自动滑膜细胞计数对全髋关节置换翻修术不同无菌性病因及假体周围病变的影响是什么
该回顾性研究分析了702例因无菌性原因行全髋翻修患者的术前滑膜液自动细胞计数,发现聚乙烯磨损者平均白细胞计数最高(3817±3711 cells/μL),60%超过2018年ICM阈值3000 cells/μL;而多形核百分比受影响较小,各无菌病因间无差异。作者认为自动分析仪下白细胞计数单独升高不应强烈提示假体周围关节感染。
要点
- 聚乙烯磨损者平均滑膜白细胞计数为3817±3711 cells/μL,60%(25/42)超过ICM 3000 cells/μL阈值。
- 磨损性滑膜炎平均白细胞计数4464±3620 cells/μL,60%(50/83)超过ICM阈值。
- 金属沉着病平均多形核百分比最高(45%±25%),21%(10/47)超过ICM 70%阈值。
核心结论
- 自动细胞计数下,因无菌性原因行全髋翻修的各指征间白细胞计数差异很大,高比例患者白细胞计数超过常用阈值3000 cells/μL。
- 多形核百分比在几种常见无菌翻修指征中受影响较小,使其在自动分析仪解读抽吸结果时更可靠。
- 基于观察到的数据分布,作者建议可考虑在聚乙烯磨损、金属对金属 bearing 表面或疑似金属沉着病患者中采用手工计数技术。
- 作者认为,在聚乙烯磨损背景下自动分析仪观察到白细胞计数单独升高不应被强烈提示为假体周围关节感染,因为该发现在无感染患者中非常常见。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,纳入2015年1月至2017年12月在一家三级转诊关节置换中心因无菌性原因行全髋翻修患者的术前滑膜液细胞计数分析。
- 预设排除后(主要排除15%[197/1306]散在缺失数据和12%[155/1306]抽吸获得的滑膜液不足),最终分析702例因无菌性原因行全髋翻修的患者。
- 据作者所知,平均随访46±11个月时无患者因假体周围关节感染再翻修,这倾向于确认这些髋关节确实无感染。
- 细胞计数分析使用自动分析仪;临床发现、术前X线片和手术报告(经可用组织学结果证实)用于确立诊断。
- 证据等级:III级,诊断性研究。
主要发现
- 整个队列平均白细胞计数为2120±2395 cells/μL,平均多形核百分比为36%±22%。
- 与无菌性松动和复发性脱位相比,聚乙烯磨损的平均白细胞计数最高(3817±3711 cells/μL;p<0.001)。
- 在研究的假体周围病变中,磨损性滑膜炎的平均白细胞计数最高(4464±3620 cells/μL;p<0.001)。
- 考虑ICM阈值,聚乙烯磨损在无菌翻修指征中白细胞计数超过3000 cells/μL的比例最高(60%[25/42];p<0.001);磨损性滑膜炎在假体周围病变中超过ICM阈值的比例最高(60%[50/83];p<0.001)。
- 无菌性病因的平均多形核百分比在28%至44%之间,无差异(p=0.12);金属沉着病在假体周围病变中平均多形核百分比最高(45%±25%;p=0.007)。
关键数值与推荐
- 2018年国际共识会议(ICM)推荐阈值:白细胞计数3000 cells/μL,多形核百分比70%。
- 聚乙烯磨损:平均白细胞计数3817±3711 cells/μL,60%(25/42)超过3000 cells/μL。
- 磨损性滑膜炎:平均白细胞计数4464±3620 cells/μL,60%(50/83)超过3000 cells/μL。
- 金属沉着病:平均多形核百分比45%±25%,21%(10/47)超过70%;磨损性滑膜炎6%(5/83)超过70%;骨溶解3%(1/33)超过70%。
- 整个队列:平均白细胞计数2120±2395 cells/μL,平均多形核百分比36%±22%。
临床怎么用
- 作者建议,基于观察到的数据分布,可考虑在聚乙烯磨损、金属对金属 bearing 表面或疑似金属沉着病患者中采用手工计数技术。
- 作者认为,在聚乙烯磨损背景下自动分析仪观察到白细胞计数单独升高不应被强烈提示为假体周围关节感染。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Studies have suggested that automated synovial cell counting may overestimate the white blood cell (WBC) count, resulting in false positive tests when evaluating patients for the possibility of periprosthetic joint infection (PJI) after THA. However, associations between WBC counts high enough to mimic PJI in patients whose arthroplasties are not infected but rather are experiencing a variety of aseptic problems-including but not limited to metallosis, polyethylene wear, and recurrent dislocation-have not, to our knowledge, been adequately addressed. In addition, there is a lack of analyses about the polymorphonuclear percentage (PMN%) when assessed by automated analyzers in this context. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: In the context of different indications for aseptic revision and different periprosthetic hip pathologic findings, we asked: (1) What were the synovial WBC count levels, and what proportion of values were above the 2018 International Consensus Meeting (ICM) cutoff (3000 cells/μL)? (2) What were the synovial PMN% levels, and what proportion of values were above the 2018 ICM (70%)? METHODS: We retrospectively studied the preoperative cell count analyses of synovial fluid in patients who underwent revision THA for aseptic reasons at our tertiary referral arthroplasty center between January 2015 and December 2017. We considered all revisions performed on patients during that time potentially eligible, and after prespecified exclusions were applied (exclusions mainly included 15% [197 of 1306] sporadic missing data and 12% [155 of 1306] insufficient synovial fluid obtained in the aspirate), a