旋转平台与固定平台胫骨衬垫的聚乙烯损伤及假体周围组织的尸检分析
对11例旋转平台(RP)和13例固定平台(FB)胫骨衬垫进行尸检取回分析,平均植入9.3年(1.7-19.6年),表面抛光是最常见损伤模式。RP平均损伤评分53.4高于FB的34.4,主要因背面损伤差异(RP 13.4 vs FB 1.4),而关节面损伤差异较小(RP 37.4 vs FB 30.0)。
要点
- 尸检取回的RP和FB衬垫损伤水平低、组织反应轻微,不同于翻修取回假体。
- RP平均损伤评分53.4高于FB的34.4,差异主要来自背面损伤(RP 13.4 vs FB 1.4)。
- 关节面平均损伤评分RP 37.4 vs FB 30.0,差异较小。
核心结论
- 尸检取回的衬垫损伤水平低、组织反应轻微,与翻修取回假体所报告的結果不同。
- RP与FB衬垫的比较趋势与取回分析一致,显示取回研究能捕捉TKA设计的性能差异。
研究设计与样本
- 对11例旋转平台(RP)和13例固定平台(FB)胫骨衬垫进行尸检取回分析,所有膝关节均行MRI扫描并从标准化区域取组织做组织学检查。
- 对聚乙烯衬垫的关节面、背面和PS柱后表面损伤模式和严重程度进行主观评分。
主要发现
- 平均植入时间9.3年(1.7-19.6年)。
- 表面抛光是最常见的聚乙烯损伤模式。
- RP平均损伤评分53.4高于FB的34.4,主要因背面损伤RP 13.4 vs FB 1.4。
- 关节面平均损伤评分RP 37.4 vs FB 30.0,差异较小。
- 轻度固有巨噬细胞反应见于8例(72.7%)RP和5例(45.5%)FB标本;聚乙烯颗粒见于7例(63.6%)RP和3例(27.7%)FB标本。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Mobile bearing designs are intended to reduce wear, but mixed results were reported from retrieval analyses. Postmortem evaluation (PM) provides the opportunity to assess polyethylene damage in successful implants. We compared damage patterns, MRI presentation, and histology between mobile-bearing and fixed tibial inserts retrieved postmortem and compared these results to our prior findings from implants retrieved at revision. METHODS: Eleven postmortem knees with rotating platform (RP) implants and 13 with fixed bearing (FB) implants were examined. All were MRI scanned, and tissue samples were collected from standardized regions for histology. Polyethylene inserts were subjectively scored to assess articular, backside, and PS post surfaces for damage modes and severity. RESULTS: Average duration of implantation was 9.3 years (1.7-19.6 years). Surface burnishing was the most common polyethylene damage mode. Average damage scores were higher for RP (53.4) compared to FB inserts (34.4) due to greater backside damage (13.4 for RP vs 1.4 for FB). A minimal difference in damage was observed on the articular surfaces (37.4 RP vs 30.0 FB). Mild innate macrophage reactions were seen in 8 (72.7%) RP and 5 (45.5%) FB specimens. Polyethylene particles were identified in 7 (63.6%) RP and 3 (27.7%) FB specimens. CONCLUSIONS: Postmortem inserts showed low damage levels and mild tissue reactions compared to those reported for implants removed at revision arthroplasty. Nonetheless, trends in comparing RP and FB inserts were consistent with those seen in retrieval analyses, demonstrating the usefulness of retrieval studies in capturing performance differences among TKA designs.
引用
- Chen JB, Baral EC, Hopper RH, et al. A Postmortem Analysis of Polyethylene Damage and Periprosthetic Tissue in Rotating Platform and Fixed Bearing Tibial Inserts. J Arthroplasty. 2022. PMID: 35183710. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2022.02.051
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。