PROMIS评分如何对应常见身体活动能力
该横断面研究汇总了2017至2020年间在三级学术机构就诊的37517例骨科患者的97852次PROMIS身体功能评估,识别出CAT最常用的28个条目(前4项占63%),并通过图形展示不同PROMIS评分段对应的患者活动能力水平,为临床解读PROMIS数值提供直观工具。
要点
- PROMIS CAT最常用的4个条目询问2小时体力劳动、庭院工作、家务和步行超过1英里的能力。
- 评分40分患者对上述活动最常报告「有些困难」,50分报告「很少」或「没有」困难,30分报告「不能做」。
- 研究提供图形化对照工具,将PROMIS数值评分转化为患者熟悉的活动能力描述。
核心结论
- 研究提供了将PROMIS数值评分与身体活动能力水平相联系的视觉化对照工具,使用临床相关且熟悉的术语。
- 未来研究可能探讨使用类似图形展示作为患者教育工具是否增强医患沟通并改善患者体验。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面研究,汇总2017年至2020年间在三级学术机构就诊的37517例骨科患者的97852次PROMIS身体功能评估进行描述性分析。
- PROMIS身体功能采用0至100分制,人群均值为50,标准差为10;本研究中平均PROMIS身体功能评分为41±9。
- 足踝人群基于锚定的最小临床重要差异为8至10分,脊柱人群为7至8分,手外科人群约为4分。
- 最有效且精确的PROMIS身体功能施测方式为计算机自适应测试(CAT)。
主要发现
- 165个条目的题库中有28个条目被PROMIS CAT软件频繁使用(即施测于超过0.1%的队列),前4个条目占所有条目的63%。
- 前4个条目询问患者进行2小时体力劳动、庭院工作、家务和步行超过1英里的能力。
- 评分40分的患者对体力劳动、庭院工作、家务和步行超过1英里最常报告「有些困难」,评分50分报告「很少」或「没有」困难,评分30分报告「不能做」。
关键数值与推荐
- PROMIS身体功能评分0至100分,人群均值50,标准差10。
- 足踝人群最小临床重要差异为8至10分,脊柱人群为7至8分,手外科人群约为4分。
- 本研究平均PROMIS身体功能评分为41±9。
- 评分分组为<18、20±2、25±2、30±2、35±2、40±2、45±2、50±2、55±2、60±2和>62。
临床怎么用
- 本研究的PROMIS评分的视觉化解释可能帮助PROMIS新使用者理解该工具,增强将其纳入实践的信心,并用作向患者解释其评分的咨询工具。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The Patient-Report Outcomes Measurement Information System (PROMIS) is increasingly used as a general-purpose tool for measuring orthopaedic surgery outcomes. This set of questionnaires is efficient, precise, and correlates well with specialty-specific measures, but impactful implementation of patient-specific data, especially at the point of care, remains a challenge. Although clinicians may have substantial experience with established patient-reported outcome measures in their fields, PROMIS is relatively new, and the real-life meaning of PROMIS numerical summary scores may be unknown to many orthopaedic surgeons. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: We aimed to (1) identify a small subset of important items in the PROMIS Physical Function (PF) item bank that are answered by many patients with orthopaedic conditions and (2) graphically display characteristic responses to these items across the physical function spectrum in order to translate PROMIS numerical scores into physical ability levels using clinically relevant, familiar terms. METHODS: In a cross-sectional study, 97,852 PROMIS PF assessments completed by 37,517 patients with orthopaedic conditions presenting to a tertiary-care academic institution were pooled and descriptively analyzed. Between 2017 and 2020, we evaluated 75,354 patients for outpatient orthopaedic care. Of these, 67% (50,578) were eligible for inclusion because they completed a PROMIS version 2.0 physical function assessment; 17% (12,720) were excluded because they lacked information in the database on individual item responses, and another < 1% (341) were excluded because the assessment standard error was greater than 0.32, leaving 50% of the patients (37,517) for analysis. The PROMIS PF is scored on a 0-point to 100-point scale, with a population mean of 50 and SD of 10. Anchor-based minimum clinically important differences have been found to be 8 to 10 points in a foot and ankle population, 7 to 8 points in a spine population, and approximately 4 points in a hand surgery population. The most efficient and precise means of administering the PROMIS PF is as a computerized adaptive test (CAT), whereby an algorithm intelligently tailors each follow-up question based on responses to previous questions, requiring only a few targeted questions to generate an accurate result. In this study, the mean PROMIS PF score was 41 ± 9. The questions most frequently used by the PROMIS CAT software were identified (defined in this study as any question administered to > 0.1% of the cohort). To understand the ability levels of patients based on their individual scores, patients were grouped into score categories: < 18, 20 ± 2, 25 ± 2, 30 ± 2, 35 ± 2, 40 ± 2, 45 ± 2, 50 ± 2, 55 ± 2, 60 ± 2, and > 62. For each score category, the relative frequency of each possible response (ranging from "cannot do" to "without any difficulty") was determined for each question. The distribution of responses given by each score group for each question was graphically displayed to generate an intuitive map linking PROMIS scores to patient ability levels (with ability levels represented by how patients responded to the PROMIS items). RESULTS: Twenty-eight items from the 165-question item bank were used frequently (that is, administered to more than 0.1% of the cohort) by the PROMIS CAT software. The top four items constituted 63% of all items. These top four items asked about the patient's ability to perform 2 hours of physical labor, yard work, household chores, and walking more than 1 mile. Graphical displays of responses to the top 28 and top four items revealed how PROMIS scores correspond to patient ability levels. Patients with a score of 40 most frequently responded that they experienced "some difficulty" with physical labor, yard work, household chores, and walking more than 1 mile, compared with "little" or "no" difficulty for patients with a score of 50 and "cannot do" for patients with a score of 30. CONCLUSION: We provided a visual key linking PROMIS numerical scores to physical ability levels using clinically relevant, familiar terms. Future studies might investigate whether using similar graphical displays as a patient education tool enhances patient-provider communication and improves the patient experience. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: The visual explanation of PROMIS scores provided by this study may help new users of the PROMIS understand the instrument, feel empowered to incorporate it into their practices, and use it as a tool for counseling patients about their scores.
引用
- Brodke DJ, Zhang C, Shaw JD, et al. How Do PROMIS Scores Correspond to Common Physical Abilities? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2021. PMID: 34855330. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000002046
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。