早期与延期手术治疗孤立性前交叉韧带及多韧带膝关节损伤结果等效:系统综述与Meta分析
该系统综述与Meta分析评估早期与延期手术治疗孤立性前交叉韧带(ACL)或多韧带膝关节损伤(MLIK)的优劣,分别以3周和6周为界区分早期与延期。孤立性ACL手术16项研究2093例患者,高级别证据显示早期与延期在半月板或软骨损伤、失败与再手术率、僵硬、活动度缺损、并发症、肌力、仪器测量松弛度及功能结果上均无差异(均P>.05)。MLIK手术14项研究1172例患者,低级别证据显示早期组半月板损伤(RR 0.7;P=.04)和软骨损伤(RR 0.5;P<.001)显著更少,其余结局无差异。
要点
- 孤立性ACL损伤早期与延期手术在临床和功能结果上无差异(高级别证据,均P>.05)。
- MLIK早期手术组半月板损伤RR 0.7(P=.04)、软骨损伤RR 0.5(P<.001),显著少于延期组(低级别证据)。
- MLIK 3周分析中早期组Lysholm评分更高(平均差6.8;P=.01),其余截断分析无差异。
核心结论
- 孤立性ACL损伤早期与延期手术在临床和功能结果上无差异。
- MLIK损伤早期与延期手术在手术结果上亦无差异。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与Meta分析,纳入1、2、3级研究;证据等级为4级。
- 通过PubMed、EMBASE和Cochrane系统检索报告孤立性ACL损伤或MLIK手术时机结局的研究,采用加速康复方案。
- 以3周和6周两个截断值区分早期与延期治疗进行分析。
- 孤立性ACL手术纳入16项研究共2093例患者;MLIK手术纳入14项研究共1172例患者。
主要发现
- 孤立性ACL手术:高级别证据显示早期与延期组在半月板或软骨损伤、失败与再手术率、僵硬、活动度缺损、并发症、肌力、仪器测量松弛度及功能结果上均无差异(均P>.05)。
- 孤立性ACL手术:仅纳入未设术前早期手术标准的研究时,结果相似。
- MLIK手术:低级别证据显示早期组半月板损伤显著更少(RR 0.7;P=.04),软骨损伤显著更少(RR 0.5;P<.001)。
- MLIK手术:再手术率、并发症、僵硬、活动度缺损、肌力、仪器测量松弛度及功能结果在两组间无差异。
- MLIK手术:除3周分析中早期组Lysholm评分更高(平均差6.8;P=.01)外,其他截断分析无差异。
关键数值与推荐
- 孤立性ACL手术:早期与延期组所有比较均P>.05。
- MLIK手术:早期组半月板损伤RR 0.7(P=.04),软骨损伤RR 0.5(P<.001)。
- MLIK手术3周分析:早期组Lysholm评分平均差6.8(P=.01)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Early surgery for acute ligamentous injuries has recently shown good clinical and functional outcomes. PURPOSE: To assess the advantages of early vs delayed surgery in patients undergoing isolated anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) or multiligament-injured knee (MLIK) surgery. STUDY DESIGN: Meta-analyses of Level 1, 2, and 3 studies; Level of evidence, 4. METHODS: A systematic search was performed via PubMed, EMBASE, and Cochrane for studies reporting outcomes of timing of surgery after isolated ACL injury or in the MLIK setting using accelerated rehabilitation protocols. Two analyses were conducted to differentiate early and delayed treatment (3- and 6-week cutoffs). Collected outcomes included meniscal or chondral lesions, failure and reoperation rates, range of motion (ROM) deficits, other complications, muscle strength, instrumented laxity, and functional outcomes. Outcomes were reported in risk ratios (RR) or mean differences with 95% CIs. RESULTS: For timing of isolated ACL surgery, 16 studies were included with 2093 patients. High-grade evidence indicated that there were no differences in meniscal or chondral lesions, failure and reoperation rates, stiffness, ROM deficits, complications, muscle strength, instrumented laxity, and functional outcomes between patients treated early and late (all P > .05). When including only studies that set no preoperative criteria for early surgery, the findings were similar. Regarding MLIK surgery, 14 studies were included with 1172 patients. Low evidence was noted for the following: patients treated early had significantly fewer meniscal injuries (RR, 0.7; P = .04) and chondral injuries (RR, 0.5; P < .001), while no differences were found in reoperation rates, complications, stiffness, ROM deficits, muscle strength, instrumented laxity, and functional outcomes between the groups. Other than higher Lysholm scores in the early group for the 3-week analysis (mean difference, 6.8; P = .01), there were no differences between cutoff analyses. CONCLUSION: This systematic review with meta-analysis found no differences in clinical and functional outcomes between early and delayed surgery for isolated ACL injuries. For MLIK injuries, there were also no differences in surgical outcomes between early and delayed surgery.
引用
- Vermeijden HD, Yang XA, Rademakers MV, et al. Early and Delayed Surgery for Isolated ACL and Multiligamentous Knee Injuries Have Equivalent Results: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Am J Sports Med. 2022. PMID: 35099334. doi:10.1177/03635465211069356
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。