开发髋部骨折审计最小通用数据集以帮助各国建立可支持国际比较的国家审计
本研究比较了10个已建立的国家髋部骨折登记处使用的全部问题,并与全球脆性骨折网络最小通用数据集(MCD)的32个问题交叉对照,发现仅3个字段被所有登记处使用,21个MCD问题被多数审计使用。通过共识方法(亚太FFN会议反馈及2021年9月全球FFN会议95国代表在线反馈)制定了修订版MCD,旨在帮助有志国家建立登记项目并支持国际基准比较。
要点
- 10个国家登记处共使用215个独特问题,仅72个(34%)被一个以上国家审计使用,仅32个(15%)被超过半数审计使用。
- 仅3个字段(麻醉分级、手术、手术日期/时间)被所有10个已建立审计使用。
- 修订版MCD通过共识方法制定,将帮助有志国家建立登记项目并支持跨国合作。
核心结论
- 修订版MCD将帮助有志国家建立新的登记项目,促进新颖分析技术的整合和更大范围的跨国合作,并作为监测和改善髋部骨折服务的国际公认标准。
研究设计与样本
- 比较所有十个已建立的国家髋部骨折登记处(英格兰、威尔士和北爱尔兰;苏格兰;澳大利亚和新西兰;爱尔兰共和国;德国;荷兰;瑞典;挪威;丹麦;西班牙),将各登记处问题与MCD数据集的32个问题交叉对照,并采用共识方法(亚太FFN会议反馈及2021年9月全球FFN会议95国代表在线反馈)制定修订版MCD。
主要发现
- 十个登记处共使用215个独特问题,仅72个(34%)被一个以上国家审计使用,仅32个(15%)被超过半数审计使用。
- 仅一个登记处使用了2014年MCD的全部32个问题,五个问题仅被单个登记处收集。
- MCD的32个问题中仅21个被多数国家审计使用,仅三个字段(麻醉分级、手术、手术日期/时间)被所有十个已建立审计使用。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: The aim of this study was to explore current use of the Global Fragility Fracture Network (FFN) Minimum Common Dataset (MCD) within established national hip fracture registries, and to propose a revised MCD to enable international benchmarking for hip fracture care. METHODS: We compared all ten established national hip fracture registries: England, Wales, and Northern Ireland; Scotland; Australia and New Zealand; Republic of Ireland; Germany; the Netherlands; Sweden; Norway; Denmark; and Spain. We tabulated all questions included in each registry, and cross-referenced them against the 32 questions of the MCD dataset. Having identified those questions consistently used in the majority of national audits, and which additional fields were used less commonly, we then used consensus methods to establish a revised MCD. RESULTS: A total of 215 unique questions were used across the ten registries. Only 72 (34%) were used in more than one national audit, and only 32 (15%) by more than half of audits. Only one registry used all 32 questions from the 2014 MCD, and five questions were only collected by a single registry. Only 21 of the 32 questions in the MCD were used in the majority of national audits. Only three fields (anaesthetic grade, operation, and date/time of surgery) were used by all ten established audits. We presented these findings at the Asia-Pacific FFN meeting, and used an online questionnaire to capture feedback from expert clinicians from different countries. A draft revision of the MCD was then presented to all 95 nations represented at the Global FFN conference in September 2021, with online feedback again used to finalize the revised MCD. CONCLUSION: The revised MCD will help aspirant nations establish new registry programmes, facilitate the integration of novel analytic techniques and greater multinational collaboration, and serve as an internationally-accepted standard for monitoring and improving hip fracture services. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2022;104-B(6):721-728.
引用
- Johansen A, Ojeda-Thies C, Poacher AT, et al. Developing a minimum common dataset for hip fracture audit to help countries set up national audits that can support international comparisons. Bone Joint J. 2022. PMID: 35638208. doi:10.1302/0301-620X.104B6.BJJ-2022-0080.R1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。