文献速递关节外科

假设将翻修全髋与全膝置换术集中化是否会通过增加患者出行距离或时间而加剧现有就医可及性的地理或人口学差异?一项大型数据库研究

Does Hypothetical Centralization of Revision THA and TKA Exacerbate Existing Geographic or Demographic Disparities in Access to Care by Increased Patient Travel Distances or Times? A Large-database Study.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2021-12-21

该研究基于纽约州行政数据库2008至2016年37147例翻修全关节置换术住院患者,模拟三种将患者从低容量医院转至最近高容量医院的集中化政策。结果显示多数患者出行负担未增加,但西班牙裔、低收入县和农村县患者更可能受影响,非白人患者受影响可能性较低。

要点

  • 从最低25%容量医院转出仅1例住院受出行距离或时间增加影响。
  • 从最低50%容量医院转出时9%患者被转运,仅1%受影响。
  • 西班牙裔、低收入县和农村县患者转运后更可能出行负担增加。

核心结论

  • 在纽约州将翻修全关节置换术集中到高容量机构似乎未增加多数患者的出行负担,但集中化政策需精心设计以尽量减少对已面临就医可及性挑战人群的不成比例影响。
  • 作者认为进一步研究应考察建立翻修全关节置换术卓越中心指定的可行性、低容量机构采纳最佳实践以改善翻修全关节置换术照护的效果,以及远程医疗等扩展照护技术在改善就医可及性以减少出行距离对受影响人群影响方面的潜在作用。

研究设计与样本

  • 利用纽约州全州规划与研究合作系统行政数据库,采用Medicare Severity Diagnosis Related Groups 466-468识别2008至2016年37147例接受翻修全关节置换术的住院患者。
  • 排除患者标识缺失或州外标识的翻修(37147例中3474例)以及与关闭或合并机构相关的翻修(37147例中180例)。
  • 根据翻修全关节置换术平均容量将医院按四分位数分组,评估三种政策情景:将最低25%容量医院的患者、最低50%容量医院的患者、最低75%容量医院的患者转至按距离最近的更高容量机构。
  • 政策实施后变更医院且出行超过60英里或超过60分钟(考虑平均交通模式)的患者被视为受到不利影响。
  • 次要结局为三种集中化政策对低收入、非白人、农村 versus 城市县以及西班牙裔的影响。

主要发现

  • 从最低25%容量医院转出仅导致1例住院受出行距离和出行时间增加影响。
  • 从最低50%容量医院转出导致9%(33493例中3050例)患者被转运,仅1%(33493例中312例)患者受出行距离或出行时间增加影响。
  • 从最低75%容量医院转出导致28%(33493例中9323例)患者被转运,2%(33493例中814例)患者受出行距离或出行时间增加影响。
  • 非白人患者较白人患者在从最低50%容量医院转出后(OR 0.31 [95% CI 0.15至0.65];p=0.002)或从最低75%容量医院转出后(OR 0.10 [95% CI 0.07至0.15];p<0.001)更不可能遇到出行距离或时间增加。
  • 西班牙裔患者较非西班牙裔患者在从最低50%容量医院转出后(OR 12.3 [95% CI 5.04至30.2];p<0.001)和从最低75%容量医院转出后(OR 3.24 [95% CI 2.24至4.68];p<0.001)更可能经历出行距离或时间增加。

