3D打印胫骨平台骨折模型对低年资外科医生理解骨折是否有用
本研究在1级创伤中心纳入40例胫骨平台骨折患者,由9名创伤外科主治医师、8名高年资住院医师和8名低年资住院医师分别在使用与不使用3D打印模型条件下,按三种分类系统(Schatzker、OA/OTA、Luo三柱概念)对骨折进行分类,并评估置信度与准确性。结果显示3D打印模型仅使两种分类系统的一致性轻微改善,但所有分类系统均未超过中等一致性,且置信度与准确性无改善;作者据此不推荐在实践和研究中用3D打印模型进行胫骨平台骨折分类。
要点
- 3D打印模型使Schatzker分类的观察者间一致性从κ=0.514升至0.539(p=0.005),AO/OTA从κ=0.359升至0.372(p=0.03)。
- 所有分类系统即使由最有经验的创伤外科医生使用,观察者间一致性也均未超过中等水平。
- 使用3D打印模型后,分类骨折的自评置信度或准确性均无改善,所有观察者置信度约7分(10分制)。
核心结论
- 3D打印模型仅使三种分类系统中两种的总体观察者间一致性轻微改善,但所有分类系统均未超过中等一致性。
- 作者认为即使使用3D打印模型,许多骨折仍会被错误分类,可能导致沟通误导、预后评估不准确、研究不清晰和治疗选择错误。
- 因此,作者不推荐在实践和研究中用3D打印模型对胫骨平台骨折进行分类。
研究设计与样本
- 2012年至2020年间在1级创伤中心治疗113例胫骨平台骨折患者,排除44例存在骨疾病(如骨质疏松)和缺少CT扫描者,最终纳入40例。
- 9名创伤外科主治医师、8名高年资住院医师和8名低年资住院医师均未接受研究特定预训练,按Schatzker、OA/OTA和Luo三柱概念三种分类系统,在有和无3D打印模型条件下分类骨折,并用10分Likert量表(0=完全没信心,10=绝对确定)标示总体置信度。
- 由3名在膝关节手术方面具有特殊专长且执业10年至25年的资深创伤外科医生组成专家组,通过达成共识设定金标准。
- 采用Fleiss kappa确定骨折分类的观察者间一致性,使用配对t检验比较有和无3D打印模型评估骨折的置信度差异,通过将观察者结果与金标准比较计算准确性。
主要发现
- 总体观察者间一致性在三种分类系统中的两种轻微改善:Schatzker κconv=0.514 vs κ3Dprint=0.539(p=0.005);AO/OTA κconv=0.359 vs κ3Dprint=0.372(p=0.03)。
- 然而,没有任何分类系统即使由最有经验的创伤外科医生组使用,也未达到超过中等水平的观察者间一致性,意味着很大一部分骨折被至少一名观察者错误分类。
- 总体上,使用3D打印模型后,分类骨折的自评置信度或准确性均无改善;所有观察者置信度较高(10分制约7分),尽管准确性和观察者间一致性为中等或更差。
关键数值与推荐
- Schatzker分类观察者间一致性:传统影像κconv=0.514 vs 3D打印模型κ3Dprint=0.539(p=0.005)。
- AO/OTA分类观察者间一致性:传统影像κconv=0.359 vs 3D打印模型κ3Dprint=0.372(p=0.03)。
- 置信度以10分Likert量表评估,0表示完全没信心,10表示绝对确定;所有观察者置信度约7分。
- 证据等级:Level III,诊断性研究。
临床怎么用
- 作者不推荐在实践和研究中用3D打印模型对胫骨平台骨折进行分类。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Tibial plateau fractures are often complex, and they can be challenging to treat. Classifying fractures is often part of the treatment process, but intra- and interobserver reliability of fracture classification systems often is inadequate to the task, and classifications that lack reliability can mislead providers and result in harm to patients. Three-dimensionally (3D)-printed models might help in this regard, but whether that is the case for the classification of tibial plateau fractures, and whether the utility of such models might vary by the experience of the individual classifying the fractures, is unknown. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) Does the overall interobserver agreement improve when fractures are classified with 3D-printed models compared with conventional radiology? (2) Does interobserver agreement vary among attending and consultant trauma surgeons, senior surgical residents, and junior surgical residents? (3) Do surgeons' and surgical residents' confidence and accuracy improve when tibial plateau fractures are classified with an additional 3D model compared with conventional radiology? METHODS: Between 2012 and 2020, 113 patients with tibial plateau fractures were treated at a Level 1 trauma center. Forty-four patients were excluded based on the presence of bone diseases (such as osteoporosis) and the absence of a CT scan. To increase the chance to detect an improvement or deterioration and to prevent observers from losing focus during the classification, we decided to include 40 patients with tibial plateau fractures. Nine trauma surgeons, eight senior surgical residents, and eight junior surgical residents-none of whom underwent any study-specific pretraining-classified these fractures according to three often-used classification systems (Schatzker, OA/OTA, and the Luo three-column concept), with and without 3D-printed models, and they indicated their overall confidence on a 10-point Likert scale, with 0 meaning not confident at all and 10 absolutely certainty. To set the gold standard, a panel of three experienced trauma surgeons who had special expertise in knee surgery and 10 years to 25 years of experience in practice also classified the fractures until consensus was reached. The Fleiss kappa was used to determine interobserver agreement for fracture classification. Differences in confidence in assessing fractures with and without the 3D-printed model were compared using a paired t-test. Accuracy was calculated by comparing the participants' observations with the gold standard. RESULTS: The overall interobserver agreement improved minimally for fracture classification according to two of three classification systems (Schatzker: κconv = 0.514 versus κ3Dprint = 0.539; p = 0.005; AO/OTA:κconv = 0.359 versus κ3Dprint = 0.372; p = 0.03). However, none of the classification systems, even when used by our most experienced group of trauma surgeons, achieved more than moderate interobserver agreement, meaning that a large proportion of fractures were misclassified by at least one observer. Overall, there was no improvement in self-assessed confidence in classifying fractures or accuracy with 3D-printed models; confidence was high (about 7 points on a 10-point scale) as rated by all observers, despite moderate or worse accuracy and interobserver agreement. CONCLUSION: Although 3D-printed models minimally improved the overall interobserver agreement for two of three classification systems, none of the classification systems achieved more than moderate interobserver agreement. This suggests that even with 3D-printed models, many fractures would be misclassified, which could result in misleading communication, inaccurate prognostic assessments, unclear research, and incorrect treatment choices. Therefore, we cannot recommend the use of 3D-printed models in practice and research for classification of tibial plateau fractures. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, diagnostic study.
引用
- Huitema JM, van der Gaast N, Brouwers L, et al. Are 3D-printed Models of Tibial Plateau Fractures a Useful Addition to Understanding Fractures for Junior Surgeons? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2022. PMID: 35230277. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000002137
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。