without deformities were used. Each specimen underwent six weightbearing CT scans under different conditions. The first three CT examinations were performed without any osteotomy of the first metatarsal. The first was a simulated nonweightbearing condition. The second was a simulated weightbearing condition. The third was a simulated weightbearing condition with medial soft tissue release. Subsequentially, a 30° pronation osteotomy of the first metatarsal was performed, and the same sequence of weightbearing CT images was obtained. On each weightbearing CT image, the HVA, IMA, sesamoid rotation angle, metatarsal pronation angle (MPA), metatarsosesamoid rotation angle, and hallucal pronation (HP) were measured. Motions were calculated based on the differential values of these angular measurements produced by the six different conditions (weightbearing, medial soft tissue release, 30° pronation osteotomy, and combinations of these conditions). We compared means using a t-test for normally distributed variables and the Mann-Whitney U test for nonnormally distributed variables. Correlations were assessed with Pearson product-moment correlation coefficients. RESULTS: We found that 30° pronation osteotomy of the first metatarsal increased the MPA and HP by 28° ± 4° and 26° ± 6°, respectively, in the nonweightbearing condition. No differences between the increase in MPA and the increase in HP were noted (mean difference 2° [95% CI -1° to 5°]; p = 0.20). Therefore, an increase in first metatarsal pronation caused an increase in hallucal pronation. When a 30° pronation osteotomy of the first metatarsal was performed, the first ray motion during weightbearing went from pronation to supination (4° ± 2° in pronation without osteotomy versus 4° ± 2° in supination after the osteotomy, mean difference 8° [95% CI 6° to 9°]; p < 0.001). Therefore, an intrinsic increase in pronation of the first metatarsal led to a first ray supination motion during weightbearing. When a first metatarsophalangeal medial soft tissue release was performed in addition to the 30° osteotomy of the first metatarsal, the supination motion of the first ray increased (4° ± 2° without medial soft tissue release versus 11° ± 7° after the release, mean difference 8° [95% CI 3° to 12°]; p = 0.003). Therefore, a combination of intrinsic first metatarsal hyperpronation and first metatarsophalangeal medial soft tissue failure increased supination of the first ray during weightbearing. Regarding static angular measurements, the HVA and IMA were not correlated with the MPA (ρ = 0.20; p = 0.09 and ρ = 0.22; p = 0.07, respectively). Regarding motions, as the HVA and IMA increased from nonweightbearing to weightbearing the pronation decreased, with strong correlations (ρ = -0.82; p < 0.001 and ρ = -0.77; p < 0.001, respectively). Therefore, a first ray supination during weightbearing was associated with an increase in the HVA and IMA. CONCLUSION: The combination of first metatarsal intrinsic hyperpronation and first metatarsophalangeal medial soft tissue failure led to a hallux valgus deformity in this cadaveric study. The static measurement of first metatarsal head pronation relative to the ground (MPA) did not reflect the real intrinsic pronation of the first ray, and foot and ankle specialists should be careful when interpreting these measurements. Hallux valgus is a dynamic condition, and the deformity could be more correlated with motions during weightbearing than with plain static measurements. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: First ray supination compensating for first metatarsal intrinsic hyperpronation might be an important factor in the hallux valgus pathogenesis. Further in vivo studies involving nonweightbearing and weightbearing comparative assessments of hallux valgus and controls should be performed to confirm this pathomechanism.
引用
- Lalevée M, Dibbern K, Barbachan Mansur NS, et al. Impact of First Metatarsal Hyperpronation on First Ray Alignment: A Study in Cadavers. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2022. PMID: 35700368. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000002265
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。