关键数值与推荐

  • 从最低25%容量医院转出:仅1例住院受出行距离和出行时间增加影响。
  • 从最低50%容量医院转出:9%(33493例中3050例)患者被转运,1%(33493例中312例)患者受出行距离或时间增加影响。
  • 从最低75%容量医院转出:28%(33493例中9323例)患者被转运,2%(33493例中814例)患者受出行距离或时间增加影响。
  • 非白人较白人:从最低50%容量医院转出OR 0.31(95% CI 0.15至0.65;p=0.002);从最低75%容量医院转出OR 0.10(95% CI 0.07至0.15;p<0.001)。
  • 西班牙裔较非西班牙裔:从最低50%容量医院转出OR 12.3(95% CI 5.04至30.2;p<0.001);从最低75%容量医院转出OR 3.24(95% CI 2.24至4.68;p<0.001)。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 证据等级为III级,预后性研究。
  • 作者认为集中化翻修全关节置换术照护的政策需精心设计以尽量减少对已面临就医可及性挑战人群的不成比例影响。
  • 作者认为进一步研究应考察建立翻修全关节置换术卓越中心指定的可行性、低容量机构采纳最佳实践以改善翻修全关节置换术照护的效果,以及远程医疗等扩展照护技术在改善就医可及性以减少出行距离对受影响人群影响方面的潜在作用。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Higher hospital volume is associated with lower rates of adverse outcomes after revision total joint arthroplasty (TJA). Centralizing revision TJA care to higher-volume hospitals might reduce early complication and readmission rates after revision TJA; however, the effect of centralizing revision TJA care on patient populations who are more likely to experience challenges with access to care is unknown. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) Does a hypothetical policy of transferring patients undergoing revision TJA from lower-to higher-volume hospitals increase patient travel distance and time? (2) Does a hypothetical policy of transferring patients undergoing revision TJA from lower- to higher-volume hospitals disproportionately affect travel distance or time in low income, rural, or racial/ethnic minority populations? METHODS: Using the Medicare Severity Diagnosis Related Groups 466-468, we identified 37,147 patients with inpatient stays undergoing revision TJA from 2008 to 2016 in the Statewide Planning and Research Cooperative System administrative database for New York State. Revisions with missing or out-of-state patient identifiers (3474 of 37,147) or those associated with closed or merged facilities (180 of 37,147) were excluded. We chose this database for our study because of relative advantages to other available databases: comprehensive catchment of all surgical procedures in New York State, regardless of payer; each patient can be followed across episodes of care and hospitals in New York State; and New York State has an excellent cross-section of hospital types for TJA, including rural and urban hospitals, critical access hospitals, and some of the highest-volume centers for TJA in the United States. We divided hospitals into quartiles based on the mean revision TJA volume. Overall, 80% (118 of 147) of hospitals were not for profit, 18% (26 of 147) were government owned, 78% (115 of 147) were located in urban areas, and 48% (70 of 147) had fewer than 200 beds. The mean patient age was 66 years old, 59% (19,888 of 33,493) of patients were females, 79% (26,376 of 33,493) were white, 82% (27,410 of 33,493) were elective admissions, and 56% (18,656 of 33,493) of admissions were from government insurance. Three policy scenarios were evaluated: transferring patients from the lowest 25% by volume hospitals, transferring patients in the lowest 50% by volume hospitals, and transferring patients in the lowest 75% by volume hospitals to the nearest higher-volume institution by distance. Patients who changed hospitals and travelled more than 60 miles or longer than 60 minutes with consideration for average traffic patterns after the policy was enacted were considered adversely affected. The secondary outcome of interest was the impact of the three centralization policies, as defined above, on lower-income, nonwhite, rural versus urban counties, and Hispanic ethnicity. RESULTS: Transferring patients from the lowest 25% by volume hospitals resulted in only one patient stay that was affected by an increase in travel distance and travel time. Transferring patients from the lowest 50% by volume hospitals resulted in 9% (3050 of 33,493) of patients being transferred, with only 1% (312 of 33,493) of patients affected by either an increased travel distance or travel time. Transferring patients from the lowest 75% by volume hospitals resulted in 28% (9323 of 33,493) of patients being transferred, with 2% (814 of 33,493) of patients affected by either an increased travel distance or travel time. Nonwhite patients were less likely to encounter an increased travel distance or time after being transferred from the lowest 50% by volume hospitals (odds ratio 0.31 [95% CI 0.15 to 0.65]; p = 0.002) or being transferred from the lowest 75% by volume hospitals (OR 0.10 [95% CI 0.07 to 0.15]; p < 0.001) than white patients were. Hispanic patients were more likely to experience increased travel distance or time after being transferred from the lowest 50% by volume hospitals (OR 12.3 [95% CI 5.04 to 30.2]; p < 0.001) and being transferred from the lowest 75% by volume hospitals (OR 3.24 [95% CI 2.24 to 4.68]; p < 0.001) than non-Hispanic patients were. Patients from a county with a lower median income were more likely to experience increased travel distances or time after being transferred from the lowest 50% by volume hospitals (OR 69.5 [95% CI 17.0 to 283]; p < 0.001) and being transferred from the lowest 75% by volume hospitals (OR 3.86 [95% CI 3.21 to 4.64]; p < 0.001) than patients from counties with a higher median income. Patients from rural counties were more likely to be affected after being transferred from the lowest 50% by volume hospitals (OR 98 [95% CI 49.6 to 192.2]; p < 0.001) and being transferred from the lowest 75% by volume hospitals (OR 11.7 [95% CI 9.89 to 14.0]; p < 0.001) than patients from urban counties. CONCLUSION: Although centralizing revision TJA care to higher-volume institutions in New York State did not appear to increase the travel burden for most patients, policies that centralize revision TJA care will need to be carefully designed to minimize the disproportionate impact on patient populations that already face challenges with access to healthcare. Further studies should examine the feasibility of establishing centers of excellence designations for revision TJA, the effect of best practices adoption by lower volume institutions to improve revision TJA care, and the potential role of care-extending technology such as telemedicine to improve access to care to reduce the effects of travel distances on affected patient populations. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, prognostic study.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Ramirez G, Myers TG, Thirukumaran CP, et al. Does Hypothetical Centralization of Revision THA and TKA Exacerbate Existing Geographic or Demographic Disparities in Access to Care by Increased Patient Travel Distances or Times? A Large-database Study. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2021. PMID: 34870619. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000002072

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。