骨骼成熟患者胫骨平台骨折非手术治疗后的功能结局:可接受的间隙和台阶大小为多少?
该多中心横断面研究纳入2003年至2018年间四家创伤中心非手术治疗胫骨平台骨折的445例骨骼成熟患者,203例完成KOOS问卷,平均随访6±3年。CT测量的间隙或台阶小于2毫米、2至4毫米、大于4毫米三组间KOOS各子量表评分均无显著差异,5年免于全膝关节置换的生存率为97%(95%CI 94%至99%)。作者认为CT上间隙或台阶达4毫米仍可获良好功能结局,2毫米的任意界限可重新审视。
要点
- CT测量间隙或台阶小于2毫米、2至4毫米、大于4毫米三组间KOOS各子量表评分均无显著差异。
- 平均随访5年时免于全膝关节置换的生存率为97%(95%CI 94%至99%)。
- 作者认为CT上间隙或台阶达4毫米仍可获良好功能结局,2毫米的任意界限可重新审视。
核心结论
- 作者认为,选择非手术治疗的轻微移位胫骨平台骨折患者,CT测量间隙或台阶达4毫米仍可获良好功能结局,2毫米的任意界限可重新审视。
- 免于转为全膝关节置换的生存率较高。
- 需要高应答率的大样本前瞻性队列研究进一步了解骨折移位程度与功能恢复的关系。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心横断面研究,纳入2003年至2018年四家创伤中心非手术治疗胫骨平台骨折的骨骼成熟患者。
- 530例非手术治疗患者中,45例随访时死亡、30例受伤时小于18岁、10例为孤立性胫骨髁间隆突撕脱,最终445例纳入随访分析。
- 445例中46%(203/445)完成KOOS问卷,平均随访6±3年。
- 所有膝关节X线片和CT图像重新评估,进行骨折分型及间隙和台阶测量。
- 根据CT测量的间隙和/或台阶将患者分为小于2毫米、2至4毫米、大于4毫米三组,采用方差分析评估初始骨折移位增加是否与较差功能结局相关,采用Kaplan-Meier法估计平均随访5年时免于全膝关节置换的生存率。
主要发现
- 间隙小于2毫米、2至4毫米、大于4毫米三组KOOS评分无差异:症状83 vs 83 vs 82(p=0.98),疼痛85 vs 83 vs 86(p=0.69),日常生活87 vs 84 vs 89(p=0.44),运动65 vs 64 vs 66(p=0.95),生活质量70 vs 71 vs 74(p=0.85)。
- 台阶小于2毫米、2至4毫米、大于4毫米三组KOOS评分无差异:症状84 vs 83 vs 77(p=0.32),疼痛85 vs 85 vs 81(p=0.66),日常生活86 vs 87 vs 82(p=0.54),运动65 vs 68 vs 56(p=0.43),生活质量71 vs 73 vs 61(p=0.19)。
- 平均随访5年时免于转为全膝关节置换的生存率为97%(95%CI 94%至99%)。
- 未应答者与应答者比较:年龄53±16岁 vs 54±20岁(p=0.89),女性70%(142/203)vs 59%(142/242)(p=0.01),间隙2.1±1.3毫米 vs 1.7±1.6毫米(p=0.02),台阶2.1±2.2毫米 vs 1.9±1.7毫米(p=0.13)。
- 研究人群平均间隙为2.1±1.3毫米,平均台阶为2.1±2.2毫米。
关键数值与推荐
- 所有患者均有诊断性CT扫描,间隙和/或台阶大于2毫米是建议手术的指征。
- 部分间隙和/或台阶超过2毫米的患者可能基于共同决策未接受手术。
- KOOS问卷包括症状、疼痛、日常生活活动能力、运动和娱乐功能、膝关节相关生活质量五个子量表,每个子量表评分0至100分,评分越高功能越好。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,选择非手术治疗轻微移位胫骨平台骨折的患者应被告知,CT测量间隙或台阶达4毫米仍可获良好功能结局。
- 作者认为,胫骨平台骨折间隙和台阶的任意2毫米界限可重新审视。
局限性
- 需要高应答率的大样本前瞻性队列研究进一步了解骨折移位程度与功能恢复的关系。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Gap and stepoff measurements provide information about fracture displacement and are used for clinical decision-making when choosing either operative or nonoperative management of tibial plateau fractures. However, there is no consensus about the maximum size of gaps and stepoffs on CT images and their relation to functional outcome in skeletally mature patients with tibial plateau fractures who were treated without surgery. Because this is important for patient counseling regarding treatment and prognosis, it is critical to identify the limits of gaps and stepoffs that are well tolerated. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) In patients treated nonoperatively for tibial plateau fractures, what is the association between initial fracture displacement, as measured by gaps and stepoffs at the articular surface on a CT image, and functional outcome? (2) What is the survivorship of the native joint, free from conversion to a total knee prosthesis, among patients with tibial plateau fractures who were treated without surgery? METHODS: A multicenter cross-sectional study was performed in all patients who were treated nonoperatively for a tibial plateau fracture between 2003 and 2018 in four trauma centers. All patients had a diagnostic CT scan, and a gap and/or stepoff more than 2 mm was an indication for recommending surgery. Some patients with gaps and/or stepoffs exceeding 2 mm might not have had surgery based on shared decision-making. Between 2003 and 2018, 530 patients were treated nonoperatively for tibial plateau fractures, of which 45 had died at follow-up, 30 were younger than 18 years at the time of injury, and 10 had isolated