高手术量外科医生机器人辅助与手动全膝关节置换术的成本与质量指标比较
本研究回顾性匹配比较了6名高手术量外科医生完成的2392例手动全膝关节置换术(MTKA)与2392例机器人辅助全膝关节置换术(RTKA)。RTKA手术时间更长、总直接成本更高(11615美元 vs 8674美元,P < .0001),家庭医疗使用更多(38% vs 29%),但30天再入院率更低(1.2% vs 4.9%),90天并发症无显著差异。
要点
- RTKA总直接成本高于MTKA(11615美元 vs 8674美元,P < .0001)。
- RTKA手术时间更长(139分钟 vs 107分钟,P < .0001)。
- RTKA后30天再入院率更低(1.2% vs 4.9%),90天并发症无显著差异。
核心结论
- 对于经验丰富的外科医生,RTKA是比MTKA更长且成本更高的手术,住院时间或并发症无临床显著差异。
- RTKA后家庭医疗使用更频繁,但RTKA后再入院更少。
- 需要更长期随访和功能结局研究来确定RTKA更高的成本是否被更低的翻修率和/或更好的功能结果所抵消。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性审查2017年1月1日至2019年12月31日期间由6名高手术量外科医生完成的全部MTKA和RTKA,每个队列各6名。
- 队列经倾向评分匹配,一对一匹配后纳入2392例MTKA和2392例RTKA。
- 研究指标包括手术时间、住院时间、总直接成本、90天并发症、急性后期服务利用和30天再入院。
主要发现
- RTKA的入室/出室手术时间(139分钟)长于MTKA(107分钟),P < .0001。
- RTKA的手术时间(78分钟)长于MTKA(70分钟),P < .0001。
- MTKA与RTKA的中位住院时间相等(33小时)。
- RTKA每例总成本(11615美元)高于MTKA(8674美元),P < .0001。
- RTKA后家庭医疗使用率(38%)高于MTKA(29%),P < .0001;90天并发症率无显著差异;30天再入院率MTKA(4.9%)高于RTKA(1.2%),P < .0001。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 需要更长期随访和功能结局研究来确定RTKA更高的成本是否被更低的翻修率和/或更好的功能结果所抵消。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Robotic-assisted total knee arthroplasty (RTKA) was introduced to improve surgical accuracy and patient outcomes. However, RTKA may also increase operating time and add cost to TKA. This study sought to compare the differences in cost and quality measures between manual TKA (MTKA) and RTKA METHODS: All MTKAs and RTKAs performed between January 1, 2017 and December 31, 2019, by 6 high volume surgeons in each cohort, were retrospectively reviewed. Cohorts were propensity score matched. Operative time, length of stay (LOS), total direct cost, 90-day complications, utilization of postacute services, and 30-day readmissions were studied. RESULTS: After one-to-one matching, 2392 MTKAs and 2392 RTKAs were studied. In-room/out-of-room operating time was longer for RTKA (139 minutes) than for MTKA (107 minutes) P < .0001, as was procedure time (RTKA 78 minutes; MTKA 70 minutes), P < .0001. Median LOS was equal for MTKA and RTKA (33 hours). Total cost per case was greater for RTKA ($11,615) than MTKA ($8674), P < .0001. Home health care was utilized more frequently after RTKA (38%) than MTKA (29%), P < .0001. There was no significant difference in 90-day complication rates. Thirty-day readmissions occurred more often after MTKA (4.9%) than RTKA (1.2%), P < .0001. CONCLUSION: RTKA was a longer and costlier procedure than MTKA for experienced surgeons, without clinically significant differences in LOS or complications. Home health care was utilized more often after RTKA, but fewer readmissions occurred after RTKA. Longer term follow-up and functional outcome studies are required to determine if the greater cost of RTKA is offset by lower revision rates and/or improved functional results.
引用
- Tompkins GS, Sypher KS, Li HF, et al. Robotic Versus Manual Total Knee Arthroplasty in High Volume Surgeons: A Comparison of Cost and Quality Metrics. J Arthroplasty. 2021. PMID: 34952162. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2021.12.018
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。