文献速递运动医学关节外科

关节镜下部分半月板切除术后关节间隙狭窄加重:来自骨关节炎倡议的数据

Increased Joint Space Narrowing After Arthroscopic Partial Meniscectomy: Data From the Osteoarthritis Initiative.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Sports Med · 2022-05-23

基于骨关节炎倡议队列,144例接受关节镜下部分半月板切除术(APM)的患者与144例半月板撕裂非手术治疗者及144例无撕裂者按性别、年龄、Kellgren-Lawrence分级和随访时间匹配。APM组术后前12个月内侧间室最小关节间隙宽度(JSW)下降速率约为非手术组的27倍、无撕裂组的5倍;12至72个月三组下降速率无显著差异。APM组JSW在72个月时持续下降。

要点

  • APM组前12个月JSW下降速率为-0.083 mm/月,约为非手术组(-0.003 mm/月)的27倍。
  • APM组前12个月JSW下降速率约为无撕裂组(-0.015 mm/月)的5倍。
  • 12至72个月三组JSW下降速率无显著差异(非手术组-0.009 mm/月,无撕裂组-0.010 mm/月)。

核心结论

  • 术后第一年,APM相比半月板撕裂非手术治疗导致更快的关节间隙狭窄速率。
  • 此后,无论选择何种处理方式,骨关节炎进展速率相当。
  • APM导致JSW在至少72个月内持续下降。
  • 未治疗的半月板撕裂与完整半月板相比,不贡献基于JSW评估的影像学进展。

研究设计与样本

  • 队列研究,证据等级3级。
  • 利用骨关节炎倡议队列,共识别144例接受APM且随访至少12个月、无既往膝关节手术的患者。
  • 144例有半月板撕裂但未接受APM者及144例无撕裂者按性别、年龄、Kellgren-Lawrence分级和随访时间与APM患者匹配。
  • 参与者基线接受磁共振成像,每年或每两年采集膝关节X线片评估JSW。
  • 采用经验证的自动化方法计算内侧间室最小JSW变化,构建分段线性混合效应模型分析JSW下降与治疗组关系,校正年龄、体重指数、吸烟状态、Kellgren-Lawrence分级和基线JSW。

主要发现

  • 所有组基线JSW相当,范围为4.33 mm至4.38 mm。
  • APM组JSW下降速率在前12个月为-0.083 mm/月,12至72个月为-0.014 mm/月。
  • APM组前12个月JSW下降速率约为非手术组(-0.003 mm/月)的27倍,约为无撕裂组(-0.015 mm/月)的5倍。
  • 12至72个月组间无显著差异(非手术组-0.009 mm/月,无撕裂组-0.010 mm/月)。
  • 校正后APM组JSW从基线4.38 mm降至72个月2.57 mm;非手术组从4.31 mm降至3.73 mm;无撕裂组从4.33 mm降至3.54 mm;APM组与其他组基线至72个月JSW变化差异有统计学意义(P < .001),非手术组与无撕裂组间无统计学差异(P = .12)。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Arthroscopic partial meniscectomy (APM) is widely performed and remains an important therapeutic option for patients with a meniscal tear. However, it is debated whether or not APM accelerates the progression of osteoarthritis (OA) in the long term. PURPOSE/HYPOTHESIS: The purpose was to compare the progression of OA measured by the change in tibiofemoral joint space width (JSW)-a quantitative measure of OA radiographic severity-across 3 groups with a midterm follow-up: (1) patients undergoing APM; (2) those with a meniscal tear treated nonoperatively; and (3) those without a tear. We hypothesized that the reduction in JSW would be greatest in patients undergoing APM and least in those patients without a tear. STUDY DESIGN: Cohort study; Level of evidence, 3. METHODS: Using the Osteoarthritis Initiative cohort, a total of 144 patients were identified that underwent APM with at least 12 months of follow up and without previous knee surgery. Those with a meniscal tear who did not have APM (n = 144) and those without a tear (n = 144) were matched to patients who had APM by sex, age, Kellgren-Lawrence (KL) grade, and follow up time. Participants underwent magnetic resonance imaging at baseline. Knee radiographs to assess JSW were collected annually or biannually. The change in minimum medial compartment JSW was calculated using a validated automated method. A piecewise linear mixed effects model was constructed to examine the relationship between JSW decline over time and treatment group-adjusting for age, body mass index, smoking status, KL grade, and baseline JSW. RESULTS: All groups had comparable baseline JSW-ranging from 4.33 mm to 4.38 mm. The APM group had a rate of JSW decline of -0.083 mm/mo in the first 12 months and -0.014 mm/mo between 12 and 72 months. The rate of JSW decline in the APM group was approximately 27 times greater in the first 12 months than that in the nonsurgical group (-0.003 mm/mo) and 5 times greater than that in the no tear group (-0.015 mm/mo); however, there was no significant difference between groups for 12 to 72 months (nonsurgical group: -0.009 mm/mo; no tear group: -0.010 mm/mo). The adjusted JSW in the APM group was 4.38 mm at baseline and decreased to 2.57 mm at 72 months; the JSW in the nonsurgical group declined from 4.31 mm to 3.73 mm, and in the no tear group it declined from 4.33 mm to 3.54 mm. There was a statistically significant difference in JSW change between baseline and 72 months for the APM group compared with the other groups (P < .001), but not between the nonsurgical and no tear groups (P = .12). CONCLUSION: In the first postoperative year, APM results in a faster rate of joint space narrowing compared with knees undergoing nonsurgical management of meniscal tears. Thereafter, there are comparable rates of OA progression regardless of the chosen management. APM results in a persistent decrease in JSW over at least 72 months. An untreated meniscal tear does not contribute to radiographic progression-assessed by JSW-as compared with an intact meniscus.

来源:Am J Sports Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Santana DC, Oak SR, Jin Y, et al. Increased Joint Space Narrowing After Arthroscopic Partial Meniscectomy: Data From the Osteoarthritis Initiative. Am J Sports Med. 2022. PMID: 35604336. doi:10.1177/03635465221096790

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。