全髋关节置换术中下肢不等长测量技术:信度与效度的系统综述
该系统综述纳入42项研究共2059名参与者,评估全髋关节置换术前术后下肢不等长量化测量技术的信度与效度。结果显示多数技术评定者内与评定者间信度变异很大,卷尺测量法是有效的临床测量方法,影像技术除双平面放射摄影外均经过适当交叉验证,但缺乏与共同参照技术的验证。
要点
- 卷尺测量法是有效的下肢不等长临床测量方法,而无标记运动分析和垫块法不是。
- 双平面放射摄影的评定者内与评定者间信度均为优秀。
- 影像技术除双平面放射摄影外均经适当交叉验证,但缺乏与共同参照技术的验证。
核心结论
- 大多数测量技术的评定者内与评定者间信度变异很大。
- 卷尺测量法是有效的下肢不等长临床测量方法。
- 影像技术除双平面放射摄影外均经适当交叉验证,但缺乏与共同参照技术的验证。
研究设计与样本
- 遵循PRISMA指南检索Embase和MEDLINE数据库,纳入评估下肢不等长测量技术效度或信度的文章。
- 采用随机效应Meta分析合并数据以得出信度估计值,使用Brink和Louw清单评估研究质量。
- 共纳入42篇文章、2059名参与者,其中33项研究信度、25项研究效度。
主要发现
- 评定者内信度:骨盆前后位X线片为差至优秀,CT扫描图为中等至优秀,临床方法和远距放射摄影为良好至优秀,双平面放射摄影为优秀。
- 评定者间信度:骨盆前后位X线片和临床方法为差至优秀,远距放射摄影为中等至优秀,CT扫描图为良好至优秀,双平面放射摄影为优秀。
- 卷尺测量法是有效的下肢不等长临床测量方法,无标记运动分析和垫块法不是。
- 影像技术除双平面放射摄影外均经适当交叉验证。
关键数值与推荐
- 信度显示高度异质性。
- 卷尺测量法为有效的临床测量方法;无标记运动分析和垫块法不是有效的临床测量方法。
- 影像技术除双平面放射摄影外均经适当交叉验证,但缺乏与共同参照技术的验证。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 信度显示高度异质性。
- 影像技术缺乏与共同参照技术的验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Total hip arthroplasty (THA) carries a substantial litigative burden. THA may introduce leg length discrepancy (LLD), necessitating a valid and reliable technique for LLD measurement. This study investigates the reliability and validity of techniques quantitively measuring LLD in both pre- and post-THA. METHODS: Embase and MEDLINE databases were searched following Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines for articles assessing either the validity or reliability of LLD measurement techniques. Data was pooled using random effects meta-analysis to derive reliability estimates. Study quality was assessed using the Brink and Louw checklist. RESULTS: Forty-two articles with 2059 participants were included. Thirty-three investigated reliability and 25 validity. Reliability displayed high heterogeneity. Poor to excellent intra-rater reliability was reported for antero-posterior pelvis radiographs, moderate to excellent for computed tomography scanograms, and good to excellent for clinical methods and teleradiography, and excellent for bi-planar radiography (BPR). Poor to excellent inter-rater reliability was reported for antero-posterior pelvis radiographs and clinical methods, moderate to excellent for teleradiography, good to excellent for computed tomography scanogram and excellent for BPR. The tape measure method is a valid clinical measure of LLD whilst markerless motion analysis and the block method are not. Imaging techniques are appropriately cross-validated with the exception of BPR. CONCLUSION: The reported intra- and inter-rater reliability for most measurement techniques vary widely. The tape measure method is a valid clinical measurement of LLD. Imaging techniques have been appropriately cross-validated, with the exception of BPR, although they lack validation against a common reference technique.
引用
- Pettit MH, Kanavathy S, McArthur N, et al. Measurement Techniques for Leg Length Discrepancy in Total Hip Arthroplasty: A Systematic Review of Reliability and Validity. J Arthroplasty. 2022. PMID: 35605764. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2022.05.029
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。