LaPrade技术与一种新术式重建膝关节内侧损伤的生物力学比较
研究采用20例配对新鲜冷冻男性尸体膝关节,随机分入LaPrade(LP)技术与新术式MARCI(内侧副韧带解剖重建联合关节囊叠缝)组,在完整、失稳和重建三阶段测试外翻与旋转稳定性;MARCI在0°至90°屈膝的外翻稳定性及屈膝≤30°的外旋负荷下更接近完整状态。
要点
- MARCI与LP重建在恢复外翻稳定性上存在显著差异(P=0.021),MARCI更接近完整膝关节。
- 内旋方面两种技术整体无差异(P=0.163),均接近完整状态。
- 外旋效应取决于屈膝角度(P<0.001),屈膝≤30°时MARCI更接近完整状态。
核心结论
- 两种技术均较失稳状态改善膝关节稳定性,但MARCI技术在屈膝0°至90°的外翻负荷及屈膝≤30°的外旋负荷下更接近完整膝关节稳定性。
研究设计与样本
- controlled laboratory study,使用20例新鲜冷冻、男性(平均年龄43.7岁,范围20-63岁)、股骨中段至足趾配对的尸体膝关节。
- 所有重建由同一名接受过专科培训的运动医学外科医生完成,配对左右标本随机分配至LP或MARCI组。
- 每例标本在完整、失稳(MCL与POL完全切断)和重建三阶段测试,在屈膝0°、20°、30°、60°和90°下施加外翻与外旋力矩,量化内侧关节线张开及胫骨内旋与外旋。
主要发现
- 与完整状态相比,MARCI与LP重建组在外翻稳定性上存在显著差异(P=0.021),MARCI更接近完整膝关节。
- MARCI与LP重建技术在内旋方面整体无差异(P=0.163),两者均接近完整状态。
- 外旋方面,重建技术效应取决于屈膝角度(P<0.001);在较高屈膝角度时两种重建无差异,在较低屈膝角度时MARCI更接近完整状态。
关键数值与推荐
- 外翻稳定性组间比较P=0.021;内旋整体比较P=0.163;外旋技术效应与屈膝角度交互P<0.001。
临床怎么用
- MARCI技术提供一种改善全范围外翻稳定性的替代选择,其利用POL前移,避免了LP技术中多隧道复杂性与碰撞等潜在局限,尤其适用于多发韧带损伤的膝关节。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Medial-sided knee injuries can lead to symptomatic valgus laxity or anteromedial rotatory instability and may require surgery, particularly in the setting of cruciate tears and tibial-sided medial collateral ligament (MCL) avulsions. The LaPrade (LP) technique utilizes 2 free grafts to reconstruct the superficial MCL (sMCL) and the posterior oblique ligament (POL). An alternative MCL reconstruction devised by the senior author comprises an anatomic single-bundle reconstruction using a free graft to reconstruct the sMCL with advancement and imbrication of the posteromedial capsule/POL (MCL anatomic reconstruction with capsular imbrication [MARCI] technique). These techniques have not been biomechanically compared with one another. PURPOSE: To identify if one of these reconstruction techniques better restores valgus and rotational medial knee stability throughout the range of motion. STUDY DESIGN: Controlled laboratory study. METHODS: A total of 20 fresh-frozen, male (mean age, 43.7 years [range, 20-63 years]), midfemur-to-toe-matched cadaveric knees were utilized. All reconstructions were performed by a single fellowship-trained sports medicine surgeon. Left and right specimens within matched pairs were randomized to 1 of the 2 treatment groups: LP or MARCI. Each specimen was tested in 3 phases: (1) intact knee, (2) destabilized (MCL and POL completely severed), and (3) reconstructed (post-LP or post-MARCI reconstruction). We quantified valgus angulation defined by medial joint line opening, as well as internal and external tibial rotation at 0°, 20°, 30°, 60°, and 90° of knee flexion under applied external moments/torques at each phase. RESULTS: There were significant differences between the MARCI and LP reconstruction groups in valgus stability compared with the intact state (P = .021), with the MARCI reconstruction more closely approximating the intact knee. There was no overall difference between the MARCI and LP reconstruction techniques for internal rotation (P = .163), with both closely resembling the intact state. For external rotation, the effect of the reconstruction technique was dependent on the knee flexion angle (P < .001). At the highest angles, there were no differences between reconstructions; however, for lower knee flexion angles, the MARCI technique more closely resembled the intact state. CONCLUSION: Although both techniques improved knee stability compared with destabilized conditions, the MARCI technique better approximated intact stability during valgus at knee flexion angles from 0° to 90° and external rotation loads at knee flexion angles ≤30° in a cadaveric model. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: The MARCI technique provides an alternative option to improve valgus stability throughout the range of motion. It utilizes a POL advancement without the potential limitations seen in the LP technique, such as multiple tunnel complexity and collision, particularly in the multiple ligament-injured knee.
引用
- Richter DL, McIver ND, Sapradit T, et al. A Biomechanical Comparison of the LaPrade Technique Versus a Novel Technique for Reconstruction of Medial-Sided Knee Injuries. Am J Sports Med. 2022. PMID: 35604087. doi:10.1177/03635465221094000
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。