内置关节稳定器与标准化方案能否预防复杂持续性肘关节不稳的复发性不稳?
该回顾性研究纳入14例创伤后复杂持续性肘关节不稳患者,采用铰链式内置关节稳定器联合标准化方案治疗,术后无复发性不稳,疼痛、残疾、功能及活动度均改善;是否发生创伤后关节炎与术后结局无差异。
要点
- 内置关节稳定器联合标准化方案可维持同心复位并允许早期功能活动。
- 术后VAS、DASH、MEPS及活动度均较术前改善(p < 0.001)。
- 是否发生创伤后关节炎与术后疼痛、残疾、功能及活动度无差异。
核心结论
- 在这项小型回顾性研究中,内置关节稳定器联合标准化治疗方案可维持同心复位并允许早期功能活动,且可改善复杂持续性肘关节不稳患者的临床结局。
- 但必须告知患者,可能发生与桡骨头假体相关的并发症,且早期活动的获益必须补偿额外取出手术及血清肿形成的风险。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,纳入2014年9月至2019年10月在本院因创伤性肘关节骨折脱位初始治疗后持续脱位或半脱位而接受治疗的患者。
- 潜在合格条件为年龄至少20岁、损伤(初始治疗)与索引重建手术间隔6周或以上且手术在本院进行。
- 22例中82%(18/22)合格,14%(3/22)因行全肘关节置换被排除,另5%(1/22)在最低1年随访前失访,最终64%(14/22)纳入分析。
- 14例(14肘)接受内置关节稳定器及标准化方案,包括清创关节成形术加尺神经松解、骨与韧带结构恢复(再附着)、应用内置关节稳定器及早期康复。
- 8男6女,中位年龄44岁(范围21至68);初始损伤类型为恐怖三联征7例、后外侧旋转损伤4例、后孟氏骨折3例。
主要发现
- 装置取出期间及之后无复发性不稳。
- 7例发生并发症,包括伤口感染、血清肿、神经血管损伤、内固定物并发症及异位骨化;2例并发症与内置关节稳定器相关,3例与桡骨头假体相关。
- 术前至术后中位(范围)变化:疼痛VAS从5(2至9)降至0(0至3),中位数差值-5,p < 0.001。
- 残疾DASH从41(16至66)降至7(0至46),中位数差值-34,p < 0.001;功能MEPS从60(25至70)改善至95(65至100),中位数差值35,p < 0.001。
- 伸直-屈曲弧从40°(10°至70°)改善至113°(75°至140°),中位数差值73°,p < 0.001;旋前-旋后弧从78°(30°至165°)改善至148°(70°至175°),中位数差值70°,p < 0.001。
关键数值与推荐
- 术后疼痛VAS:发生创伤后关节炎组0(0至3)vs 未发生组0(0至1),中位数差值0,p = 0.17。
- 术后残疾DASH:发生创伤后关节炎组7(0至46)vs 未发生组7(0至18),中位数差值0,p = 0.40。
- 术后功能MEPS:发生创伤后关节炎组80(65至100)vs 未发生组95(75至100),中位数差值15,p = 0.79。
- 术后伸直-屈曲弧:发生创伤后关节炎组105°(75°至140°)vs 未发生组115°(80°至125°),中位数差值10°,p = 0.40。
- 术后旋前-旋后弧:发生创伤后关节炎组155°(125°至175°)vs 未发生组135°(70°至160°),中位数差值-20°,p < 0.18。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,内置关节稳定器联合标准化治疗方案可维持同心复位、允许早期功能活动并改善复杂持续性肘关节不稳患者的临床结局。
- 作者建议必须告知患者可能发生与桡骨头假体相关的并发症,且早期活动的获益必须补偿额外取出手术及血清肿形成的风险。
- 本研究中铰链式内置关节稳定器在术后6至8周于全身麻醉下通过另一次开放手术取出。
局限性
- 这是一项小型回顾性研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The treatment of complex persistent elbow instability after trauma is challenging. Previous studies on treatments have reported varied surgical techniques, which makes it difficult to establish a therapeutic algorithm. Furthermore, the surgical procedures may not sufficiently restore elbow stability, even with an additional device, and a noted high rate of arthritis progression.While a recently developed internal joint stabilizer effectively treats elbow instability, its clinical application for complex persistent elbow instability is limited and the standardized protocol is not well described. Additionally, we want to know whether the arthritis progression will cause a negative impact on the functional outcomes of complex persistent elbow instability. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) Does treatment of complex persistent elbow instability with a hinged internal joint stabilizer and a standardized protocol prevent recurrent instability and other complications? (2) What are the pre- to postoperative improvements in pain, disability, elbow performance, and ROM? (3) Is the development of post-traumatic arthritis associated with worse pain, disability, elbow performance, and ROM? METHODS: Between September 2014 and October 2019, we treated 22 patients for persistent dislocation or subluxation after initial treatment of traumatic elbow fracture-dislocations. Of those, we considered patients who were at least 20 years of age, with an interval of 6 weeks or more between the injury (initial treatment) and the index reconstructive procedure, which had been performed at our institute, as potentially eligible. During that time, we used an internal joint stabilizer with a standardized protocol for posttraumatic complex persistent elbow instability. We performed total elbow replacements in patients older than 50 years who had advanced elbow arthritis. Based on that, 82% (18 of 22) of patients were eligible; 14% (3 of 22) were excluded because total elbow replacements was undertaken, and another 5% (1 of 22) were lost before the minimum study follow-up of 1 year (median 24 months [range 12 to 63]), leaving 64% (14 of 22) for analysis in this retrospective