文献速递关节外科

55岁以下患者初次膝关节置换术的全因生存率与功能结局如何?一项系统综述

What Are the All-Cause Survivorship Rates and Functional Outcomes in Patients Younger Than 55 Years Undergoing Primary Knee Arthroplasty? A Systematic Review.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2022-01-01

该系统综述纳入21项全膝关节置换术(TKA)研究和5项单髁膝关节置换术(UKA)研究,共3095例TKA膝和482例UKA膝,评估55岁及以下患者初次膝关节置换术后的全因生存率、翻修原因、患者报告结局及恢复体育活动与运动情况。TKA的5至10年全因生存率为90%至98%,10至20年为84%至99%(95%CI 93%至98%);UKA的10年生存率为90%,19年为75%。尽管多数生存率高于90%且患者报告结局良好至优秀,但部分研究报告长期生存率70%至85%及一般水平的结局评分。

要点

  • TKA的5至10年全因生存率为90%至98%,10至20年为84%至99%(95%CI 93%至98%)。
  • UKA最大Kaplan-Meier估计的10年生存率为90%,19年为75%。
  • TKA常见翻修原因为聚乙烯磨损/松动、无菌性胫骨松动和感染;UKA为膝痛、无菌性松动、膝骨关节炎进展和聚乙烯磨损/松动。

核心结论

  • TKA全因生存率常高于90%且患者报告结局评分总体良好至优秀,但部分研究报告长期生存率70%至85%及一般水平的患者报告结局评分,术前咨询时应考虑这些因素。
  • 作者认为,为减少55岁以下TKA患者翻修频率,临床医生应警惕聚乙烯磨损/松动、无菌性胫骨松动和感染;膝痛和膝骨关节炎进展也是55岁以下UKA患者的常见翻修原因。
  • 作者建议进一步研究应单独纳入年轻膝关节置换患者,并在评估术后活动水平时考虑术前体育活动和运动参与情况。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统综述,全面检索PubMed、Medline、SportDiscus和CINAHL从建库至2021年3月,纳入报告55岁及以下患者初次膝关节置换术后结局且至少随访1年的原创研究。
  • 共纳入21项TKA研究和5项UKA研究,含3095例TKA膝和482例UKA膝。
  • 采用MINORS评分评估病例系列和比较研究质量,采用Cochrane偏倚风险工具和Jadad量表评估随机研究。
  • 排除未发表材料、非英文出版物及主要诊断为类风湿关节炎的研究。
  • 证据等级为IV级,治疗性研究。

主要发现

  • TKA的Kaplan-Meier全因生存率在5至10年随访为90%至98%,在10至20年随访为84%至99%(95%CI 93%至98%)。
  • UKA最大Kaplan-Meier生存率估计在10年为90%,在19年为75%。
  • TKA患者Knee Society评分在5至10年随访为85至98,在10至20年随访为86至97;Knee Society功能评分在5至10年随访为70至95,在10至20年随访为79至86。
  • TKA常见翻修原因为聚乙烯磨损/松动、无菌性胫骨松动和感染;UKA常见翻修原因为膝痛、无菌性松动、膝骨关节炎进展和聚乙烯磨损/松动。
  • 多数55岁以下患者膝关节置换术后体育活动水平较术前改善,但恢复体育活动和运动的报告方式不一。

关键数值与推荐

  • Knee Society和Knee Society功能评分范围0至100分,85至100分为优秀,低于60分为差;最小临床重要差异(MCID)分别为7.2和9.7。
  • WOMAC评分MCID为10。
  • Tegner评分无报告的膝关节置换术MCID。
  • 全因生存率和翻修原因在17项研究中报告;Knee Society评分在19项研究中报告,Knee Society功能评分在18项研究中报告;WOMAC评分和Tegner评分各在4项研究中报告;恢复体育活动和恢复运动分析在7项研究中进行。

临床怎么用

  • 术前咨询55岁及以下膝关节置换患者时,应将部分研究报告的长期生存率70%至85%及一般水平的患者报告结局评分纳入考虑。
  • 作者认为,为减少55岁以下TKA患者翻修频率,临床医生应警惕聚乙烯磨损/松动、无菌性胫骨松动和感染。
  • 作者指出,膝痛和膝骨关节炎进展也是55岁以下UKA患者的常见翻修原因。

