偏心性盂肱骨关节炎患者后侧肩袖肌内脂肪增加但力量无差异
该前瞻性横断面研究纳入51名受试者(偏心性骨关节炎16例、同心性17例、对照18例),采用三维力量平衡评估肩关节力量,发现偏心性组与同心性组在相对外旋力量上无显著差异,但偏心性组三维力量平衡变异性更大;偏心性组后侧与前方肩袖肌内脂肪百分比比值高于同心性组。
要点
- 偏心性组与同心性组相对外旋力量无显著差异,但偏心性组三维力量平衡变异性更大。
- 两组静息痛和力矩依赖性疼痛均无显著差异。
- 偏心性组后侧与前方肩袖肌内脂肪百分比比值高于同心性组。
核心结论
- 偏心性畸形患者的力量变异性大于同心性畸形患者,提示不同亚型的偏心性磨损模式可能通过独特的运动学或肌肉激活模式对潜在解剖改变进行不同代偿。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性横断面研究,纳入51名受试者,分为偏心性组(n=16)、同心性组(n=17)和对照组(n=18)。
主要发现
- 偏心性组三维力量平衡Y分量均值±标准差为-4.7%±5.1%,同心性组为-0.05%±4.5%,均值差-4.7%(95%CI -7.5%至-1.9%),p=0.05。
- 偏心性组三维力量平衡95%CI体积为893 %³,同心性组为579 %³。
- 偏心性组静息痛中位数(四分位距)为1.0(3.0),同心性组为2.0(2.3),平均秩差4.5(95%CI -6.6至16),p=0.61。
- 偏心性组力矩依赖性疼痛中位数(四分位距)为0.70(3.0),同心性组为0.58(1.5),平均秩差2.6(95%CI -8.8至14),p=0.86。
- 在33例骨关节炎患者中接受MRI的18例子集里,7例偏心性畸形患者后侧与前方肩袖肌内脂肪百分比比值高于11例同心性畸形患者(1.2[0.8] vs 0.70[0.3]),平均秩差6.4(95%CI 1.4至11.5),p=0.01。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,研究结果强调对表现为偏心性畸形的患者进行仔细临床评估的重要性,因为部分患者可能表现出潜在不利的力量缺陷。
- 作者认为,识别此类力量缺陷可能有助于针对性康复。
- 作者建议,未来工作应探索特定偏心性磨损模式亚型患者的力量与潜在运动学或肌肉代偿形式之间的关系,以确定这些因素是否在偏心性畸形患者的全肩关节置换术失败中起作用。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: When nonoperative measures do not alleviate the symptoms of glenohumeral osteoarthritis (OA), patients with advanced OA primarily are treated with anatomic total shoulder arthroplasty (TSA). It is unknown why TSAs performed in patients with eccentric (asymmetric glenoid wear) compared with concentric (symmetric glenoid wear) deformities exhibit higher failure rates, despite surgical advances. Persistent disruption of the posterior-to-anterior rotator cuff (RC) force couple resulting from posterior RC intramuscular degeneration in patients with eccentric deformities could impair external rotation strength and may contribute to eventual TSA failure. Pain and intramuscular fat within the RC muscles may impact external rotation strength measures and are important to consider. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) Is there relative shoulder external rotation weakness in patients with eccentric compared with concentric deformities? (2) Is there higher resting or torque-dependent pain in patients with eccentric compared with concentric deformities? (3) Do patients with eccentric deformities have higher posterior-to-anterior RC intramuscular fat percent ratios than patients with concentric deformities? METHODS: From February 2020 to November 2021, 65% (52 of 80) of patients with OA met study eligibility criteria. Of these, 63% (33 of 52) of patients enrolled and provided informed consent. From a convenience sample of 21 older adults with no history of shoulder pain, 20 met eligibility criteria as control participants. Of the convenience sample, 18 patients enrolled and provided informed consent. In total for this prospective, cross-sectional study, across patients with OA and control participants, 50% (51 of 101) of participants were enrolled and allocated into the eccentric (n = 16), concentric (n = 17), and control groups (n = 18). A 3-degree-of-freedom load cell was used to sensitively quantify strength in all three dimensions surrounding the shoulder. Participants performed maximal isometric contractions in 26 1-, 2-, and 3-degree-of-freedom direction combinations involving adduction/abduction, internal/external rotation, and/or flexion/extension. To test for relative external rotation weakness, we quantified relative strength in opposing directions (three-dimensional [3D] strength balance) along the X (+adduction/-abduction), Y (+internal/-external rotation), and Z (+flexion/-extension) axes and compared across the three groups. Patients with OA rated their shoulder pain (numerical rating 0-10) before testing at rest (resting pain; response to "How bad is your pain today?") and with each maximal contraction (torque-dependent pain; numerical rating 0-10). Resting and torque-dependent pain were compared between patients with eccentric and concentric deformities to determine if pain was higher in the eccentric group. The RC cross-sectional areas and intramuscular fat percentages were quantified on Dixon-sequence MRIs by a single observer who performed manual segmentation using previously validated methods. Ratios of posterior-to-anterior RC fat percent (infraspinatus + teres minor fat percent/subscapularis fat percent) were computed and compared between the OA groups. RESULTS: There was no relative external rotation weakness in patients with eccentric deformities (Y component of 3D strength balance, mean ± SD: -4.7% ± 5.1%) compared with patients with concentric deformities (-0.05% ± 4.5%, mean difference -4.7% [95% CI -7.5% to -1.9%]; p = 0.05). However, there was more variability in 3D strength balance in the eccentric group (95% CI volume, % 3 : 893) compared with the concentric group (95% CI volume, % 3 : 579). In patients with eccentric compared with concentric deformities, there was no difference in median (IQR) resting pain (1.0 [3.0] versus 2.0 [2.3], mean rank difference 4.5 [95% CI -6.6 to 16]; p = 0.61) or torque-dependent pain (0.70 [3.0] versus 0.58 [1.5], mean rank difference 2.6 [95% CI -8.8 to 14]; p = 0.86). In the subset of 18 of 33 patients with OA who underwent MRI, seven patients with eccentric deformities demonstrated a higher posterior-to-anterior RC fat percent ratio than the 11 patients with concentric deformities (1.2 [0.8] versus 0.70 [0.3], mean rank difference 6.4 [95% CI 1.4 to 11.5]; p = 0.01). CONCLUSION: Patients with eccentric deformities demonstrated higher variability in strength compared with patients with concentric deformities. This increased variability suggests patients with potential subtypes of eccentric wear patterns (posterior-superior, posterior-central, and posterior-inferior) may compensate differently for underlying anatomic changes by adopting unique kinematic or muscle activation patterns. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Our findings highlight the importance of careful clinical evaluation of patients presenting with eccentric deformities because some may exhibit potentially detrimental strength deficits. Recognition of such strength deficits may allow for targeted rehabilitation. Future work should explore the relationship between strength in patients with specific subtypes of eccentric wear patterns and potential forms of kinematic or muscular compensation to determine whether these factors play a role in TSA failures in patients with eccentric deformities.
引用
- Coats-Thomas MS, Baillargeon EM, Ludvig D, et al. No Strength Differences Despite Greater Posterior Rotator Cuff Intramuscular Fat in Patients With Eccentric Glenohumeral Osteoarthritis. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2022. PMID: 35675568. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000002253
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。