tibial eminence avulsions, leaving 445 patients for follow-up analysis. All patients were asked to complete the validated Knee Injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score (KOOS) questionnaire consisting of five subscales: symptoms, pain, activities of daily living (ADL), function in sports and recreation, and knee-related quality of life (QOL). The score for each subscale ranged from 0 to 100, with higher scores indicating better function. A total of 46% (203 of 445) of patients participated at a mean follow-up of 6 ± 3 years since injury. All knee radiographs and CT images were reassessed, fractures were classified, and gap and stepoff measurements were taken. Nonresponders did not differ much from responders in terms of age (53 ± 16 years versus 54 ± 20 years; p = 0.89), gender (70% [142 of 203] women versus 59% [142 of 242] women; p = 0.01), fracture classifications (Schatzker types and three-column concept), gaps (2.1 ± 1.3 mm versus 1.7 ± 1.6 mm; p = 0.02), and stepoffs (2.1 ± 2.2 mm versus 1.9 ± 1.7 mm; p = 0.13). In our study population, the mean gap was 2.1 ± 1.3 mm and stepoff was 2.1 ± 2.2 mm. The participating patients divided into groups with increasing fracture displacement based on gap and/or stepoff (< 2 mm, 2 to 4 mm, or > 4 mm), as measured on CT images. ANOVA was used to assess whether an increase in the initial fracture displacement was associated with poorer functional outcome. We estimated the survivorship of the knee free from conversion to total knee prosthesis at a mean follow-up of 5 years using a Kaplan-Meier survivorship estimator. RESULTS: KOOS scores in patients with a less than 2 mm, 2 to 4 mm, or greater than 4 mm gap did not differ (symptoms: 83 versus 83 versus 82; p = 0.98, pain: 85 versus 83 versus 86; p = 0.69, ADL: 87 versus 84 versus 89; p = 0.44, sport: 65 versus 64 versus 66; p = 0.95, QOL: 70 versus 71 versus 74; p = 0.85). The KOOS scores in patients with a less than 2 mm, 2 to 4 mm, or greater than 4 mm stepoff did not differ (symptoms: 84 versus 83 versus 77; p = 0.32, pain: 85 versus 85 versus 81; p = 0.66, ADL: 86 versus 87 versus 82; p = 0.54, sport: 65 versus 68 versus 56; p = 0.43, QOL: 71 versus 73 versus 61; p = 0.19). Survivorship of the knee free from conversion to total knee prosthesis at mean follow-up of 5 years was 97% (95% CI 94% to 99%). CONCLUSION: Patients with minimally displaced tibial plateau fractures who opt for nonoperative fracture treatment should be told that fracture gaps or stepoffs up to 4 mm, as measured on CT images, could result in good functional outcome. Therefore, the arbitrary 2-mm limit of gaps and stepoffs for tibial plateau fractures could be revisited. The survivorship of the native knee free from conversion to a total knee prosthesis was high. Large prospective cohort studies with high response rates are needed to learn more about the relationship between the degree of fracture displacement and functional recovery after tibial plateau fractures. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, prognostic study.
引用
- Vaartjes TP, Assink N, Nijveldt RJ, et al. Functional Outcome After Nonoperative Management of Tibial Plateau Fractures in Skeletally Mature Patients: What Sizes of Gaps and Stepoffs Can be Accepted? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2022. PMID: 35638902. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000002266
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。