常见骨科手术的临床获益:PROMIS与其他验证结局工具的评估对比
本研究在两家学术医学中心和三家社区医院回顾性分析9925例完成术前PROMIS评估的患者,采用分布法计算常见骨科手术的MCID阈值及达标比例,并与已发表的锚定法MCID及其他验证工具(HOOS、KOOS等)比较。结果显示PROMIS的MCID达标比例总体低于其他验证工具,例如关节镜部分半月板切除术1/2 SD法下PROMIS Physical Function达标72% vs KOOS 86%。
要点
- 1/2 SD法下所有手术的PROMIS MCID阈值为3.4至4.5分。
- 除半月板切除术(3.5分)外,锚定法PROMIS MCID阈值(4.5至8.1分)高于SD分布法(2.3至4.5分)。
- PROMIS的MCID达标比例总体低于其他验证工具,如部分半月板切除术后PROMIS Physical Function 72% vs KOOS 86%(1/2 SD法)。
核心结论
- MCID计算可为PROM评分解读提供临床相关性。
- PROMIS因跨诊断通用性而被日益广泛使用,但本研究发现其MCID达标比例低于历史PROM。
- 利用常见骨科手术的历史达标比例及多种MCID计算方法,PROMIS的MCID基准值对常见骨科手术是可实现的。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,纳入两家学术医学中心和三家社区医院接受择期全髋关节置换术(骨关节炎)、全膝关节置换术(骨关节炎)、单节段后路腰椎融合术(腰椎管狭窄或滑脱)、解剖型全肩关节置换术或反式全肩关节置换术(盂肱关节炎或肩袖关节病)、关节镜下前交叉韧带重建术、关节镜下半月板部分切除术或关节镜下肩袖修复术的18岁及以上患者。
- 排除翻修手术、非退行性病变手术及无术前PROM评估的患者后,9925例完成术前PROMIS评估,9478例完成其他术前验证结局工具(HOOS、KOOS、腿痛数字评定量表、背痛数字评定量表、QuickDASH)。
- 约66%(9925例中的6529例)有术后PROMIS评分(Physical Function、Mental Health、Pain Intensity、Pain Interference、Upper Extremity)并纳入分析;约74%(9478例中的7007例)有术后历史评估评分并纳入分析。
- 采用分布法计算MCID,包括标准差分数(1/2或1/3 SD)及基于统计学显著性的最小可检测变化(如p < 0.1的MDC 90),随访6个月时计算各手术队列达标比例;并采用已发表的类似手术队列及类似PROM的锚定法MCID阈值计算达标比例。
主要发现
- 在给定分布法下,PROMIS评估的MCID阈值在多种手术间相似;1/2 SD法下所有手术的MCID阈值范围为3.4至4.5分。
- 除半月板切除术(3.5分)外,锚定法PROMIS MCID阈值(范围4.5至8.1分)高于SD分布法MCID值(2.3至4.5分)。
- 以全髋关节置换术为例,采用锚定法阈值7.9分时76%的患者达到PROMIS MCID;采用MDC 95法(6.1分)时82%达到MCID;采用1/2 SD法(3.9分)时88%达到MCID。
- 同一全髋关节置换术队列采用HOOS(0至100分)时,锚定法阈值17.5分下86%达到MCID;MDC 90法(12.5分)下91%达到MCID;1/2 SD法(8.4分)下93%达到MCID。
- 总体上PROMIS的MCID达标比例低于其他验证结局工具;例如1/2 SD法下,关节镜下半月板部分切除术患者PROMIS Physical Function达标比例为72%,KOOS为86%。
关键数值与推荐
- 1/2 SD法下所有手术的PROMIS MCID阈值范围为3.4至4.5分。
- 锚定法PROMIS MCID阈值范围为4.5至8.1分,SD分布法MCID值范围为2.3至4.5分;半月板切除术锚定法阈值为3.5分。
- 全髋关节置换术:PROMIS锚定法阈值7.9分(达标76%)、MDC 95法6.1分(达标82%)、1/2 SD法3.9分(达标88%);HOOS锚定法阈值17.5分(达标86%)、MDC 90法12.5分(达标91%)、1/2 SD法8.4分(达标93%)。
- 关节镜下半月板部分切除术1/2 SD法下PROMIS Physical Function达标72%,KOOS达标86%。
临床怎么用
- 对于常规收集PROMIS评分的临床实践,个体外科医生可用这些结果评估个人实践趋势,医疗系统可用其量化临床护理举措是否产生有意义的差异。
- 开展PROMIS回顾性结局研究的研究者可使用这些MCID阈值。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs), including the Patient-reported Outcomes Measurement Information System (PROMIS), are increasingly used to measure healthcare value. The minimum clinically important difference (MCID) is a metric that helps clinicians determine whether a statistically detectable improvement in a PROM after surgical care is likely to be large enough to be important to a patient or to justify an intervention that carries risk and cost. There are two major categories of MCID calculation methods, anchor-based and distribution-based. This variability, coupled with heterogeneous surgical cohorts used for existing MCID values, limits their application to clinical care. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: In our study, we sought (1) to determine MCID thresholds and attainment percentages for PROMIS after common orthopaedic procedures using distribution-based methods, (2) to use anchor-based MCID values from published studies as a comparison, and (3) to compare MCID attainment percentages using PROMIS scores to other validated outcomes tools such as the Hip Disability and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score (HOOS) and Knee Disability and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score (KOOS). METHODS: This was a retrospective study at two academic medical centers and three community hospitals. The inclusion criteria for this study were patients who were age 18 years or older and who underwent elective THA for osteoarthritis, TKA for osteoarthritis, one-level posterior lumbar fusion for lumbar spinal stenosis or spondylolisthesis, anatomic total shoulder arthroplasty or reverse total shoulder arthroplasty for glenohumeral arthritis or rotator cuff arthropathy, arthroscopic anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction, arthroscopic partial meniscectomy, or arthroscopic rotator cuff repair. This yielded 14,003 