文献速递关节外科

关节置换外科医生在术中软组织评估上存在差异:一项在人体尸体上量化全膝关节置换术手术决策的研究

Arthroplasty Surgeons Differ in Their Intraoperative Soft Tissue Assessments: A Study in Human Cadavers to Quantify Surgical Decision-making in TKA.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2022-03-24

研究利用7具非关节炎人体尸体下肢,由5名关节置换外科医生和1名首席住院医师独立评估全膝关节置换术软组织平衡并选择聚乙烯衬垫厚度。结果显示医生间施加的力矩在屈膝中期和屈曲位存在差异,测量的间隙在所有屈曲角度均存在差异,衬垫厚度选择与施加力矩呈弱相关。

要点

  • 医生间在屈膝中期和屈曲位施加的内翻力矩存在差异,屈膝中期平均差异最大为16.5 Nm(p=0.02)。
  • 医生间测量的内外侧间隙在所有屈曲角度均存在差异,屈曲位平均差异最大为1.1±0.4 mm(p<0.001)。
  • 衬垫厚度选择与伸展位内翻、外翻及屈曲位内翻施加力矩呈弱相关,最大回归系数β=-0.11提示力矩每增加9 Nm衬垫厚度选择减少1 mm。

核心结论

  • 在人体尸体模型的全膝关节置换术软组织评估中,5名外科医生和1名首席住院医师在屈膝中期和屈曲位施加不同力矩,并在伸展位、屈膝中期和屈曲位针对不同间隙。
  • 施加力矩与衬垫选择呈弱相关,屈曲位和伸展位力矩变化分别为9 Nm和11 Nm(对应医生手部22至27 N力)时,衬垫厚度选择至少改变1 mm。
  • 作者认为衬垫厚度选择在体内手术中可能对施加力矩更敏感,因为外科医生在衬垫厚度之外有更多选择余地。

研究设计与样本

  • 获取7具非关节炎人体尸体下肢(骨盆至足趾),包括5例女性和2例男性,平均年龄73±7岁,平均BMI 25.8±3.8 kg/m²。
  • 仅对右膝行后交叉韧带替代型(后稳定型)全膝关节置换术。
  • 5名完成关节置换专科培训的膝关节外科医生(临床经验分别为24、15、15、7、6年)和1名首席骨科住院医师独立评估每例膝关节在伸展位(屈曲0°)、屈膝中期(屈曲30°)和屈曲位(屈曲90°)的软组织平衡,并据此选择聚乙烯衬垫。
  • 使用柔性力传感器缠绕腿部测量每位医生施加的负荷,三维运动捕捉系统测量膝关节运动学,动态分析软件估算内外侧间隙。
  • 采用重复测量方差分析比较医生间平均施加力矩和平均内外侧间隙(p<0.05为差异显著),采用广义估计方程分析施加力矩与衬垫厚度选择的关联(p<0.05为显著关联)。

主要发现

  • 医生间施加的力矩存在差异,最大平均差异出现在屈膝中期内翻(16.5 Nm;p=0.02)和屈曲位(7.9 Nm;p<0.001)。
  • 医生间测量的间隙在所有屈曲角度均存在差异,最大平均差异出现在屈曲位(1.1±0.4 mm;p<0.001)。
  • 除1例外,所有膝关节的衬垫厚度选择在医生间相差1 mm。
  • 衬垫厚度选择与伸展位内翻(β=-0.06±0.02[95%CI -0.11至-0.01];p=0.03)、伸展位外翻(β=-0.09±0.03[95%CI -0.18至-0.01];p=0.03)和屈曲位内翻(β=-0.11±0.04[95%CI -0.22至0.00];p=0.04)施加力矩呈弱关联。
  • 最大回归系数(β=-0.11)提示施加内翻力矩每增加9 Nm(假设小腿长0.4 m,即足部施加22 N力),衬垫厚度选择减少1 mm。

关键数值与推荐

  • 医生间施加力矩比较采用重复测量方差分析,p<0.05视为显著不同。
  • 医生间测量间隙比较采用重复测量方差分析,p<0.05视为显著不同。
  • 施加力矩与衬垫厚度选择的关联采用广义估计方程,p<0.05视为显著关联。

