比较三种用于决定髋关节置换术中是否使用骨水泥的评分系统在骨折患者中的可靠性及手术经验的影响:Spotorno、Dorr与髓腔喇叭指数
本研究比较了Spotorno标准、Dorr指数和髓腔喇叭指数在决定髋关节置换术中是否使用骨水泥的可靠性,并评估手术经验的影响。60例髋关节前后位X线片由4名骨科医生和4名骨科住院医师评估,间隔4周两次测量。Spotorno标准的观察者内和观察者间可靠性均高于Dorr指数和髓腔喇叭指数,且更适用于决定骨水泥与非骨水泥髋关节置换。
要点
- Spotorno标准的观察者内一致性为「优秀」,且观察者间一致性最高。
- 髓腔喇叭指数的观察者内一致性最低。
- Spotorno标准在决定骨水泥与非骨水泥髋关节置换方面更有用。
核心结论
- Spotorno标准的观察者内和观察者间可靠性均高于Dorr指数和髓腔喇叭指数。
- Spotorno标准在决定骨水泥与非骨水泥髋关节置换方面更有用。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入60例髋关节的前后位X线片,由4名骨科医生和4名骨科住院医师进行评估。
- 观察者使用Spotorno标准、Dorr指数和髓腔喇叭指数进行测量,并决定使用骨水泥或非骨水泥股骨柄。
- 同一批X线片在4周后以不同顺序发送给所有参与者进行第二次评估。
- 使用SPSS软件(版本24.0)进行统计分析,观察者内一致性通过组内相关系数(ICC)确定,观察者间可靠性通过加权kappa(κ)统计量计算。
主要发现
- 患者平均年龄为73.1 ± 12.1岁。
- 33例(55%)患者为女性,32例(53.3%)骨折位于右侧。
- 根据Spotorno标准,所有参与者的观察者内一致性为「优秀」。
- 髓腔喇叭指数的观察者内一致性最低。
- 使用Spotorno标准时观察者间一致性最高。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: No consensus has been reached regarding the best index to decide whether to use cement during hip replacement surgery. Therefore, this study compared the reliability of three frequently used scoring systems. The secondary purpose was to evaluate the effect of surgical experience on the decision to use cement. METHODS: Anteroposterior radiographs of 60 hips were assessed by four orthopedic surgeons and four orthopedic residents. The observers were asked to make measurements using the Spotorno criteria, the Dorr index, and the canal flare index, and to decide whether to use a cemented or cementless femoral stem. The same X-rays were sent to all participants, in a different order, 4 weeks later, for a second evaluation. The SPSS software (version 24.0) was used for the statistical analysis. Intraobserver agreement was determined for all observers via the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC), and interobserver reliability was calculated using the weighted kappa (κ) statistic. RESULTS: The average age of the patients were 73.1 ± 12.1 years. Thirty-three (55%) patients were female and thirty-two (53.3%) had fractures on the right side. Intraobserver agreement was "excellent" for all participants according to the Spotorno criteria. The canal flare index had the lowest intra-observer agreement. The highest interobserver agreement was found using the Spotorno criteria. CONCLUSION: The intra- and interobserver reliabilities of the Spotorno criteria were higher than those of the Dorr index and the canal flare index. The Spotorno criteria was more useful for deciding between cemented and un-cemented hip arthroplasty.
引用
- Kacmaz IE, Turgut A, Basa CD, et al. Comparison of the Reliability of Three Scoring Systems Used to Decide Whether to Apply Cement in Hip Arthroplasty Among Fracture Patients and the Effect of Surgical Experience: The Spotorno, Dorr, and Canal Flare Indices. J Arthroplasty. 2022. PMID: 35337947. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2022.03.062
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。