total of 702 patients undergoing revision THA for aseptic reasons remained for the final analysis. As far as we know, no patients underwent re-revision for PJI at a mean follow-up of 46 ± 11 months, which tends to confirm our impression that indeed these hips did not have PJI. Cell count analyses were conducted using an automated analyzer. Clinical findings, preoperative radiographs, and surgical reports--confirmed by available histologic results--were used to establish diagnoses. We evaluated these hips considering the recommendations of the 2018 ICM (WBC count of 3000 cells/μL and PMN% of 70%) to see what proportion of them would have been characterized as likely having PJI on basis of those cutoff values. The mean WBC count for the entire cohort was 2120 ± 2395 cells/μL. The mean PMN% for the entire cohort was 36% ± 22%. RESULTS: Compared with aseptic loosening and recurrent dislocation, polyethylene wear had the highest mean WBC count (3817 ± 3711 cells/μL; p < 0.001). Of the investigated periprosthetic conditions, wear-induced synovitis had the highest value (4464 ± 3620 cells/μL; p < 0.001). Considering the ICM threshold, polyethylene wear showed the highest proportion of WBC counts above 3000 cells/μL among the indications for aseptic revision (60% [25 of 42]; p < 0.001). Of the periprosthetic conditions, wear-induced synovitis showed the highest proportion beyond the ICM cutoff (60% [50 of 83]; p < 0.001). The mean PMN% for aseptic causes ranged between 28% and 44% without differences among them (p = 0.12). Patients with metallosis had the highest mean PMN% of the periprosthetic conditions investigated (45% ± 25%; p = 0.007). Regarding the ICM threshold, metallosis resulted in the largest proportion of patients with a PMN% above 70% (21% [10 of 47]; p = 0.003), and that for wear-induced synovitis was 6% (5 of 83; p = 0.42) and for osteolysis was 3% (1 of 33; p = 0.51). There were no differences among aseptic loosening, recurrent dislocation, and polyethylene wear in terms of the proportion above 70% among the aseptic revision causes. CONCLUSION: Using automated cell counting, we found that WBC counts differ widely across indications for aseptic revision THA, and a high proportion of patients who underwent revision THA for aseptic reasons had WBC counts above the commonly used threshold of 3000 cells/μL. However, the PMN% was much less affected in several common indications for aseptic revision THA, making this measure more reliable for interpreting aspiration results using an automated analyzer. Based on the data distributions we observed, manual counting techniques might be considered in particular among patients with polyethylene wear, metal-on-metal bearing surfaces, or suspected metallosis. However, an elevated WBC count alone, observed using an automated analyzer in the context of polyethylene wear, should not be considered to be strongly suggestive of PJI, since that finding occurred so commonly among patients without infection. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, diagnostic study.
引用
- Abdelaziz H, Aljawabra A, Rossmann M, et al. What Is the Impact of Automated Synovial Cell Counting on Different Aseptic Causes and Periprosthetic Conditions Associated With Revision THA? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2021. PMID: 34851871. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000002063
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。