关节置换术的手术量与结局
该研究基于2009至2015年接受全膝关节或全髋关节置换术的Medicare受益人,描述手术量趋势并用混合效应模型分析术者与医院年手术量与30天并发症或死亡率的关系,同时检验最佳手术量切点。结果显示调整后年并发症率在术者和医院层面均与手术量呈负相关,但2009至2015年间集中化程度极低;每种手术年手术量超过260例后并发症不再下降。约93%的髋关节置换和88%的膝关节置换由手术量未达最佳的术者完成。
要点
- 调整后30天并发症率在术者和医院层面均随手术量增加而下降,但2009至2015年间集中化程度极低。
- 每种关节置换年手术量超过260例后,并发症不再进一步下降。
- 约93%的髋关节置换和88%的膝关节置换由手术量未达最佳的术者完成。
核心结论
- 在关节置换术的手术量-结局关系确立20余年后,许多病例仍由低手术量术者完成,且由手术量未达最佳的术者完成的病例多得多。
- 通过医院和术者层面的集中化,以每位术者每年每种手术至少260例为目标,有望进一步改善结局。
- 支付方似乎最有能力推动集中化。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入2009年至2015年接受全膝关节或全髋关节置换术的Medicare受益人,描述手术量趋势,并使用混合效应模型分析年度术者和医院手术量与30天并发症或死亡率的关系,同时在医院和术者层面检验最佳手术量切点。
主要发现
- 调整后年并发症率在术者和医院层面均与两种手术的手术量呈负相关,但2009年至2015年间集中化程度极低。
- 每种手术年手术量超过260例后,并发症不再下降。
- 约93%的髋关节置换术和88%的膝关节置换术由手术量未达最佳的术者完成。
关键数值与推荐
- 每种关节置换术的术者年手术量最佳切点为至少260例,超过该量后并发症不再下降。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Joint arthroplasties are among the most commonly performed elective surgeries in the United States. Surgical outcomes are known to improve with volume but it is unclear whether this has led to consolidation among elective surgeries. We examined trends in volumes per surgeon and hospital to assess whether the known volume-outcome relationship has led to consolidation in elective joint arthroplasty and to determine if there exist volume thresholds above which outcomes do not change. METHODS: Among Medicare beneficiaries who underwent either total knee or total hip arthroplasty from 2009 through 2015, we described volume trends and used mixed-effect models to relate annual surgeon and hospital volumes with 30-day complications or mortality. We tested for optimal volume cut points at both the hospital and surgeon level. RESULTS: Adjusted annual complication rates were inversely associated with volume for both procedures at both the surgeon level and hospital level, but there was minimal consolidation between 2009 and 2015. Complications no longer declined after volumes of each case exceeded 260 per year. The vast majority of cases (around 93% of hip and 88% of knee arthroplasties) were performed by surgeons operating at suboptimal volumes. CONCLUSION: More than 2 decades after the volume-outcome relationship was established for joint arthroplasty, many cases continue to be performed by low-volume surgeons, with far more cases performed by surgeons operating at suboptimal volumes. Further improvement could be expected through consolidation at both the hospital and surgeon level, with a target of at least 260 cases per surgeon annually for each operation. Payers seem best-equipped to drive consolidation.
引用
- Pappas MA, Spindler KP, Hu B, et al. Volume and Outcomes of Joint Arthroplasty. J Arthroplasty. 2022. PMID: 35568138. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2022.05.011
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。