局限性

  • 本报告无法控制外科医生手术量,既往研究表明手术量增加与并发症减少相关。
  • 纳入的研究不同程度受选择偏倚、转移偏倚和评估偏倚影响,使本综述结果很可能代表最佳情况估计。
  • 作者建议进一步研究应单独纳入年轻膝关节置换患者,并在评估术后活动水平时考虑术前体育活动和运动参与情况。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Approximately one-fourth of TKAs will be performed in patients 55 years or younger within the next decade. Postoperative outcomes for younger patients who had a knee arthroplasty were systematically reviewed in 2011; however, numerous studies evaluating young patients who had both a TKA and unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) have been reported in the past decade. Therefore, to better counsel this growing population of young patients undergoing knee arthroplasty, an updated understanding of their expected postoperative outcomes is warranted. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: In this systematic review, we evaluated (1) all-cause survivorship, (2) reasons for revision, (3) patient-reported outcomes, and (4) return to physical activity and sport in patients 55 years or younger undergoing primary TKA or UKA. METHODS: A comprehensive search of PubMed, Medline, SportDiscus, and CINAHL was performed to identify all original studies evaluating outcomes after primary knee arthroplasty for young patients (55 years of age or younger) from inception until March 2021. The following keywords were used: knee, arthroplasty, replacement, pain, function, revision, survivorship, sport, physical activity, and return to play. Only original research studies that were related to knee arthroplasty and reported postoperative outcomes with a minimum 1-year follow-up for patients 55 years or younger were included. Unpublished materials, publications not available in English, and studies with a primary diagnosis of rheumatoid arthritis were excluded. The Methodological Index for Non-Randomized Studies (MINORS) score was used to evaluate the study quality of case series and comparative studies, while the Cochrane Risk of Bias tool and the Jadad scale were used for randomized studies. The primary outcomes of interest for this study were all-cause survivorship rate, reasons for all-cause revision, Knee Society and Knee Society Function scores (minimum clinically important difference [MCID] 7.2 and 9.7, respectively), WOMAC scores (MCID 10), Tegner scores (no reported MCID for knee arthroplasty), and return to physical activity or sport. Knee Society and Knee Society Function scores range from 0 to 100, with scores from 85 to 100 considered excellent and below 60 representing poor outcomes. All-cause survivorship rate and reasons for revision were both reported in 17 total studies. Knee Society scores were presented in 19 and Knee Society Function scores were reported in 18 included studies. WOMAC scores and Tegner scores were each found in four included studies, and return to physical activity and return to sport analyses were performed in seven studies. Overall, 21 TKA studies and five UKA studies were included in this analysis, featuring 3095 TKA knees and 482 UKA knees. RESULTS: Kaplan-Meier estimates of all-cause survivorship ranged from 90% to 98% at 5 to 10 years of follow-up after TKA and from 84% to 99% (95% CI 93% to 98%) at 10 years to 20 years post-TKA. All-cause UKA survivorship was 90% at 10 years and 75% at 19 years in the largest Kaplan-Meier estimate of survivorship for patients younger than 55 who underwent UKA. Common reasons for revision in TKA patients were polyethylene wear/loosening, aseptic tibial loosening, and infection, and in UKA patients the common reasons for revision were knee pain, aseptic loosening, progression of knee osteoarthritis, and polyethylene wear/loosening. Knee Society scores ranged from 85 to 98 for 5-year to 10-year follow-up and ranged from 86 to 97 at 10-year to 20-year follow-up in TKA patients. Knee Society Function scores ranged from 70 to 95 for 5-year to 10-year follow-up and ranged from 79 to 86 at 10-year to 20-year follow-up. Return to physical activity and sport was reported variably; however, most patients younger than 55 have improved physical activity levels after knee arthroplasty relative to preoperative levels. CONCLUSION: Although all-cause survivorship rates were frequently above 90% and patient-reported outcome scores were generally in the good to excellent range, several studies reported long-term survivorship rates from 70% to 85% and fair patient-reported outcome scores, which must be factored into any preoperative counseling with patients. We could not control for surgeon volume in this report, and prior research suggests that increasing volume is associated with less frequent complications; in addition, the studies we included were variably affected by selection bias, transfer bias, and assessment bias, which makes it likely that the findings of our review represent best-case estimates. To limit the frequency of revision in patients younger than 55 years undergoing TKA, clinicians should be cautious of polyethylene wear/loosening, aseptic tibial loosening, and infection, while knee pain and progression of knee osteoarthritis are also common reasons for revision in patients younger than 55 undergoing UKA. Further research should isolate younger knee arthroplasty patients and evaluate postoperative activity levels while accounting for preoperative physical activity and sport participation. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level IV, therapeutic study.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Paul RW, Osman A, Clements A, et al. What Are the All-Cause Survivorship Rates and Functional Outcomes in Patients Younger Than 55 Years Undergoing Primary Knee Arthroplasty? A Systematic Review. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2022. PMID: 34846307. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000002023

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。