文献速递运动医学关节外科

疫苗接种后持续性肩痛与常见偶发病理相关:一项系统综述

Persistent Shoulder Pain After Vaccine Administration Is Associated with Common Incidental Pathology: A Systematic Review.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2022-03-23

该系统综述检索2006年至2020年PubMed和Embase,纳入20篇报告29例疫苗接种后肩痛患者的病例报告,由两名评价者独立评估。57%(16/28)患者有特定诊断,最常见为肩袖肌腱病(9/16)和粘连性肩关节囊炎(4/16);非手术治疗17例中15例症状缓解。作者认为持续性肩痛与常见肩部病理重叠,高度可能为偶发而非因果关联。

要点

  • 57%(16/28)患者有特定诊断,最常见为肩袖肌腱病(9/16)和粘连性肩关节囊炎(4/16)。
  • 非手术治疗17例中15例报告症状缓解,平均评估期6个月。
  • 作者认为疫苗接种后肩痛与常见肩部病理重叠,高度可能为偶发而非因果关联。

核心结论

  • 疫苗接种后持续性肩痛与常见肩部病理重叠,在大型数据库和详细病例报告中均如此,作者认为高度可能为偶发而非因果关联。
  • 在缺乏疫苗特异性肩部病理高质量实验证据的情况下,作者认为最安全健康的做法是假定 perceived SIRVA 是对既有病理新症状的误读,而非新的疫苗特异性病理。

研究设计与样本

  • 2020年8月检索PubMed和Embase 2006年至2020年,检索策略包括肩功能障碍/肩痛/肩滑囊炎/肩袖肌腱炎/粘连性肩关节囊炎/盂肱关节炎与疫苗/接种/免疫,以及SIRVA。
  • 纳入标准为任何详细报告三例或以下疫苗接种后肩痛的病例报告;共纳入20篇报告29例患者,由两名评价者独立评估。
  • 排除1例报告的盂肱关节感染;作者假定偏倚风险高,但未找到病例报告的偏倚评估工具。

主要发现

  • 75%(21/28)患者为女性,平均年龄54±19岁。
  • 82%(23/28)患者至少进行了一项诊断检查,包括X线7例、超声7例、MRI 16例(部分患者接受一种以上影像检查)。
  • 57%(16/28)患者有特定诊断;12例有疼痛和活动受限但无特定病理诊断。
  • 最常见特定诊断为肩袖肌腱病(9/16)和粘连性肩关节囊炎(4/16);较少见包括肩袖关节病(及类风湿关节炎)和疑似化脓性关节炎伴关节镜下非特异性滑膜炎。
  • 非手术治疗17例中15例报告症状缓解,2例症状未完全缓解,平均评估期6个月。

关键数值与推荐

  • 特定诊断比例:57%(16/28)。
  • 最常见特定诊断:肩袖肌腱病9/16,粘连性肩关节囊炎4/16。
  • 非手术治疗缓解比例:15/17,平均评估期6个月。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 作者假定偏倚风险高,但未找到病例报告的偏倚评估工具。
  • 在缺乏疫苗特异性肩部病理高质量实验证据的情况下,作者认为最安全健康的做法是假定SIRVA是对既有病理新症状的误读。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Claims of shoulder injury now account for half of all claims to the Vaccine Injury Compensation Program. Reports from databases of claims or potential adverse events note a relatively high mean age and high prevalences of rotator cuff tendinopathy and adhesive capsulitis-common shoulder problems that might be incidental to vaccination. Published case reports provide much more detail about individual patients than is available in databases. A review of published cases provides an opportunity for more detailed review of symptoms, diagnoses, pathology, treatment, and prognosis. Such a review can better assess the relative likelihood that pathologies associated with new persistent shoulder symptoms after vaccination are coincidental or unique to and caused by vaccine. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: Regarding published case reports addressing persistent shoulder pain after vaccination: (1) In what proportion of patients was a specific diagnosis made? (2) What diagnoses were most common? (3) Among patients treated nonsurgically, what proportion resolved, and over what time span did they resolve? METHODS: In August 2020, we searched PubMed and Embase between 2006 and 2020 using the following search strategy: Search 1: (shoulder dysfunction OR shoulder pain OR shoulder bursitis OR rotator cuff tendonitis OR adhesive capsulitis OR glenohumeral arthritis AND [vaccine OR vaccination OR immunization]); Search 2: (shoulder injury related to vaccine administration or SIRVA). The search was supplemented by reviewing reference lists of identified studies. Inclusion criteria were any detailed report of three or fewer cases involving shoulder pain after vaccine administration. Twenty published reports of 29 patients were identified and assessed by two reviewers independently. One reported glenohumeral joint infection was excluded because the relationship between this type of relatively uncommon, discrete diagnosis and vaccination raises different considerations. We assumed a high risk of bias, although we are not aware of bias assessment tool for case reports. We recorded and summarized patient demographics, symptoms, examination and imaging findings, surgery findings, diagnoses, treatments, and outcomes. Seventy-five percent (21 of 28) of patients were women, with a mean age of 54 ± 19 years. In search of an underlying pathology, at least one diagnostic study was performed in 82% (23 of 28) of patients including radiographs in seven, ultrasound in seven, and MRI in 16 patients (some patients underwent more than one type of imaging). We distinguished specific pathophysiological diagnosis from shoulder pain and stiffness, counted the most common diagnoses among patients a specific diagnosis, and tracked symptom resolution among patients treated nonoperatively. RESULTS: A specific diagnosis was made in 57% (16 of 28) of patients. Twelve patients had pain and limitation of motion due to pain but no specific pathological diagnosis. The most common specific diagnoses were rotator cuff tendinopathy (9 of 16) and adhesive capsulitis (4 of 16). Less common specific diagnoses included rotator cuff arthropathy (and rheumatoid arthritis) and suspected septic arthritis with nonspecific synovitis on arthroscopy. One patient had transient MRI signal change in the humeral head, which was interpreted as osteonecrosis that resolved in a manner not typical for that diagnosis. Of the 17 patients treated nonsurgically, 15 reported resolution, and two had incomplete symptom resolution with the mean 6-month evaluation period. CONCLUSION: The observation that persistent shoulder pain after vaccination overlaps with common shoulder pathology-both in large databases as well as in more detailed reports of specific patients as analyzed in this review-establishes a high probability of a coincidental rather than a causal association. In the absence of high-quality experimental evidence of vaccine-specific shoulder pathology, in our opinion, it seems safest and healthiest to assume that perceived shoulder injury related to vaccine administration (SIRVA) is due to misinterpretation of new symptoms from established pathology rather than a new, vaccine-specific pathology. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level IV, therapeutic study.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Slette E, Rohrback M, Ring D, et al. Persistent Shoulder Pain After Vaccine Administration Is Associated with Common Incidental Pathology: A Systematic Review. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2022. PMID: 35319515. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000002191

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。