膝关节置换术后松弛临床检查的评分者间信度
10例全膝关节置换术后患者由4名经过专科培训的关节外科医生以随机顺序、盲法进行前抽屉试验(30°和90°屈曲)及内外翻测试,并用动作捕捉估算关节反作用力。作者认为置换术后不稳不应仅凭临床检查诊断,应结合完整临床评估。
要点
- 内外翻测试的评分者间信度同样差,检查者施加力量的信度也差。
- 作者认为置换术后不稳不应仅凭临床检查诊断,应结合完整临床评估。
核心结论
- 使用动作分析时,全膝关节置换术后膝关节松弛的临床检查在不同外科医生之间信度差。
- 目前尚不清楚该结果源于检查者技术差异,还是源于受试者疼痛或股四头肌功能差异。
- 全膝关节置换术后不稳不应严格依据临床检查诊断,应结合对患者的完整临床评估。
研究设计与样本
- 10例既往接受全膝关节置换术的受试者由4名经过专科培训的骨科膝关节置换外科医生进行检查。
- 每名外科医生以随机顺序评估每名受试者,并对其他外科医生的结果设盲。
- 每名外科医生在屈曲30°和90°时进行前抽屉试验,并将不稳分级为0-5 mm、5-10 mm或>10 mm;内外翻测试也进行分级。
- 检查过程中使用动作捕捉确定关节位置并估算检查时的关节反作用力。
主要发现
- 内外翻测试的评分者间信度同样差。
- 检查者施加力量的信度也差。
关键数值与推荐
- 原文提到屈曲时前后平移超过10 mm在屈曲不稳诊断中被描述为重要。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为全膝关节置换术后不稳不应严格依据临床检查诊断,应结合对患者的完整临床评估。
局限性
- 目前尚不清楚信度差源于检查者技术差异,还是源于受试者疼痛或股四头肌功能差异。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The clinical examination for laxity has been considered a mainstay in evaluation of the painful knee arthroplasty, especially for the diagnosis of instability. More than 10 mm of anterior-posterior (AP) translation in flexion has been described as important in the diagnosis of flexion instability. The inter-observer reliability of varus/valgus and AP laxity testing has not been tested. METHODS: Ten subjects with prior to total knee arthroplasty (TKA) were examined by 4 fellowship-trained orthopedic knee arthroplasty surgeons. Each surgeon evaluated each subject in random order and was blinded to the results of the other surgeons. Each surgeon performed an anterior drawer test at 30 and 90 degrees of flexion and graded the instability as 0-5 mm, 5-10 mm or >10 mm. Varus-valgus testing was also graded. Motion capture was used during the examination to determine the joint position and estimate joint reaction force during the examination. RESULTS: Inter-rater reliability (IRR) was poor at 30 and 90 degrees for both the subjective rater score and the measured AP laxity in flexion (k = 018-0.22). Varus-valgus testing similarly had poor reliability. Force applied by the rater also had poor IRR. CONCLUSION: Clinical testing of knee laxity after TKA has poor reliability between surgeons using motion analysis. It is unclear if this is from differences in examiner technique or from differences in pain or quadriceps function of the subjects. Instability after TKA should not be diagnosed strictly by clinical testing and should involve a complete clinical assessment of the patient.
引用
- Mears SC, Severin AC, Wang J, et al. Inter-Rater Reliability of Clinical Testing for Laxity After Knee Arthroplasty. J Arthroplasty. 2022. PMID: 35307526. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2022.03.044
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。