patients. Patients undergoing revision operations or surgery for nondegenerative pathologies and patients without preoperative PROMs assessments were excluded, leaving 9925 patients who completed preoperative PROMIS assessments and 9478 who completed other preoperative validated outcomes tools (HOOS, KOOS, numerical rating scale for leg pain, numerical rating scale for back pain, and QuickDASH). Approximately 66% (6529 of 9925) of patients had postoperative PROMIS scores (Physical Function, Mental Health, Pain Intensity, Pain Interference, and Upper Extremity) and were included for analysis. PROMIS scores are population normalized with a mean score of 50 ± 10, with most scores falling between 30 to 70. Approximately 74% (7007 of 9478) of patients had postoperative historical assessment scores and were included for analysis. The proportion who reached the MCID was calculated for each procedure cohort at 6 months of follow-up using distribution-based MCID methods, which included a fraction of the SD (1/2 or 1/3 SD) and minimum detectable change (MDC) using statistical significance (such as the MDC 90 from p < 0.1). Previously published anchor-based MCID thresholds from similar procedure cohorts and analogous PROMs were used to calculate the proportion reaching MCID. RESULTS: Within a given distribution-based method, MCID thresholds for PROMIS assessments were similar across multiple procedures. The MCID threshold ranged between 3.4 and 4.5 points across all procedures using the 1/2 SD method. Except for meniscectomy (3.5 points), the anchor-based PROMIS MCID thresholds (range 4.5 to 8.1 points) were higher than the SD distribution-based MCID values (2.3 to 4.5 points). The difference in MCID thresholds based on the calculation method led to a similar trend in MCID attainment. Using THA as an example, MCID attainment using PROMIS was achieved by 76% of patients using an anchor-based threshold of 7.9 points. However, 82% of THA patients attained MCID using the MDC 95 method (6.1 points), and 88% reached MCID using the 1/2 SD method (3.9 points). Using the HOOS metric (scaled from 0 to 100), 86% of THA patients reached the anchor-based MCID threshold (17.5 points). However, 91% of THA patients attained the MCID using the MDC 90 method (12.5 points), and 93% reached MCID using the 1/2 SD method (8.4 points). In general, the proportion of patients reaching MCID was lower for PROMIS than for other validated outcomes tools; for example, with the 1/2 SD method, 72% of patients who underwent arthroscopic partial meniscectomy reached the MCID on PROMIS Physical Function compared with 86% on KOOS. CONCLUSION: MCID calculations can provide clinical correlation for PROM scores interpretation. The PROMIS form is increasingly used because of its generalizability across diagnoses. However, we found lower proportions of MCID attainment using PROMIS scores compared with historical PROMs. By using historical proportions of attainment on common orthopaedic procedures and a spectrum of MCID calculation techniques, the PROMIS MCID benchmarks are realizable for common orthopaedic procedures. For clinical practices that routinely collect PROMIS scores in the clinical setting, these results can be used by individual surgeons to evaluate personal practice trends and by healthcare systems to quantify whether clinical care initiatives result in meaningful differences. Furthermore, these MCID thresholds can be used by researchers conducting retrospective outcomes research with PROMIS. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, therapeutic study.
引用
- Karhade AV, Bernstein DN, Desai V, et al. What Is the Clinical Benefit of Common Orthopaedic Procedures as Assessed by the PROMIS Versus Other Validated Outcomes Tools? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2022. PMID: 35543521. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000002241
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。