失败开放或关节镜下肩袖修复后关节镜翻修肩袖修复的结果:一项100例的前瞻性多中心研究
这项前瞻性多中心病例系列(证据等级4)纳入100例关节镜翻修肩袖修复患者,术后Constant评分、牛津肩关节评分和主观肩关节值均显著改善,但2年再撕裂率为51.8%(43/83),再手术率为12.6%(11/87)。再撕裂患者肩关节功能不一定更差,既往开放修复、肩胛下肌受累、Outerbridge≥2级软骨损伤及内侧肩袖失败与2年主观肩关节值较差相关,创伤性再撕裂者功能改善更好。
要点
- 关节镜翻修肩袖修复后Constant评分从术前44±16分改善至24个月69±19分(P<.01)。
- 2年再撕裂率为51.8%(43/83),再手术率为12.6%(11/87)。
- 既往开放修复、肩胛下肌受累、Outerbridge≥2级软骨损伤及内侧肩袖失败与2年主观肩关节值较差相关(P≤.047)。
核心结论
- 关节镜翻修肩袖修复改善了肩关节功能,再撕裂常见但通常较小。
- 再撕裂患者不一定肩关节功能更差。
- 既往开放肩袖修复、肩胛下肌撕裂或骨关节炎存在、再撕裂位于肌腱肌腱结合处时,2年患者满意度较低。
- 创伤性再撕裂患者翻修后功能改善更好。
研究设计与样本
- 研究为病例系列,证据等级4。
- 在40个月期间前瞻性纳入100例接受关节镜翻修肩袖修复的患者,多中心设计。
- 采用Constant评分、牛津肩关节评分和主观肩关节值在术前、6个月和24个月评估结果。
- 2年时使用磁共振成像分析肌腱完整性。
- 13例(13%)失访,14例(14%)在24个月随访前出现症状性再撕裂。
主要发现
- Constant评分:术前44±16分,6个月58±22分,24个月69±19分(P<.01)。
- 牛津肩关节评分:术前27±8分,6个月36±11分,24个月40±9分(P<.01)。
- 主观肩关节值:术前43%±18%,6个月66%±24%,24个月75%±22%(P<.01)。
- 2年时再撕裂率为51.8%(43/83),手术再翻修率为12.6%(11/87)。
- 平均全层撕裂大小从5.00±1.61 cm²减小至3.25±1.92 cm²(P=.041),Sugaya评分从4.5±0.9改善至3.7±1.4(P=.043),但肌腱完整性与更好的结果评分不相关。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 13例(13%)失访,14例(14%)在24个月随访前出现症状性再撕裂。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Retears after rotator cuff repair (RCR) have been associated with poor clinical results. Meaningful data regarding the role of arthroscopic revision RCR are sparse thus far. PURPOSE/HYPOTHESIS: To investigate results after arthroscopic revision RCR. We hypothesized that (1) arthroscopic revision RCR would lead to improved outcomes, (2) the clinical results would be dependent on tendon integrity and (3) tear pattern, tendon involvement, and repair technique would influence clinical and structural results. STUDY DESIGN: Case series; Level of evidence 4. METHODS: During a 40-month period, 100 patients who underwent arthroscopic revision RCR were prospectively enrolled in this multicenter study. Outcomes were evaluated preoperatively, at 6 months (6M), and at 24 months (24M) using the Constant score (CS), the Oxford Shoulder Score (OSS), and the Subjective Shoulder Value (SSV). Tendon integrity at 2 years was analyzed using magnetic resonance imaging. A total of 13 patients (13%) were lost to follow-up, and 14 patients (14%) had a symptomatic retear before the 24M follow-up. RESULTS: All clinical scores improved significantly during the study period (CS: preoperative, 44 ± 16; 6M, 58 ± 22; 24M, 69 ± 19 points; OSS: preoperative, 27 ± 8; 6M, 36 ± 11; 24M, 40 ± 9 points; SSV: preoperative, 43% ± 18%; 6M, 66% ± 24%; 24M, 75% ± 22%) (P < .01). At 2 years, a retear rate of 51.8% (43/83) and a surgical revision rate of 12.6% (11/87) were observed. Mean full-thickness tear size decreased from 5.00 ± 1.61 cm2 to 3.25 ± 1.92 cm2 (P = .041). Although the Sugaya score improved from 4.5 ± 0.9 to 3.7 ± 1.4 (P = .043), tendon integrity did not correlate with better outcome scores. Previous open RCR, involvement of the subscapularis, chondral lesions of Outerbridge grade ≥2, and medial cuff failure were correlated with poorer SSV scores at 2 years (P≤ .047). Patients with traumatic retears had better CS and OSS scores at 2 years (P≤ .039). CONCLUSION: Although arthroscopic revision RCR improved shoulder function, retears were frequent but usually smaller. Patients with retears, however, did not necessarily have poorer shoulder function. Patient satisfaction at 2 years was lower when primary open RCR was performed, when a subscapularis tear or osteoarthritis was present, and when the rotator cuff retear was located at the musculotendinous junction. Patients with traumatic retears showed better functional improvement after revision.
引用
- Hackl M, Flury M, Kolling C, et al. Results of Arthroscopic Revision Rotator Cuff Repair for Failed Open or Arthroscopic Repair: A Prospective Multicenter Study on 100 Cases. Am J Sports Med. 2022. PMID: 35666098. doi:10.1177/03635465221097410
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。