study. We treated 14 patients (14 elbows) with posttraumatic complex persistent elbow instability with an internal joint stabilizer and a standardized protocol that comprised debridement arthroplasty with ulnar neurolysis, restoration of bony and ligamentous (reattachment) structures, application of an internal joint stabilizer, and early rehabilitation. There were eight men and six women in this study, with a median (range) age of 44 years (21 to 68). The initial elbow fracture-dislocation injury pattern was a terrible triad injury in seven patients, a posterolateral rotatory injury in four patients, and a posterior Monteggia fracture in three patients. Preoperative and follow-up radiographs were reviewed for evidence of recurrent instability and arthritis. Complications such as wound infection, seroma, neurovascular injury, and hardware complications were ascertained through chart review. Preoperative and postoperative VAS score for pain, DASH, and Mayo Elbow Performance Scores (MEPS) were collected and compared. Furthermore, extension-flexion and supination-pronation arcs were collected by chart review. We divided the patients into two groups according to whether or not they developed posttraumatic arthritis. We then presented the differences between pain, disability, elbow performance, and ROM. The hinged internal joint stabilizer was removed using another open procedure under general anesthesia 6 to 8 weeks after surgery. RESULTS: There were no recurrent instability during and after device removal. Seven patients developed complications, including wound infection, seroma, neurovascular injury, hardware complications, and heterotopic ossification. Two patients had complications related to internal joint stabilizers and three had complications linked to radial head prostheses. Median (range) preoperative to postoperative changes included decreased pain (VAS 5 [2 to 9] to 0 [0 to 3], difference of medians -5; p < 0.001), decreased disability (DASH 41 [16 to 66] to 7 [0 to 46], difference of medians -34; p < 0.001), improved function (MEPS 60 [25 to 70] to 95 [65 to 100], difference of medians 35; p < 0.001), improved extension-flexion arc (40° [10° to 70°] to 113° [75° to 140°], difference of medians 73°; p < 0.001), and supination-pronation arc (78° [30° to 165°] to 148° [70° to 175°], difference of medians 70°; p < 0.001). Between patients with and without development of post-traumatic arthritis, there were no differences in postoperative pain (VAS 0 [0 to 3] to 0 [0 to 1], difference of medians 0; p = 0.17), disability (DASH 7 [0 to 46] to 7 [0 to 18], difference of medians 0; p = 0.40), function (MEPS 80 [65 to 100] to 95 [75 to 100], difference of medians 15; p = 0.79), extension-flexion arc (105° [75° to 140°] to 115° [80° to 125°], difference of medians 10°; p = 0.40), and supination-pronation arc (155° [125° to 175°] to 135° [70° to 160°], difference of medians -20°; p < 0.18). CONCLUSION: In this small, retrospective study, we found that an internal joint stabilizer with a standardized treatment protocol could maintain concentric reduction while allowing early functional motion, and that it could improve clinical outcomes for patients with complex persistent elbow instability. However, patients must be counseled that the complications related to the radial head prostheses may occur, and that the benefits of early motion must compensate for an additional removal procedure and the risk of seroma formation. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level IV, therapeutic study.
引用
- Ma CH, Hsueh YH, Wu CH, et al. Does an Internal Joint Stabilizer and Standardized Protocol Prevent Recurrent Instability in Complex Persistent Elbow Instability? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2022. PMID: 35266916. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000002159
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。