关节镜与开放/小切口肩袖修复长期临床与影像学结局的系统综述
该系统综述纳入11项研究、550肩(539例患者),平均随访14.0年,比较关节镜与开放/小切口肩袖修复的长期结局。术后Constant评分(44至78分)与ASES评分(52%至91%)均显著改善(均P < .001),再撕裂率41%(141/342肩),两组间无显著差异(关节镜43% vs 开放/小切口39%,P = .364)。再撕裂与Constant评分显著降低相关(P = .004)。
要点
- 平均随访14.0年,Constant评分从44分改善至78分,ASES评分从52%改善至91%(均P < .001)。
- 总体再撕裂率41%(141/342肩),关节镜组43% vs 开放/小切口组39%,无显著差异(P = .364)。
- 再撕裂与Constant评分显著降低相关(P = .004),两组术后功能评分、并发症及再撕裂率无显著差异。
核心结论
- 关节镜与开放/小切口肩袖修复的汇总分析显示,两组长期肩关节评分和疼痛均持续改善,但再撕裂率较高,且再撕裂与肩关节功能较差相关。
- 两种技术在长期功能结局、再撕裂率和并发症方面无显著差异,两种手术技术可根据患者或术者偏好及费用等因素选用。
- 作者建议开展更稳健的随机对照试验或更大队列设计的研究,以确定一种修复技术是否优于另一种。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,证据等级4级,遵循PRISMA指南。
- 检索CENTRAL(Cochrane)、MEDLINE(PubMed)和Embase数据库,纳入报告全层肩袖撕裂关节镜或开放/小切口修复长期临床和影像学结局、随访至少9年的研究。
- 共纳入11项研究:5项关于关节镜修复,6项关于开放/小切口修复;基于550肩(539例患者),平均年龄56.3岁(范围25-77岁)。
主要发现
- 平均随访14.0年(范围9-20年),术前平均绝对Constant评分从44分改善至术后78分,ASES肩关节评分从52%改善至91%(两项比较均P < .001)。
- 再撕裂率为41%(141/342肩),组间无显著差异:关节镜组43% vs 开放/小切口组39%(P = .364)。
- 与愈合的修复相比,再撕裂与Constant评分显著降低相关(P = .004)。
- 关节镜与开放/小切口修复组在术后功能评分、并发症及失败修复后的再撕裂率方面无显著差异。
关键数值与推荐
- 纳入标准:报告全层肩袖撕裂关节镜或开放/小切口修复长期临床和影像学结局、随访至少9年的研究。
- 再撕裂率:总体41%(141/342肩);关节镜组43% vs 开放/小切口组39%(P = .364)。
- Constant评分:术前44分 vs 术后78分(P < .001);ASES评分:术前52% vs 术后91%(P < .001)。
- 再撕裂与Constant评分降低相关(P = .004)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,两种手术技术可根据患者或术者偏好及费用等因素选用。
- 作者建议开展更稳健的随机对照试验或更大队列设计的研究,以确定一种修复技术是否优于另一种。
局限性
- 作者建议开展更稳健的随机对照试验或更大队列设计的研究,以确定一种修复技术是否优于另一种。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Arthroscopic rotator cuff repair (aRCR) has shown similar midterm functional results and retear rates as open/mini-open rotator cuff repair (oRCR). A pooled analysis of long-term results of both techniques is yet missing. PURPOSE: To evaluate the long-term results of aRCR and oRCR for full-thickness rotator cuff tears. STUDY DESIGN: Systematic review; Level of evidence, 4. METHODS: The systematic review followed the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) guidelines. The CENTRAL (Cochrane), MEDLINE (PubMed), and Embase databases were searched for studies that reported on long-term clinical and radiographic outcomes of full-thickness aRCR and oRCR with a minimum follow-up of 9 years. RESULTS: Eleven studies were included: 5 studies on aRCR and 6 studies on oRCR. Studies were based on 550 shoulders (539 patients) with a mean patient age of 56.3 years (range, 25-77). After a mean follow-up of 14.0 years (range, 9-20), the mean preoperative absolute Constant score (CS) and American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons (ASES) shoulder score were significantly improved postoperatively (CS, 44 to 78 points; ASES, 52% to 91%; both comparisons, P < .001). The retear rate was 41% (141 of 342 shoulders) without a significant difference between groups (aRCR, 43%; oRCR, 39%) (P = .364). A retear was associated with significantly reduced CS as compared with a healed repair (P = .004). No significant differences were found in postoperative functional scores, complications, and retear rates after failed cuff repairs between the arthroscopic and open/mini-open repair groups. CONCLUSION: Pooled analysis of arthroscopic and open rotator cuff repairs demonstrated sustained improvement in long-term shoulder scores and pain with a substantial retear rate in both groups, which was associated with inferior shoulder function. There were no significant differences in long-term functional outcomes, retear rates, and complications. Both surgical techniques may be used on the basis of factors such as patient or surgeon preference and cost. Further studies using a more robust randomized controlled trial or larger cohort design are recommended to ascertain whether one surgical repair technique is superior to the other. REGISTRATION: CRD42020180448 (PROSPERO).
引用
- Plachel F, Jo OI, Rüttershoff K, et al. A Systematic Review of Long-term Clinical and Radiological Outcomes of Arthroscopic and Open/Mini-open Rotator Cuff Repairs. Am J Sports Med. 2022. PMID: 35179393. doi:10.1177/03635465211073332
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。