文献速递关节外科

保留股骨颈短柄与Corail柄相比结局与迁移无差异但骨密度丢失更多:五年随访随机对照试验

No difference in outcome or migration but greater loss of bone mineral density with the Collum Femoris Preserving stem compared with the Corail stem: a randomized controlled trial with five-year follow-up.
PubMed 文献 · Bone Joint J · 2022-01-01

本研究为随机对照试验,比较保留股骨颈短柄(CFP)与常规非骨水泥柄(Corail)的中期患者报告结局、骨重塑和迁移,81例初始入组、71例完成五年随访。两组牛津髋关节评分无统计学显著差异,RSA显示两组柄均稳定,但CFP组近端Gruen区骨密度丢失显著更多。

要点

  • 两组患者报告结局无统计学显著差异,中位牛津髋关节评分CFP组45分 vs Corail组45分(p=0.568)。
  • RSA显示两组柄均稳定,2至5年间几乎或没有进一步下沉。
  • CFP组近端Gruen区骨密度丢失显著高于Corail组,提示更明显的应力遮挡。

核心结论

  • CFP柄与Corail柄相比具有相似的临床结局和下沉模式。
  • CFP柄可见更明显的近端应力遮挡,提示骨干固定,并对其长期保留股骨颈的特性提出疑问。

研究设计与样本

  • 随机对照试验,初始入组81例患者,五年随访时71例可用。
  • 主要结局指标为牛津髋关节评分(OHS)评估的临床结果。
  • 次要结局包括放射立体测量分析(RSA)测量的柄迁移、柄周围骨密度变化、放射透亮线的出现及其他患者报告结局指标(PROMs)。

主要发现

  • PROMs组间无统计学显著差异:中位OHS CFP组45(四分位距35至48)vs Corail组45(四分位距40至48),p=0.568。
  • RSA显示两组柄均稳定,2至5年间几乎或没有进一步下沉。
  • CFP组9例患者可见股骨颈吸收,而可研究的15例带领Corail柄中无一例出现股骨颈吸收。
  • 双能X线吸收测定显示CFP组近端Gruen区骨密度丢失显著更高:Gruen 1区平均变化CFP -9.5(95%CI -14.8至-4.2)vs Corail 1.0(95%CI 3.4至5.4);Gruen 7区CFP -23.0(95%CI -29.4至-16.6)vs Corail -7.2(95%CI -15.9至1.4)。
  • 两例CFP柄在两年随访前因松动翻修,一例Corail柄在两年后因慢性感染翻修。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

AIMS: The aim of this study was to compare the mid-term patient-reported outcome, bone remodelling, and migration of a short stem (Collum Femoris Preserving; CFP) with a conventional uncemented stem (Corail). METHODS: Of 81 patients who were initially enrolled, 71 were available at five years' follow-up. The outcomes at two years have previously been reported. The primary outcome measure was the clinical result assessed using the Oxford Hip Score (OHS). Secondary outcomes were the migration of the stem, measured using radiostereometric analysis (RSA), change of bone mineral density (BMD) around the stem, the development of radiolucent lines, and additional patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs). RESULTS: There were no statistically significant differences between the groups regarding PROMs (median OHS (CFP 45 (interquartile range (IQR) 35 to 48); Corail 45 (IQR 40 to 48); p = 0.568). RSA showed stable stems in both groups, with little or no further subsidence between two and five years. Resorption of the femoral neck was evident in nine patients in the CFP group and in none of the 15 Corail stems with a collar that could be studied. Dual X-ray absorbiometry showed a significantly higher loss of BMD in the proximal Gruen zones in the CFP group (mean changes in BMD: Gruen zone 1, CFP -9.5 (95% confidence interval (CI) -14.8 to -4.2), Corail 1.0 (95% CI 3.4 to 5.4); Gruen zone 7, CFP -23.0 (95% CI -29.4 to -16.6), Corail -7.2 (95% CI -15.9 to 1.4). Two CFP stems were revised before two years' follow-up due to loosening, and one Corail stem was revised after two years due to chronic infection. CONCLUSION: The CFP stem has a similar clinical outcome and subsidence pattern when compared with the Corail stem. More pronounced proximal stress-shielding was seen with the CFP stem, suggesting diaphyseal fixation, and questioning its femoral neck-sparing properties in the long term. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2022;104-B(5):581-588.

来源:Bone Joint J,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Rilby K, Nauclér E, Mohaddes M, et al. No difference in outcome or migration but greater loss of bone mineral density with the Collum Femoris Preserving stem compared with the Corail stem: a randomized controlled trial with five-year follow-up. Bone Joint J. 2022. PMID: 35491578. doi:10.1302/0301-620X.104B5.BJJ-2021-1539.R1

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。