临床怎么用

  • 在5名不同经验水平的关节置换外科医生和1名首席住院医师中,主观软组织评估导致衬垫厚度选择存在1至2 mm的差异。
  • 作者认为,开发全膝关节置换术软组织评估标准化工具的开发者应考虑控制外科医生施加的力,以更好地控制衬垫选择的变化。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: In TKA, soft tissue balancing is assessed through manual intraoperative trialing. This assessment is a physical examination via manually applied forces at the ankle, generating varus and valgus moments at the knee while the surgeon visualizes the lateral and medial gaps at the joint line. Based on this examination, important surgical decisions are made that influence knee stability, such as choosing the polyethylene insert thickness. Yet, the applied forces and the assessed gaps in this examination represent a qualitative art that relies on each surgeon's intuition, experience, and training. Therefore, the extent of variation among surgeons in conducting this exam, in terms of applied loads and assessed gaps, is unknown. Moreover, whether variability in the applied loads yields different surgical decisions, such as choice of insert thickness, is also unclear. Thus, surgeons and developers have no basis for deciding to what extent the applied loads need to be standardized and controlled during a knee balance exam in TKA. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) Do the applied moments in soft tissue assessment differ among surgeons? (2) Do the assessed gaps in soft tissue assessment differ among surgeons? (3) Is the choice of insert thickness associated with the applied moments? METHODS: Seven independent human cadaveric nonarthritic lower extremities from pelvis to toe were acquired (including five females and two males with a mean age of 73 ± 7 years and a mean BMI of 25.8 ± 3.8 kg/m 2 ). Posterior cruciate ligament substituting (posterior stabilized) TKA was performed only on the right knees. Five fellowship-trained knee surgeons (with 24, 15, 15, 7, and 6 years of clinical experience) and one chief orthopaedic resident independently examined soft tissue balance in each knee in extension (0° of flexion), midflexion (30° of flexion), and flexion (90° of flexion) and selected a polyethylene insert based on their assessment. Pliable force sensors were wrapped around the leg to measure the loads applied by each surgeon. A three-dimensional (3D) motion capture system was used to measure knee kinematics and a dynamic analysis software was used to estimate the medial and lateral gaps. We assessed (1) whether surgeons applied different moments by comparing the mean applied moment by surgeons in extension, midflexion, and flexion using repeated measures (RM)-ANOVA (p < 0.05 was assumed significantly different); (2) whether surgeons assessed different gaps by comparing the mean medial and lateral gaps in extension, midflexion, and flexion using RM-ANOVA (p < 0.05 was assumed significantly different); and (3) whether the applied moments in extension, midflexion, and flexion were associated with the insert thickness choice using a generalized estimating equation (p < 0.05 was assumed a significant association). RESULTS: The applied moments differed among surgeons, with the largest mean differences occurring in varus in midflexion (16.5 Nm; p = 0.02) and flexion (7.9 Nm; p < 0.001). The measured gaps differed among surgeons at all flexion angles, with the largest mean difference occurring in flexion (1.1 ± 0.4 mm; p < 0.001). In all knees except one, the choice of insert thickness varied by l mm among surgeons. The choice of insert thickness was weakly associated with the applied moments in varus (β = -0.06 ± 0.02 [95% confidence interval -0.11 to -0.01]; p = 0.03) and valgus (β = -0.09 ± 0.03 [95% CI -0.18 to -0.01]; p= 0.03) in extension and in varus in flexion (β = -0.11 ± 0.04 [95% CI -0.22 to 0.00]; p = 0.04). To put our findings in context, the greatest regression coefficient (β = -0.11) indicates that for every 9-Nm increase in the applied varus moment (that is, 22 N of force applied to the foot assuming a shank length of 0.4 m), the choice of insert thickness decreased by 1 mm. CONCLUSION: In TKA soft tissue assessment in a human cadaver model, five surgeons and one chief resident applied different moments in midflexion and flexion and targeted different gaps in extension, midflexion, and flexion. A weak association between the applied moments in extension and flexion and the insert choice was observed. Our results indicate that in the manual assessment of soft tissue, changes in the applied moments of 9 and 11 Nm (22 to 27 N on the surgeons' hands) in flexion and extension, respectively, yielded at least a 1-mm change in choice of insert thickness. The choice of insert thickness may be more sensitive to the applied moments in in vivo surgery because the surgeon is allowed a greater array of choices beyond insert thickness. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Among five arthroplasty surgeons with different levels of experience and a chief resident, subjective soft tissue assessment yielded 1 to 2 mm of variation in their choice of insert thickness. Therefore, developers of tools to standardize soft tissue assessment in TKA should consider controlling the force applied by the surgeon to better control for variations in insert selection.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Elmasry SS, Sculco PK, Kahlenberg CA, et al. Arthroplasty Surgeons Differ in Their Intraoperative Soft Tissue Assessments: A Study in Human Cadavers to Quantify Surgical Decision-making in TKA. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2022. PMID: 35323146. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000002184

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。